############################################################################## FullChemBenchmark budgets for Jul2016 NOTES: - When using the non-local mixing scheme (default), 'Mixing' includes emissions and dry deposition applied below the PBL. 'EmisDryDep' therefore only captures fluxes above the PBL. - When using full mixing, 'Mixing' and 'EmisDryDep' are fully separated. - Budgets are calculated as the sum of [kg/s] tendencies - Strat budget is calculated as Full minus Trop - ACCUMULATION is calculated as sum of all other operations ############################################################################## ACET budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ACET +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1528.13738 | -1554.30328 | -26.16590 | 1.71227 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -25.15750 | | EmisDryDep | 0.07872 | 0.08044 | 0.00172 | 2.18073 | | Mixing | 2170.43778 | 2234.47089 | 64.03312 | 2.95024 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ACET +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1501.31023 | -1529.68126 | -28.37103 | 1.88975 | | Convection | -0.01286 | -0.00972 | 0.00314 | -24.38115 | | EmisDryDep | 0.07664 | 0.07828 | 0.00165 | 2.14978 | | Mixing | 2169.74006 | 2233.43789 | 63.69783 | 2.93574 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ACET +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 408.07510 | 369.70429 | -38.37081 | -9.40288 | | Convection | -335.36665 | -364.71785 | -29.35120 | 8.75197 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -113.71801 | | Mixing | 1411.84016 | 1573.73623 | 161.89607 | 11.46703 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ACET +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -26.82716 | -24.62202 | 2.20514 | -8.21979 | | Convection | 0.01286 | 0.00972 | -0.00314 | -24.38115 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00208 | 0.00215 | 0.00007 | 3.31887 | | Mixing | 0.69772 | 1.03301 | 0.33529 | 48.05530 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ ACTA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ACTA +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2142.90375 | 2192.75266 | 49.84891 | 2.32623 | | Convection | -206.11699 | -226.37981 | -20.26282 | 9.83074 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 176.57076 | | Mixing | -729.77801 | -709.57125 | 20.20677 | -2.76889 | | WetDep | -893.25703 | -915.36314 | -22.10612 | 2.47478 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ACTA +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2143.78440 | 2193.43631 | 49.65192 | 2.31609 | | Convection | -206.11783 | -226.38069 | -20.26286 | 9.83072 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 227.16167 | | Mixing | -729.79935 | -709.61130 | 20.18805 | -2.76625 | | WetDep | -893.25703 | -915.36314 | -22.10612 | 2.47478 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ACTA +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1145.77993 | 1140.04468 | -5.73525 | -0.50055 | | Convection | 30.49922 | 35.02387 | 4.52465 | 14.83529 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -108.96624 | | Mixing | -690.36659 | -676.15034 | 14.21625 | -2.05923 | | WetDep | -181.40197 | -161.57329 | 19.82869 | -10.93080 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ACTA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.88065 | -0.68366 | 0.19699 | -22.36867 | | Convection | 0.00084 | 0.00088 | 0.00004 | 4.87805 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.42125 | | Mixing | 0.02133 | 0.04005 | 0.01872 | 87.73946 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ AERI budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : AERI +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 35.84366 | 40.55193 | 4.70827 | 13.13558 | | Convection | -15.12082 | -16.53570 | -1.41488 | 9.35714 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -5.94700 | | Mixing | -5.09516 | -5.44009 | -0.34494 | 6.76986 | | WetDep | -15.87613 | -17.96459 | -2.08847 | 13.15476 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : AERI +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 35.71144 | 40.42477 | 4.71332 | 13.19835 | | Convection | -15.12081 | -16.53568 | -1.41487 | 9.35713 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -7.50945 | | Mixing | -5.09381 | -5.43870 | -0.34489 | 6.77083 | | WetDep | -15.87572 | -17.96434 | -2.08863 | 13.15611 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : AERI +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 21.08044 | 23.07868 | 1.99824 | 9.47913 | | Convection | -4.91428 | -5.04511 | -0.13083 | 2.66219 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.01786 | | Mixing | -10.50748 | -11.16904 | -0.66156 | 6.29607 | | WetDep | -2.18968 | -2.45897 | -0.26929 | 12.29799 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : AERI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.13222 | 0.12717 | -0.00505 | -3.81747 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00002 | -0.00000 | 33.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.35184 | | Mixing | -0.00135 | -0.00139 | -0.00004 | 3.10206 | | WetDep | -0.00041 | -0.00025 | 0.00016 | -39.06250 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ALD2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ALD2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -3198.30026 | -3411.74605 | -213.44579 | 6.67373 | | Convection | -0.02139 | -0.03568 | -0.01430 | 66.84279 | | EmisDryDep | 0.71943 | 0.71945 | 0.00002 | 0.00317 | | Mixing | 3227.64300 | 3449.34501 | 221.70201 | 6.86885 | | WetDep | -41.80355 | -48.82163 | -7.01808 | 16.78825 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ALD2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -3198.10409 | -3411.59173 | -213.48764 | 6.67544 | | Convection | -0.02272 | -0.03710 | -0.01438 | 63.30204 | | EmisDryDep | 0.69533 | 0.69455 | -0.00078 | -0.11265 | | Mixing | 3227.63613 | 3449.33487 | 221.69874 | 6.86876 | | WetDep | -41.80355 | -48.82163 | -7.01808 | 16.78825 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ALD2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1927.81829 | -1999.77479 | -71.95650 | 3.73254 | | Convection | -408.77241 | -426.77044 | -17.99803 | 4.40295 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -100.94207 | | Mixing | 2544.85632 | 2750.30974 | 205.45342 | 8.07328 | | WetDep | -21.89705 | -23.49980 | -1.60276 | 7.31951 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ALD2 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.19617 | -0.15432 | 0.04185 | -21.33333 | | Convection | 0.00133 | 0.00141 | 0.00008 | 6.30713 | | EmisDryDep | 0.02410 | 0.02491 | 0.00081 | 3.34468 | | Mixing | 0.00687 | 0.01014 | 0.00327 | 47.61905 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ ALK4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ALK4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -3045.74099 | -3042.83536 | 2.90563 | -0.09540 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 27.67700 | | EmisDryDep | 3.82225 | 3.85304 | 0.03079 | 0.80557 | | Mixing | 3159.99443 | 3148.31305 | -11.68138 | -0.36966 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ALK4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -3043.24274 | -3040.16513 | 3.07761 | -0.10113 | | Convection | -0.00454 | -0.00515 | -0.00061 | 13.43869 | | EmisDryDep | 3.70163 | 3.72841 | 0.02678 | 0.72360 | | Mixing | 3159.96141 | 3148.25420 | -11.70721 | -0.37049 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ALK4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1644.47728 | -1515.25854 | 129.21874 | -7.85774 | | Convection | -395.97890 | -453.11150 | -57.13261 | 14.42819 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -88.29859 | | Mixing | 2357.23885 | 2396.50003 | 39.26119 | 1.66556 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ALK4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.49825 | -2.67023 | -0.17198 | 6.88392 | | Convection | 0.00454 | 0.00515 | 0.00061 | 13.43869 | | EmisDryDep | 0.12062 | 0.12463 | 0.00401 | 3.32123 | | Mixing | 0.03302 | 0.05885 | 0.02583 | 78.21782 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ASOA1 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ASOA1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.42126 | 24.83118 | 1.40991 | 6.01979 | | Convection | -7.21156 | -7.56941 | -0.35785 | 4.96224 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.16721 | | Mixing | -3.47110 | -3.21418 | 0.25692 | -7.40175 | | WetDep | -12.28890 | -13.22738 | -0.93848 | 7.63677 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ASOA1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.53948 | 24.88245 | 1.34297 | 5.70519 | | Convection | -7.21153 | -7.56939 | -0.35786 | 4.96230 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.45562 | | Mixing | -3.47072 | -3.21420 | 0.25653 | -7.39114 | | WetDep | -12.28820 | -13.22695 | -0.93876 | 7.63949 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ASOA1 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 19.57759 | 19.23456 | -0.34302 | -1.75213 | | Convection | -0.91524 | -0.49621 | 0.41902 | -45.78308 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -113.44104 | | Mixing | -7.12878 | -6.54103 | 0.58774 | -8.24468 | | WetDep | -1.27275 | -0.89992 | 0.37283 | -29.29302 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ASOA1 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.11822 | -0.05128 | 0.06694 | -56.62367 | | Convection | -0.00003 | -0.00003 | 0.00000 | -10.63830 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -11.38356 | | Mixing | -0.00038 | 0.00002 | 0.00040 | -105.17388 | | WetDep | -0.00070 | -0.00043 | 0.00028 | -39.67391 | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ ASOA2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ASOA2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.40501 | 9.64075 | 1.23575 | 14.70253 | | Convection | -3.04993 | -3.47287 | -0.42294 | 13.86722 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -5.99754 | | Mixing | -1.62766 | -1.60299 | 0.02467 | -1.51538 | | WetDep | -4.06234 | -4.75218 | -0.68985 | 16.98157 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ASOA2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.69990 | 9.83239 | 1.13249 | 13.01728 | | Convection | -3.04991 | -3.47285 | -0.42294 | 13.86737 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.72236 | | Mixing | -1.62794 | -1.60358 | 0.02436 | -1.49628 | | WetDep | -4.06197 | -4.75195 | -0.68998 | 16.98625 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ASOA2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.56601 | 10.83929 | 0.27328 | 2.58637 | | Convection | -0.46074 | -0.09762 | 0.36312 | -78.81296 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -95.20163 | | Mixing | -4.10376 | -3.99202 | 0.11174 | -2.72293 | | WetDep | -0.66928 | -0.54848 | 0.12080 | -18.04972 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ASOA2 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.29490 | -0.19164 | 0.10326 | -35.01479 | | Convection | -0.00002 | -0.00002 | 0.00000 | -12.50000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -20.91241 | | Mixing | 0.00028 | 0.00059 | 0.00031 | 108.46979 | | WetDep | -0.00036 | -0.00023 | 0.00013 | -35.63218 | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ ASOA3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ASOA3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.86922 | 10.33228 | 1.46307 | 16.49600 | | Convection | -2.68136 | -3.02707 | -0.34571 | 12.89308 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 4.62479 | | Mixing | -1.63847 | -1.64727 | -0.00880 | 0.53692 | | WetDep | -3.72450 | -4.15752 | -0.43302 | 11.62624 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ASOA3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.59433 | 12.06307 | 1.46874 | 13.86341 | | Convection | -2.68128 | -3.02700 | -0.34572 | 12.89384 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 6.80511 | | Mixing | -1.64253 | -1.65352 | -0.01100 | 0.66959 | | WetDep | -3.72309 | -4.15643 | -0.43335 | 11.63943 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ASOA3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.50239 | 8.35880 | -0.14360 | -1.68889 | | Convection | 0.57305 | 1.17800 | 0.60495 | 105.56762 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -399.25927 | | Mixing | -3.84988 | -3.73663 | 0.11325 | -2.94175 | | WetDep | -0.38825 | -0.26841 | 0.11984 | -30.86737 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ASOA3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.72512 | -1.73079 | -0.00567 | 0.32863 | | Convection | -0.00008 | -0.00007 | 0.00001 | -13.00813 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -11.36571 | | Mixing | 0.00406 | 0.00626 | 0.00220 | 54.26704 | | WetDep | -0.00142 | -0.00109 | 0.00033 | -22.99213 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ASOAN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ASOAN +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 235.42497 | 233.39633 | -2.02864 | -0.86169 | | Convection | -68.19173 | -68.15764 | 0.03409 | -0.04999 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 7.11803 | | Mixing | -26.13725 | -23.68712 | 2.45013 | -9.37410 | | WetDep | -135.93561 | -134.60712 | 1.32849 | -0.97730 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ASOAN +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 235.35572 | 233.33958 | -2.01614 | -0.85663 | | Convection | -68.19167 | -68.15758 | 0.03410 | -0.05000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 11.41568 | | Mixing | -26.13726 | -23.68793 | 2.44933 | -9.37102 | | WetDep | -135.93369 | -134.60608 | 1.32761 | -0.97666 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ASOAN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 102.75358 | 94.73186 | -8.02172 | -7.80676 | | Convection | -4.90596 | -3.32033 | 1.58562 | -32.32040 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -90.32591 | | Mixing | -38.70016 | -33.74252 | 4.95765 | -12.81041 | | WetDep | -4.84485 | -2.68566 | 2.15919 | -44.56667 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ASOAN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.06925 | 0.05675 | -0.01251 | -18.05842 | | Convection | -0.00006 | -0.00007 | -0.00001 | 8.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.50714 | | Mixing | 0.00002 | 0.00082 | 0.00080 | 5233.33333 | | WetDep | -0.00192 | -0.00104 | 0.00088 | -45.74468 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ASOG1 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ASOG1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.86645 | 23.06016 | -0.80629 | -3.37835 | | Convection | -2.86795 | -3.02258 | -0.15462 | 5.39144 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.75442 | | Mixing | -6.73187 | -5.86566 | 0.86620 | -12.86723 | | WetDep | -13.57979 | -13.33311 | 0.24669 | -1.81657 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ASOG1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.69267 | 22.95382 | -0.73885 | -3.11845 | | Convection | -2.86796 | -3.02258 | -0.15462 | 5.39139 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.74381 | | Mixing | -6.73136 | -5.86505 | 0.86631 | -12.86974 | | WetDep | -13.57979 | -13.33311 | 0.24669 | -1.81657 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ASOG1 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 11.49029 | 10.78863 | -0.70166 | -6.10658 | | Convection | -0.15894 | -0.50091 | -0.34197 | 215.15999 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -61.81563 | | Mixing | -6.47972 | -5.54510 | 0.93462 | -14.42379 | | WetDep | -1.94566 | -1.70393 | 0.24173 | -12.42410 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ASOG1 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.17379 | 0.10634 | -0.06745 | -38.81034 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -22.22222 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -6.89306 | | Mixing | -0.00051 | -0.00061 | -0.00010 | 20.32622 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ASOG2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ASOG2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 46.80793 | 46.97185 | 0.16392 | 0.35020 | | Convection | -6.06507 | -6.65815 | -0.59308 | 9.77861 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.38229 | | Mixing | -15.79089 | -13.78776 | 2.00314 | -12.68539 | | WetDep | -26.50481 | -27.70800 | -1.20319 | 4.53952 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ASOG2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 46.50980 | 46.77580 | 0.26601 | 0.57194 | | Convection | -6.06507 | -6.65815 | -0.59308 | 9.77864 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.68047 | | Mixing | -15.78976 | -13.78659 | 2.00317 | -12.68651 | | WetDep | -26.50481 | -27.70800 | -1.20319 | 4.53952 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ASOG2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 32.71258 | 31.67575 | -1.03683 | -3.16951 | | Convection | -0.60588 | -0.95381 | -0.34793 | 57.42503 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 118.86650 | | Mixing | -16.89409 | -14.81049 | 2.08361 | -12.33335 | | WetDep | -6.34374 | -5.57813 | 0.76561 | -12.06879 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ASOG2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.29813 | 0.19604 | -0.10209 | -34.24209 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 100.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -9.58926 | | Mixing | -0.00113 | -0.00117 | -0.00003 | 2.81532 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ASOG3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ASOG3 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 302.02881 | 301.95055 | -0.07826 | -0.02591 | | Convection | -36.92978 | -40.77754 | -3.84776 | 10.41911 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.96314 | | Mixing | -82.44788 | -75.72420 | 6.72368 | -8.15507 | | WetDep | -162.12454 | -160.79849 | 1.32605 | -0.81792 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ASOG3 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 299.74556 | 299.66987 | -0.07569 | -0.02525 | | Convection | -36.92961 | -40.77738 | -3.84777 | 10.41920 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.08218 | | Mixing | -82.43430 | -75.70938 | 6.72493 | -8.15792 | | WetDep | -162.12454 | -160.79849 | 1.32605 | -0.81792 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ASOG3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 171.69106 | 162.99392 | -8.69714 | -5.06557 | | Convection | 0.88180 | 1.91105 | 1.02925 | 116.72144 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -143.65348 | | Mixing | -84.77387 | -76.32028 | 8.45359 | -9.97193 | | WetDep | -29.85782 | -25.58397 | 4.27385 | -14.31401 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ASOG3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2.28326 | 2.28068 | -0.00257 | -0.11277 | | Convection | -0.00017 | -0.00016 | 0.00001 | -7.35294 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -8.61871 | | Mixing | -0.01357 | -0.01482 | -0.00125 | 9.18329 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ATOOH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ATOOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1084.27244 | 1090.20770 | 5.93526 | 0.54740 | | Convection | -0.55765 | -0.61809 | -0.06044 | 10.83768 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -31.64002 | | Mixing | -570.71221 | -561.78557 | 8.92664 | -1.56412 | | WetDep | -474.70737 | -484.92519 | -10.21782 | 2.15245 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ATOOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1084.60512 | 1090.50670 | 5.90159 | 0.54412 | | Convection | -0.55867 | -0.61906 | -0.06038 | 10.80829 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -34.07227 | | Mixing | -570.71777 | -561.79669 | 8.92108 | -1.56313 | | WetDep | -474.70737 | -484.92519 | -10.21782 | 2.15245 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ATOOH +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1260.96927 | 1307.54636 | 46.57709 | 3.69375 | | Convection | -32.24854 | -30.18057 | 2.06797 | -6.41260 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -149.58827 | | Mixing | -676.50607 | -665.03896 | 11.46710 | -1.69505 | | WetDep | -158.99244 | -141.07887 | 17.91357 | -11.26693 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ATOOH +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.33267 | -0.29900 | 0.03368 | -10.12285 | | Convection | 0.00102 | 0.00096 | -0.00005 | -5.28833 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -21.14357 | | Mixing | 0.00556 | 0.01112 | 0.00556 | 100.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ BCPI budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BCPI +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 537.90222 | 540.34194 | 2.43972 | 0.45356 | | Convection | -214.24178 | -210.25332 | 3.98846 | -1.86166 | | EmisDryDep | 0.48961 | 0.49794 | 0.00834 | 1.70251 | | Mixing | 58.85257 | 70.05734 | 11.20477 | 19.03871 | | WetDep | -367.52932 | -383.29961 | -15.77030 | 4.29090 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BCPI +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 537.90557 | 540.34096 | 2.43539 | 0.45275 | | Convection | -214.24174 | -210.25326 | 3.98848 | -1.86167 | | EmisDryDep | 0.43501 | 0.44250 | 0.00749 | 1.72098 | | Mixing | 58.85056 | 70.05393 | 11.20337 | 19.03697 | | WetDep | -367.52776 | -383.29871 | -15.77095 | 4.29109 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BCPI +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 277.24436 | 259.62451 | -17.61985 | -6.35535 | | Convection | -55.54675 | -55.98149 | -0.43474 | 0.78266 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -60.78636 | | Mixing | -63.62198 | -39.72989 | 23.89209 | -37.55320 | | WetDep | -40.28481 | -29.94635 | 10.33846 | -25.66342 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BCPI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00335 | 0.00098 | 0.00433 | -129.26829 | | Convection | -0.00004 | -0.00006 | -0.00002 | 50.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.05460 | 0.05545 | 0.00085 | 1.55538 | | Mixing | 0.00201 | 0.00342 | 0.00140 | 69.79695 | | WetDep | -0.00155 | -0.00090 | 0.00065 | -42.10526 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ BCPO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BCPO +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -537.90222 | -540.34194 | -2.43972 | 0.45356 | | Convection | -52.32667 | -51.35510 | 0.97157 | -1.85673 | | EmisDryDep | 0.14379 | 0.17793 | 0.03415 | 23.74982 | | Mixing | 597.79558 | 601.16095 | 3.36537 | 0.56296 | | WetDep | -3.24460 | -5.39545 | -2.15085 | 66.29000 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BCPO +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -537.89989 | -540.33540 | -2.43551 | 0.45278 | | Convection | -52.32668 | -51.35510 | 0.97157 | -1.85674 | | EmisDryDep | 0.14379 | 0.17793 | 0.03415 | 23.74982 | | Mixing | 597.79558 | 601.16078 | 3.36521 | 0.56294 | | WetDep | -3.24460 | -5.39545 | -2.15085 | 66.29008 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BCPO +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -277.24436 | -259.62451 | 17.61985 | -6.35535 | | Convection | -76.64270 | -89.16853 | -12.52582 | 16.34314 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -356.43118 | | Mixing | 456.09969 | 467.95464 | 11.85495 | 2.59920 | | WetDep | -1.00451 | -0.91778 | 0.08673 | -8.63437 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BCPO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00233 | -0.00654 | -0.00421 | 180.70175 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | -0.00001 | -100.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00016 | 0.00016 | nan | | WetDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -20.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ BENZ budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BENZ +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -659.24458 | -655.95044 | 3.29413 | -0.49968 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 30.59537 | | EmisDryDep | 0.04217 | 0.05561 | 0.01344 | 31.88269 | | Mixing | 746.73396 | 743.42209 | -3.31187 | -0.44351 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BENZ +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -658.30573 | -655.06428 | 3.24145 | -0.49239 | | Convection | -0.00126 | -0.00103 | 0.00023 | -17.96596 | | EmisDryDep | 0.04217 | 0.05561 | 0.01344 | 31.88269 | | Mixing | 746.71525 | 743.39201 | -3.32323 | -0.44505 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BENZ +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -260.58137 | -241.84351 | 18.73787 | -7.19079 | | Convection | -127.85949 | -134.71387 | -6.85438 | 5.36087 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -103.10928 | | Mixing | 516.70977 | 525.24946 | 8.53969 | 1.65271 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BENZ +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.93885 | -0.88617 | 0.05268 | -5.61118 | | Convection | 0.00126 | 0.00103 | -0.00023 | -17.96596 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.01872 | 0.03008 | 0.01136 | 60.69869 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ BR budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.03998 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.00272 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00047 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.42474 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.23129 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.24725 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.04271 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00047 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ BR2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BR2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 6.11481 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00014 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.93051 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.07056 | -0.07056 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BR2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 6.31319 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00017 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.93184 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.07056 | -0.07056 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BR2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 51.09586 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -19.70566 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -19.07863 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.04435 | -0.04435 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BR2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.19837 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00003 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00133 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ BRCL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BRCL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.85845 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00006 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.31422 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.03111 | -0.03111 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BRCL +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -11.75287 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00002 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.30012 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.03111 | -0.03111 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BRCL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 14.99434 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -5.42244 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -5.91391 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.01989 | -0.01989 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BRCL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 9.89442 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00003 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.01410 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ BRNO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BRNO2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.10990 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BRNO2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.04079 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00024 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BRNO2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.88025 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.32159 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.49512 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BRNO2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.06911 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00024 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ BRNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BRNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 23.36040 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -29.76900 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BRNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 50.66492 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -29.77433 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BRNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 41.04437 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -4.32191 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -33.80799 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BRNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -27.30452 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00533 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ BRO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BRO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 1.74091 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BRO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.36750 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00004 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.01377 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BRO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 20.15385 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -9.00029 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -8.59613 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BRO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 2.10840 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00004 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.01377 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ BRSALA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BRSALA +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 9.31650 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -5.51130 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 11.03186 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -14.12955 | -14.12955 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BRSALA +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 9.40094 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -5.51130 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 11.03123 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -14.12954 | -14.12954 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BRSALA +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -9.16949 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 1.69337 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 12.06059 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -2.37850 | -2.37850 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BRSALA +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.08445 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00063 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ BRSALC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BRSALC +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -147.97439 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -58.26568 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 524.64231 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -313.06027 | -313.06027 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BRSALC +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -147.97419 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -58.26568 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 524.64223 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -313.06027 | -313.06027 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BRSALC +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -165.74857 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -38.72643 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 476.20445 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -255.10493 | -255.10493 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BRSALC +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00019 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00008 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Br budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.09244 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03027 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00037 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.26465 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.16135 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.15906 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.06217 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00037 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Br2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : Br2 +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 3.98774 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00006 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.70860 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.04628 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : Br2 +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 4.19571 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00008 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.70906 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.04628 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : Br2 +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 37.44860 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -15.43224 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -14.91751 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.03096 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : Br2 +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.20796 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00046 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ BrCl budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BrCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.59195 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00002 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.21840 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.01806 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BrCl +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -11.07123 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00002 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.20538 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.01806 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BrCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 9.41647 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -3.89778 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -4.13472 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.01279 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BrCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.47928 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00005 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.01302 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ BrNO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BrNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.14335 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BrNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.06049 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00027 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BrNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.66303 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.22286 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.36828 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BrNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.08286 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00027 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ BrNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BrNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 18.01632 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -25.10544 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BrNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 42.51530 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00003 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -25.11545 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BrNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 34.40019 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -3.63926 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -28.17457 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BrNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -24.49898 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00003 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.01001 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ BrO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BrO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.74894 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BrO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.25105 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00006 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.01100 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BrO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 13.02116 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -6.38575 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -5.58521 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BrO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.99999 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00006 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.01100 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ BrSALA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BrSALA +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 4.50039 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -4.16389 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 9.61100 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -9.33381 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BrSALA +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 4.54808 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -4.16389 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 9.61070 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -9.33380 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BrSALA +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -8.83198 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 1.41337 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 10.34888 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -1.69312 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BrSALA +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.04769 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00030 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ BrSALC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : BrSALC +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -112.53032 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -52.72174 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 454.64679 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -284.35714 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : BrSALC +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -112.53015 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -52.72174 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 454.64671 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -284.35714 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : BrSALC +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -123.14303 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -38.28781 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 412.04129 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -237.00967 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : BrSALC +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00016 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00008 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ C2H6 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : C2H6 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -881.93864 | -878.17214 | 3.76650 | -0.42707 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -29.19395 | | EmisDryDep | 0.08744 | 0.08743 | -0.00001 | -0.01183 | | Mixing | 1139.65201 | 1124.93250 | -14.71951 | -1.29158 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : C2H6 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -865.53908 | -863.13998 | 2.39910 | -0.27718 | | Convection | -0.00499 | -0.00429 | 0.00070 | -14.00647 | | EmisDryDep | 0.08450 | 0.08439 | -0.00011 | -0.12800 | | Mixing | 1139.34590 | 1124.53010 | -14.81580 | -1.30038 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : C2H6 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -240.22832 | -233.37489 | 6.85343 | -2.85288 | | Convection | -225.33887 | -244.77509 | -19.43622 | 8.62533 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -120.13945 | | Mixing | 735.11274 | 753.22219 | 18.10944 | 2.46349 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : C2H6 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -16.39956 | -15.03216 | 1.36740 | -8.33803 | | Convection | 0.00499 | 0.00429 | -0.00070 | -14.00647 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00294 | 0.00304 | 0.00010 | 3.32464 | | Mixing | 0.30611 | 0.40240 | 0.09629 | 31.45527 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ C3H8 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : C3H8 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -724.82851 | -735.85468 | -11.02617 | 1.52121 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 16.43214 | | EmisDryDep | 0.02140 | 0.02235 | 0.00095 | 4.44935 | | Mixing | 721.48419 | 736.05134 | 14.56715 | 2.01905 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : C3H8 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -721.76562 | -732.83976 | -11.07415 | 1.53431 | | Convection | -0.00154 | -0.00187 | -0.00033 | 21.32996 | | EmisDryDep | 0.02095 | 0.02189 | 0.00094 | 4.47305 | | Mixing | 721.43760 | 735.98146 | 14.54386 | 2.01595 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : C3H8 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -300.51543 | -284.18326 | 16.33217 | -5.43472 | | Convection | -112.40426 | -128.11799 | -15.71374 | 13.97966 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -16.58435 | | Mixing | 503.08367 | 524.98083 | 21.89715 | 4.35259 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : C3H8 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -3.06290 | -3.01492 | 0.04798 | -1.56650 | | Convection | 0.00154 | 0.00187 | 0.00033 | 21.32996 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00044 | 0.00046 | 0.00001 | 3.32182 | | Mixing | 0.04659 | 0.06989 | 0.02330 | 50.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ CCL4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CCL4 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -2.10062 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CCL4 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.13952 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00125 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.21470 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CCL4 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00119 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -9.47936 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -2.87256 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CCL4 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.96110 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00125 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.21470 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CCl4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CCl4 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.10927 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CCl4 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.13483 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00090 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.13023 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CCl4 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00117 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -7.85233 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -2.56966 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CCl4 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.97444 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00090 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.13023 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CFC11 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CFC11 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.57777 | -5.55321 | 0.02456 | -0.44037 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -53.99411 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.63111 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -117.20901 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CFC11 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.23804 | -0.24370 | -0.00566 | 2.37748 | | Convection | -0.00099 | -0.00122 | -0.00024 | 23.98757 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 15.76956 | | Mixing | -0.21600 | -0.38844 | -0.17244 | 79.83106 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CFC11 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00214 | -0.00216 | -0.00003 | 1.22476 | | Convection | -5.07920 | -6.16872 | -1.08952 | 21.45052 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -142.83772 | | Mixing | -1.71042 | -1.88953 | -0.17911 | 10.47146 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CFC11 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.33973 | -5.30951 | 0.03022 | -0.56599 | | Convection | 0.00099 | 0.00122 | 0.00024 | 23.98757 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.30242 | | Mixing | 0.21600 | 0.38844 | 0.17244 | 79.83106 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ CFC113 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CFC113 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.89611 | -1.90047 | -0.00436 | 0.22991 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -103.10344 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1.23976 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -21.18412 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CFC113 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03081 | -0.03100 | -0.00020 | 0.63336 | | Convection | -0.00027 | -0.00033 | -0.00005 | 20.09475 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.62243 | | Mixing | -0.06386 | -0.13038 | -0.06652 | 104.16658 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CFC113 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00078 | -0.00079 | -0.00001 | 1.22448 | | Convection | -0.94388 | -1.16037 | -0.21648 | 22.93516 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -111.39023 | | Mixing | -0.33614 | -0.36343 | -0.02729 | 8.11927 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CFC113 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.86531 | -1.86947 | -0.00416 | 0.22325 | | Convection | 0.00027 | 0.00033 | 0.00005 | 20.09475 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.86379 | | Mixing | 0.06386 | 0.13038 | 0.06652 | 104.16658 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ CFC114 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CFC114 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.17348 | -0.17423 | -0.00076 | 0.43608 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -51.26099 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.08588 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -182.99806 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CFC114 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00179 | -0.00176 | 0.00003 | -1.48584 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -93.63655 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 5.35147 | | Mixing | -0.00393 | -0.01510 | -0.01117 | 284.03835 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CFC114 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00008 | -0.00008 | -0.00000 | 1.21270 | | Convection | 0.11727 | 0.13966 | 0.02239 | 19.09680 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 60.23823 | | Mixing | 0.03617 | 0.04140 | 0.00522 | 14.43707 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CFC114 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.17169 | -0.17247 | -0.00078 | 0.45610 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -93.63655 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.78657 | | Mixing | 0.00393 | 0.01510 | 0.01117 | 284.03835 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ CFC115 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CFC115 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01874 | -0.01874 | 0.00000 | -0.00739 | | Convection | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -158.64950 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.14819 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -213.67656 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CFC115 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00014 | -0.00014 | 0.00000 | -2.04677 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00005 | 0.00002 | 57.01949 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 3.31026 | | Mixing | 0.00123 | -0.00328 | -0.00451 | -366.06007 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CFC115 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 1.20952 | | Convection | 0.49232 | 0.59115 | 0.09884 | 20.07544 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -69.39503 | | Mixing | 0.15656 | 0.17714 | 0.02058 | 13.14576 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CFC115 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01860 | -0.01860 | -0.00000 | 0.00790 | | Convection | -0.00003 | -0.00005 | -0.00002 | 57.01949 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.52232 | | Mixing | -0.00123 | 0.00328 | 0.00451 | -366.06007 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ CFC12 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CFC12 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -6.02388 | -6.05496 | -0.03108 | 0.51595 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -59.00319 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 3.10997 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -178.70670 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CFC12 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.08251 | -0.08265 | -0.00015 | 0.17637 | | Convection | -0.00120 | -0.00150 | -0.00030 | 25.07125 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 3.25581 | | Mixing | -0.25476 | -0.55670 | -0.30194 | 118.52115 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CFC12 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00250 | -0.00253 | -0.00003 | 1.22457 | | Convection | -6.53873 | -7.93253 | -1.39380 | 21.31607 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -70.91684 | | Mixing | -2.19085 | -2.42516 | -0.23431 | 10.69496 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CFC12 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.94137 | -5.97231 | -0.03093 | 0.52067 | | Convection | 0.00120 | 0.00150 | 0.00030 | 25.07125 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.67999 | | Mixing | 0.25476 | 0.55670 | 0.30194 | 118.52115 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ CH2BR2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2BR2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -5.46990 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 5.24082 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2BR2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -5.34191 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 5.23757 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2BR2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.08388 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -1.36549 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 3.24199 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2BR2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.12799 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00326 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CH2Br2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2Br2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.48982 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 5.24708 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2Br2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.35879 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 5.24485 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2Br2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.11174 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -1.39058 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 3.21132 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2Br2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.13104 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00222 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH2CL2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2CL2 +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -107.93916 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2CL2 +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -106.70937 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00062 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.07822 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2CL2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -26.28557 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -12.12773 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -2.17246 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2CL2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.22979 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00062 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.07822 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CH2Cl2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2Cl2 +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -104.83517 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2Cl2 +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -103.56314 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00079 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.04878 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2Cl2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -26.51788 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -9.81022 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1.90094 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2Cl2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.27203 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00079 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.04878 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH2I2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2I2 +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10.00731 | -9.99588 | 0.01144 | -0.11429 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -14.08955 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 121.47629 | | Mixing | 10.00648 | 9.99246 | -0.01402 | -0.14013 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2I2 +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10.00731 | -9.99587 | 0.01144 | -0.11431 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 121.70168 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 121.53180 | | Mixing | 10.00648 | 9.99246 | -0.01402 | -0.14013 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2I2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -8.71647 | -8.65618 | 0.06028 | -0.69162 | | Convection | -0.50122 | -0.47624 | 0.02498 | -4.98455 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -240.01037 | | Mixing | 9.33580 | 9.30428 | -0.03151 | -0.33756 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2I2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 100.00000 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 121.70168 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 7.80365 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ CH2IBR budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -7.53347 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 7.52302 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -7.53346 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 7.52302 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -6.05880 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.53036 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 6.72488 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CH2IBr budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2IBr +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -7.54050 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 7.53358 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2IBr +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -7.54049 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 7.53358 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2IBr +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -6.14038 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.53995 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 6.74636 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2IBr +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH2ICL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2ICL +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -19.17719 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 19.08591 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2ICL +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -19.17688 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 19.08591 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2ICL +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -14.23888 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -1.81696 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 16.43808 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2ICL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00031 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CH2ICl budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2ICl +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -19.18771 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 19.11269 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2ICl +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -19.18738 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 19.11269 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2ICl +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -14.54167 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -1.84597 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 16.47112 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2ICl +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00033 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH2O budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH2O +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 9071.70026 | 8479.57376 | -592.12650 | -6.52718 | | Convection | -945.32521 | -960.57161 | -15.24640 | 1.61282 | | EmisDryDep | 2.09183 | 2.10173 | 0.00990 | 0.47340 | | Mixing | -3846.68689 | -3407.71799 | 438.96890 | -11.41161 | | WetDep | -4202.97294 | -4022.32807 | 180.64487 | -4.29803 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH2O +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 9070.26820 | 8479.25727 | -591.01093 | -6.51591 | | Convection | -945.32954 | -960.57578 | -15.24623 | 1.61280 | | EmisDryDep | 2.02238 | 2.02996 | 0.00758 | 0.37476 | | Mixing | -3846.64929 | -3407.70818 | 438.94111 | -11.41100 | | WetDep | -4202.97294 | -4022.32807 | 180.64487 | -4.29803 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH2O +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 7753.61489 | 7418.90382 | -334.71107 | -4.31684 | | Convection | -392.45373 | -443.16032 | -50.70659 | 12.92040 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -63.31955 | | Mixing | -4583.79846 | -4139.85497 | 443.94349 | -9.68506 | | WetDep | -1375.07232 | -1198.45551 | 176.61681 | -12.84418 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH2O +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.43205 | 0.31649 | -1.11556 | -77.89954 | | Convection | 0.00433 | 0.00417 | -0.00016 | -3.77358 | | EmisDryDep | 0.06944 | 0.07177 | 0.00232 | 3.34612 | | Mixing | -0.03760 | -0.00981 | 0.02779 | -73.91304 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ CH3BR budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH3BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -6.85799 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH3BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -6.55978 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00714 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH3BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.25751 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.26310 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.07799 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH3BR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.29822 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00714 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CH3Br budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH3Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -6.87715 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH3Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -6.57393 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00457 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH3Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.26622 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.23438 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.06618 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH3Br +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.30322 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00457 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH3CCL3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH3CCL3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -2.01403 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH3CCL3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.80149 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00031 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00557 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH3CCL3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.21004 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 4.89524 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 1.45712 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH3CCL3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.21254 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00031 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00557 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CH3CCl3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH3CCl3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.09085 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH3CCl3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.87586 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00018 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00655 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH3CCl3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.21166 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 4.09803 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 1.27554 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH3CCl3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.21498 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00018 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00655 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH3CL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH3CL +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -312.10328 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH3CL +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -302.06112 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00038 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.21515 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH3CL +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -62.22763 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -5.29137 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -1.48097 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH3CL +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -10.04216 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00038 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.21515 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH3Cl budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH3Cl +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -311.28273 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH3Cl +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -301.10813 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00035 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.08886 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH3Cl +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -62.42407 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -3.36133 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1.54879 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH3Cl +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10.17460 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00035 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.08886 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CH3I budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH3I +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -26.64220 | -26.65095 | -0.00874 | 0.03282 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -20.45495 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 21.13578 | | Mixing | 26.98213 | 26.86409 | -0.11804 | -0.43747 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH3I +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -26.60824 | -26.61695 | -0.00871 | 0.03274 | | Convection | -0.00002 | -0.00003 | -0.00001 | 78.07930 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 24.12255 | | Mixing | 26.98146 | 26.86299 | -0.11846 | -0.43906 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH3I +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -9.70929 | -9.02937 | 0.67992 | -7.00276 | | Convection | -5.82712 | -5.72757 | 0.09955 | -1.70838 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -114.81659 | | Mixing | 17.60090 | 17.57431 | -0.02659 | -0.15106 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH3I +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03396 | -0.03400 | -0.00003 | 0.09777 | | Convection | 0.00002 | 0.00003 | 0.00001 | 78.07930 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -6.90845 | | Mixing | 0.00067 | 0.00110 | 0.00043 | 63.74046 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ CH4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CH4 +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -55696.60609 | -55776.95809 | -80.35200 | 0.14427 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -96.87792 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.34120 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -73.04581 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CH4 +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -52717.22612 | -52809.71985 | -92.49373 | 0.17545 | | Convection | -0.16687 | -0.07974 | 0.08712 | -52.21141 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.73879 | | Mixing | -38.29935 | -155.58975 | -117.29040 | 306.24650 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CH4 +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -12071.55926 | -12021.76169 | 49.79758 | -0.41252 | | Convection | -598.60793 | -771.42007 | -172.81214 | 28.86900 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -98.17652 | | Mixing | -263.05839 | -311.22047 | -48.16208 | 18.30851 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CH4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2979.37997 | -2967.23824 | 12.14173 | -0.40753 | | Convection | 0.16687 | 0.07974 | -0.08712 | -52.21141 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.81530 | | Mixing | 38.29935 | 155.58975 | 117.29040 | 306.24650 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ CHBR3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CHBR3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -37.41256 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 37.92557 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CHBR3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -37.24877 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00009 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 37.91863 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CHBR3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -8.90982 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -9.64868 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 23.79946 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CHBR3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.16379 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00009 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00695 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CHBr3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CHBr3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -37.41375 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 37.96948 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CHBr3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -37.24107 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00006 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 37.96497 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CHBr3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -9.52466 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -9.80164 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 23.64676 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CHBr3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.17267 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00006 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00450 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CHCL3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CHCL3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -34.57360 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CHCL3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -34.06804 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00023 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.02310 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CHCL3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -8.12450 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -3.22868 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.82854 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CHCL3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.50556 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00023 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.02310 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CHCl3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CHCl3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -33.95353 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CHCl3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -33.43374 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00020 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.01381 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CHCl3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -8.18638 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -2.74647 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.70491 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CHCl3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.51979 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00020 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.01381 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ CL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CL +-------------+-----------+---------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+---------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.01061 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+---------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00178 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00025 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00013 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00023 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.01239 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CL2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CL2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -6.16776 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.10649 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CL2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.14546 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00003 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.10608 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CL2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 3.03339 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -1.04026 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -1.55902 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CL2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -6.02230 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00003 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00042 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CL2O2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CL2O2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 21.50090 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CL2O2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.33204 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00152 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CL2O2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CL2O2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 21.83294 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00152 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CLNO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CLNO2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.73827 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.72220 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CLNO2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 1.88958 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00007 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.72264 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CLNO2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.92160 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -5.90003 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -10.60531 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CLNO2 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.15131 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00007 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00044 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CLNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CLNO3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.93768 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -7.30705 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CLNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -25.14795 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00010 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -7.14364 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CLNO3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 4.47156 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.41666 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -7.84908 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CLNO3 +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 24.21027 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00010 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.16341 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CLO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 7.99730 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.02145 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.54195 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00003 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00636 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00341 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.33871 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.32818 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 9.53925 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00003 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.01509 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CLOO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CLOO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.00003 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CLOO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00046 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CLOO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CLOO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.00050 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ CO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : CO +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -74661.57703 | -72715.08645 | 1946.49058 | -2.60708 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -10.97783 | | EmisDryDep | 60.49630 | 61.03883 | 0.54253 | 0.89680 | | Mixing | 91104.90761 | 91381.68259 | 276.77497 | 0.30380 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : CO +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -72284.44472 | -70512.59942 | 1771.84530 | -2.45121 | | Convection | -0.53998 | -0.44006 | 0.09992 | -18.50428 | | EmisDryDep | 57.75741 | 58.22054 | 0.46313 | 0.80185 | | Mixing | 91051.31869 | 91306.10149 | 254.78280 | 0.27982 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : CO +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 8321.52331 | 9033.13810 | 711.61478 | 8.55150 | | Convection | -18507.60799 | -18853.11112 | -345.50314 | 1.86682 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -50.70169 | | Mixing | 54561.85380 | 57761.97159 | 3200.11779 | 5.86512 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : CO +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2377.13231 | -2202.48703 | 174.64528 | -7.34689 | | Convection | 0.53998 | 0.44006 | -0.09992 | -18.50428 | | EmisDryDep | 2.73888 | 2.81828 | 0.07940 | 2.89913 | | Mixing | 53.58893 | 75.58110 | 21.99217 | 41.03866 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Cl budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : Cl +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.01199 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : Cl +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00132 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : Cl +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00020 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00010 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00015 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : Cl +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.01331 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Cl2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : Cl2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.99987 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.06964 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : Cl2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.72935 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00005 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.06072 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : Cl2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.87806 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.69640 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1.05476 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : Cl2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -6.72922 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00005 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00892 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Cl2O2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : Cl2O2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 11.89418 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : Cl2O2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.27480 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00245 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : Cl2O2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : Cl2O2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 12.16897 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00245 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ ClNO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ClNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.13558 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.47037 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ClNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.09812 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.47034 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ClNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.43120 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -3.83410 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -7.71188 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ClNO2 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.23370 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00003 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ ClNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ClNO3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 6.78132 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -6.04058 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ClNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -27.54320 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00013 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -5.90190 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ClNO3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 4.01491 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.37547 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -6.55107 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ClNO3 +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 34.32452 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00013 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.13868 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ ClO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 7.73067 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.01591 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.00767 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00006 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00217 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.03179 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.23818 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.21186 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.73834 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00006 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.01808 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ ClOO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ClOO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00007 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ClOO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00031 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ClOO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ClOO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00038 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ DMS budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : DMS +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -2631.12029 | -2882.07610 | -250.95581 | 9.53798 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -23.09794 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -69.76669 | | Mixing | 2603.82346 | 2870.62097 | 266.79751 | 10.24637 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : DMS +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -2629.74414 | -2880.86834 | -251.12419 | 9.54938 | | Convection | -0.00106 | -0.00484 | -0.00378 | 358.56602 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -65.31923 | | Mixing | 2603.81022 | 2870.60201 | 266.79179 | 10.24621 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : DMS +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -1604.56987 | -1706.83182 | -102.26195 | 6.37317 | | Convection | -407.13952 | -412.20983 | -5.07031 | 1.24535 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -152.09665 | | Mixing | 2110.97939 | 2308.85093 | 197.87154 | 9.37345 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : DMS +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.37615 | -1.20776 | 0.16838 | -12.23569 | | Convection | 0.00106 | 0.00484 | 0.00378 | 358.56602 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 5393.19090 | | Mixing | 0.01324 | 0.01896 | 0.00572 | 43.20988 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ DST1 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : DST1 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -210.88358 | -312.51481 | -101.63123 | 48.19305 | | Convection | -3081.11438 | -4859.02760 | -1777.91322 | 57.70358 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 44.14292 | | Mixing | 3848.92096 | 7634.17434 | 3785.25338 | 98.34583 | | WetDep | -453.46629 | -993.59199 | -540.12570 | 119.11044 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : DST1 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -210.02860 | -310.90169 | -100.87309 | 48.02826 | | Convection | -3081.11405 | -4859.02727 | -1777.91322 | 57.70358 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 39.33928 | | Mixing | 3848.89284 | 7634.08802 | 3785.19518 | 98.34504 | | WetDep | -453.45689 | -993.58472 | -540.12783 | 119.11338 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : DST1 +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -29.84143 | -44.13573 | -14.29430 | 47.90087 | | Convection | -37.61152 | -75.08661 | -37.47510 | 99.63729 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -103.15953 | | Mixing | 3048.33340 | 6402.34770 | 3354.01430 | 110.02780 | | WetDep | 1.31160 | 18.73349 | 17.42189 | 1328.29429 | +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : DST1 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.85498 | -1.61313 | -0.75814 | 88.67352 | | Convection | -0.00033 | -0.00033 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 145.26422 | | Mixing | 0.02812 | 0.08632 | 0.05820 | 206.97674 | | WetDep | -0.00940 | -0.00727 | 0.00213 | -22.60870 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ DST2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : DST2 +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -786.72123 | -1503.25053 | -716.52930 | 91.07792 | | Convection | -899.80083 | -2267.95187 | -1368.15105 | 152.05043 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -100.04914 | | Mixing | 8089.11980 | 17889.24285 | 9800.12305 | 121.15191 | | WetDep | -7663.77144 | -13770.25992 | -6106.48848 | 79.67994 | +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : DST2 +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -786.48190 | -1502.78250 | -716.30059 | 91.07655 | | Convection | -899.80075 | -2267.95187 | -1368.15113 | 152.05045 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -99.71592 | | Mixing | 8089.11849 | 17889.23370 | 9800.11520 | 121.15183 | | WetDep | -7663.77079 | -13770.25861 | -6106.48782 | 79.67994 | +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : DST2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -128.39144 | -266.64437 | -138.25294 | 107.68081 | | Convection | 37.69808 | -51.79301 | -89.49109 | -237.38900 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -84.83892 | | Mixing | 6596.18644 | 15206.20796 | 8610.02152 | 130.53029 | | WetDep | -1858.74519 | -3545.33354 | -1686.58835 | 90.73801 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : DST2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.23933 | -0.46803 | -0.22870 | 95.56011 | | Convection | -0.00008 | 0.00000 | 0.00008 | -100.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 126.01598 | | Mixing | 0.00131 | 0.00915 | 0.00785 | 600.00000 | | WetDep | -0.00065 | -0.00131 | -0.00065 | 100.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ DST3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : DST3 +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -3680.15887 | -7103.19069 | -3423.03182 | 93.01315 | | Convection | -1245.53332 | -3261.36200 | -2015.82867 | 161.84462 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -97.16158 | | Mixing | 14591.43146 | 32013.40075 | 17421.96929 | 119.39863 | | WetDep | -11523.39488 | -21116.55007 | -9593.15518 | 83.24938 | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : DST3 +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -3679.93197 | -7102.60479 | -3422.67282 | 93.00913 | | Convection | -1245.53332 | -3261.36200 | -2015.82867 | 161.84462 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -97.20029 | | Mixing | 14591.43146 | 32013.39291 | 17421.96144 | 119.39858 | | WetDep | -11523.39358 | -21116.55007 | -9593.15649 | 83.24940 | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : DST3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -683.94977 | -1398.01609 | -714.06632 | 104.40333 | | Convection | -76.66408 | -383.56318 | -306.89910 | 400.31667 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -102.19512 | | Mixing | 11812.76409 | 27111.01067 | 15298.24657 | 129.50607 | | WetDep | -3039.62893 | -5993.06974 | -2953.44082 | 97.16452 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : DST3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.22691 | -0.58590 | -0.35899 | 158.21326 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 20.04443 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00785 | 0.00785 | nan | | WetDep | -0.00131 | 0.00000 | 0.00131 | -100.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ DST4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : DST4 +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -9481.89826 | -18884.99690 | -9403.09864 | 99.16895 | | Convection | -529.57297 | -1534.86085 | -1005.28788 | 189.82991 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -42.48774 | | Mixing | 15445.06291 | 33425.16342 | 17980.10051 | 116.41326 | | WetDep | -6454.47580 | -12511.22752 | -6056.75171 | 93.83801 | +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : DST4 +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -9481.87930 | -18884.88835 | -9403.00905 | 99.16820 | | Convection | -529.57297 | -1534.86085 | -1005.28788 | 189.82991 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -42.49320 | | Mixing | 15445.06291 | 33425.16081 | 17980.09789 | 116.41324 | | WetDep | -6454.47580 | -12511.22621 | -6056.75040 | 93.83799 | +-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : DST4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -2435.08377 | -5050.46127 | -2615.37750 | 107.40400 | | Convection | -376.23698 | -1113.64060 | -737.40362 | 195.99446 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -49.93352 | | Mixing | 12529.07654 | 28333.73427 | 15804.65773 | 126.14384 | | WetDep | -2017.92673 | -4278.35002 | -2260.42329 | 112.01711 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : DST4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01896 | -0.10855 | -0.08959 | 472.41379 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1971.79487 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00262 | 0.00262 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.00131 | -0.00131 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ EOH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : EOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -918.86498 | -854.42791 | 64.43707 | -7.01268 | | Convection | -0.16518 | -0.15791 | 0.00727 | -4.40167 | | EmisDryDep | 0.01778 | 0.02036 | 0.00257 | 14.47500 | | Mixing | 1167.10732 | 1096.71783 | -70.38949 | -6.03111 | | WetDep | -239.60410 | -236.64183 | 2.96228 | -1.23632 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : EOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -918.54824 | -854.11698 | 64.43126 | -7.01447 | | Convection | -0.16588 | -0.15858 | 0.00730 | -4.40301 | | EmisDryDep | 0.01778 | 0.02036 | 0.00257 | 14.47500 | | Mixing | 1167.10414 | 1096.71145 | -70.39268 | -6.03140 | | WetDep | -239.60410 | -236.64183 | 2.96228 | -1.23632 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : EOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -490.77225 | -415.51153 | 75.26073 | -15.33516 | | Convection | -105.07575 | -113.83794 | -8.76219 | 8.33893 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -108.11201 | | Mixing | 936.63512 | 893.55921 | -43.07591 | -4.59901 | | WetDep | -107.40845 | -93.41390 | 13.99455 | -13.02929 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : EOH +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.31674 | -0.31093 | 0.00580 | -1.83226 | | Convection | 0.00071 | 0.00067 | -0.00003 | -4.71605 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00319 | 0.00638 | 0.00319 | 100.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ETHLN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ETHLN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 20.02907 | 17.30418 | -2.72489 | -13.60469 | | Convection | -1.44309 | -1.37595 | 0.06714 | -4.65247 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -91.85294 | | Mixing | -12.98856 | -10.76811 | 2.22045 | -17.09545 | | WetDep | -5.01340 | -4.62555 | 0.38786 | -7.73639 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ETHLN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 20.02937 | 17.30452 | -2.72484 | -13.60424 | | Convection | -1.44309 | -1.37595 | 0.06714 | -4.65248 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -92.27826 | | Mixing | -12.98856 | -10.76811 | 2.22045 | -17.09541 | | WetDep | -5.01340 | -4.62555 | 0.38786 | -7.73639 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ETHLN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | 17.60185 | 16.48418 | -1.11767 | -6.34972 | | Convection | -0.75457 | -1.03559 | -0.28102 | 37.24249 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -2828.56012 | | Mixing | -14.97588 | -12.65319 | 2.32269 | -15.50956 | | WetDep | -2.44565 | -1.97137 | 0.47428 | -19.39285 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ Strat [Gg] : ETHLN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00029 | -0.00034 | -0.00005 | 17.54386 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -11.11111 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -313.58540 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 400.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ETNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ETNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 4.43718 | 3.40907 | -1.02812 | -23.17050 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -26.97804 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 3.01323 | | Mixing | 15.75938 | 17.18435 | 1.42497 | 9.04207 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ETNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 4.32150 | 3.29792 | -1.02357 | -23.68565 | | Convection | -0.00006 | -0.00011 | -0.00005 | 85.19818 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 4.15107 | | Mixing | 15.75751 | 17.18140 | 1.42389 | 9.03627 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ETNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 6.29079 | 5.69193 | -0.59886 | -9.51969 | | Convection | -5.29724 | -5.18709 | 0.11015 | -2.07938 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -449.36643 | | Mixing | 9.53791 | 10.60562 | 1.06771 | 11.19436 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ETNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.11569 | 0.11114 | -0.00454 | -3.92740 | | Convection | 0.00006 | 0.00011 | 0.00005 | 85.19818 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.90504 | | Mixing | 0.00187 | 0.00295 | 0.00108 | 58.04244 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ETP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ETP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 226.39289 | 227.79646 | 1.40357 | 0.61997 | | Convection | -0.79515 | -0.87864 | -0.08349 | 10.49988 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -13.89450 | | Mixing | -128.73444 | -127.24292 | 1.49152 | -1.15860 | | WetDep | -172.11154 | -173.53660 | -1.42507 | 0.82799 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ETP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 226.32257 | 227.79096 | 1.46839 | 0.64880 | | Convection | -0.79543 | -0.87891 | -0.08348 | 10.49536 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -12.10756 | | Mixing | -128.73657 | -127.24723 | 1.48933 | -1.15688 | | WetDep | -172.11154 | -173.53660 | -1.42507 | 0.82799 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ETP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 193.37714 | 195.63189 | 2.25475 | 1.16599 | | Convection | 7.39140 | 8.70392 | 1.31252 | 17.75740 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -179.06927 | | Mixing | -127.00271 | -127.69504 | -0.69232 | 0.54512 | | WetDep | -45.22855 | -40.55949 | 4.66906 | -10.32327 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ETP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.07032 | 0.00550 | -0.06482 | -92.18251 | | Convection | 0.00028 | 0.00027 | -0.00001 | -2.54925 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -15.94982 | | Mixing | 0.00213 | 0.00431 | 0.00219 | 102.88462 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ GLYC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : GLYC +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1254.60529 | 1154.86522 | -99.74008 | -7.94992 | | Convection | -172.20106 | -174.29624 | -2.09518 | 1.21670 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -64.99273 | | Mixing | -553.74391 | -449.72043 | 104.02349 | -18.78549 | | WetDep | -519.37918 | -520.68822 | -1.30904 | 0.25204 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : GLYC +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1254.69798 | 1154.98513 | -99.71286 | -7.94716 | | Convection | -172.20131 | -174.29646 | -2.09516 | 1.21669 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -64.05899 | | Mixing | -553.74457 | -449.72272 | 104.02185 | -18.78517 | | WetDep | -519.37918 | -520.68822 | -1.30904 | 0.25204 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : GLYC +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1298.38464 | 1248.35182 | -50.03282 | -3.85347 | | Convection | -33.30850 | -30.50886 | 2.79964 | -8.40517 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -94.98578 | | Mixing | -661.78026 | -555.01159 | 106.76867 | -16.13355 | | WetDep | -174.92176 | -140.16048 | 34.76128 | -19.87247 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : GLYC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.09269 | -0.11991 | -0.02722 | 29.36508 | | Convection | 0.00025 | 0.00022 | -0.00002 | -8.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -25.06344 | | Mixing | 0.00065 | 0.00229 | 0.00163 | 250.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ GLYX budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : GLYX +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 78.69115 | 72.69199 | -5.99916 | -7.62367 | | Convection | -11.85383 | -11.93347 | -0.07964 | 0.67186 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 89.79633 | | Mixing | -41.84467 | -35.85613 | 5.98854 | -14.31137 | | WetDep | -30.10371 | -29.85023 | 0.25348 | -0.84202 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : GLYX +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 78.69365 | 72.69503 | -5.99862 | -7.62275 | | Convection | -11.85384 | -11.93348 | -0.07964 | 0.67186 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 92.52439 | | Mixing | -41.84471 | -35.85622 | 5.98849 | -14.31122 | | WetDep | -30.10371 | -29.85023 | 0.25348 | -0.84202 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : GLYX +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 73.79675 | 72.61101 | -1.18575 | -1.60677 | | Convection | -2.53928 | -2.40527 | 0.13401 | -5.27765 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -83.16224 | | Mixing | -49.54669 | -43.25779 | 6.28890 | -12.69287 | | WetDep | -10.70967 | -8.67463 | 2.03503 | -19.00185 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : GLYX +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00250 | -0.00304 | -0.00054 | 21.42857 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 29.34096 | | Mixing | 0.00004 | 0.00009 | 0.00006 | 157.14286 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ H1211 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : H1211 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.45452 | -0.45521 | -0.00069 | 0.15114 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -13.92971 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.87260 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -66.83888 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : H1211 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.31362 | -0.31534 | -0.00172 | 0.54765 | | Convection | -0.00003 | -0.00004 | -0.00001 | 24.99719 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.21799 | | Mixing | -0.00660 | -0.01043 | -0.00384 | 58.12906 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : H1211 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03401 | -0.03405 | -0.00004 | 0.12627 | | Convection | -0.18596 | -0.22554 | -0.03958 | 21.28188 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -123.67767 | | Mixing | -0.06181 | -0.06846 | -0.00665 | 10.75638 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : H1211 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.14090 | -0.13987 | 0.00103 | -0.73142 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00004 | 0.00001 | 24.99719 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.02027 | | Mixing | 0.00660 | 0.01043 | 0.00384 | 58.12906 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ H1301 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : H1301 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.08821 | -0.08795 | 0.00026 | -0.29303 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -106.44444 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.10288 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -153.36928 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : H1301 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00178 | -0.00180 | -0.00003 | 1.63900 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00002 | 0.00001 | 62.84750 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.92109 | | Mixing | -0.00024 | -0.00209 | -0.00185 | 768.51177 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : H1301 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00002 | -0.00002 | -0.00000 | 0.95040 | | Convection | 0.14093 | 0.17039 | 0.02946 | 20.90167 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -83.64995 | | Mixing | 0.04640 | 0.05182 | 0.00542 | 11.68269 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : H1301 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.08643 | -0.08614 | 0.00029 | -0.33271 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00002 | -0.00001 | 62.84750 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.65771 | | Mixing | 0.00024 | 0.00209 | 0.00185 | 768.51177 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ H2402 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : H2402 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.04483 | -0.04532 | -0.00049 | 1.08911 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -30.66828 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 5.48348 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -223.08602 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : H2402 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.02923 | -0.02981 | -0.00058 | 1.98322 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00002 | -0.00001 | 45.33437 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 7.37758 | | Mixing | -0.00149 | -0.00240 | -0.00091 | 60.99989 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : H2402 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00379 | -0.00379 | -0.00000 | 0.02756 | | Convection | -0.16797 | -0.20210 | -0.03413 | 20.31968 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -107.47506 | | Mixing | -0.05400 | -0.06079 | -0.00679 | 12.56609 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : H2402 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01560 | -0.01551 | 0.00009 | -0.58664 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00002 | 0.00001 | 45.33437 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.59014 | | Mixing | 0.00149 | 0.00240 | 0.00091 | 60.99989 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ H2O budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : H2O +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 100485.11430 | 101153.94007 | 668.82577 | 0.66560 | | Convection | -0.00016 | -0.00015 | 0.00002 | -10.04459 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -21.75910 | | Mixing | -0.00002 | 0.00001 | 0.00003 | -173.54568 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : H2O +-------------+--------------+--------------+---------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+---------------+------------| | Chemistry | 936462.21660 | 507596.05530 | -428866.16130 | -45.79642 | | Convection | -84086.22319 | -94693.82760 | -10607.60441 | 12.61515 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -20.21746 | | Mixing | -46728.32372 | -58943.77898 | -12215.45526 | 26.14144 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+---------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : H2O +-------------+--------------------+--------------------+-------------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------------+--------------------+-------------------+------------| | Chemistry | 22251.76532 | 22000.43514 | -251.33017 | -1.12948 | | Convection | -24336828628.99200 | -27459953079.09120 | -3123124450.09920 | 12.83291 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -38.53912 | | Mixing | -11987184771.07200 | -12607432615.52640 | -620247844.45440 | 5.17426 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------------+--------------------+-------------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : H2O +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -835977.10230 | -406442.11523 | 429534.98707 | -51.38119 | | Convection | 84086.22303 | 94693.82745 | 10607.60443 | 12.61515 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -48.36197 | | Mixing | 46728.32370 | 58943.77899 | 12215.45528 | 26.14144 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ H2O2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : H2O2 +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | 23812.40413 | 22179.24450 | -1633.15963 | -6.85844 | | Convection | -3524.67076 | -3607.58051 | -82.90975 | 2.35227 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 47.67623 | | Mixing | -7862.68907 | -7574.60675 | 288.08232 | -3.66392 | | WetDep | -12190.21186 | -10741.29162 | 1448.92024 | -11.88593 | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : H2O2 +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | 23823.20666 | 22186.53425 | -1636.67242 | -6.87008 | | Convection | -3524.67403 | -3607.58280 | -82.90877 | 2.35224 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 61.71592 | | Mixing | -7862.79893 | -7574.81730 | 287.98162 | -3.66258 | | WetDep | -12190.21186 | -10741.29097 | 1448.92089 | -11.88594 | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : H2O2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 7653.56266 | 7067.91180 | -585.65086 | -7.65200 | | Convection | 645.29872 | 711.80671 | 66.50799 | 10.30654 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -65.19947 | | Mixing | -6885.46541 | -6589.68727 | 295.77814 | -4.29569 | | WetDep | -837.85564 | -760.69682 | 77.15881 | -9.20908 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : H2O2 +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10.80253 | -7.28975 | 3.51278 | -32.51816 | | Convection | 0.00327 | 0.00229 | -0.00098 | -30.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -50.30505 | | Mixing | 0.10986 | 0.21056 | 0.10070 | 91.66667 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.00065 | -0.00065 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ HAC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HAC +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2107.53167 | 2012.66066 | -94.87101 | -4.50152 | | Convection | -113.31673 | -119.51586 | -6.19912 | 5.47062 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -45.36001 | | Mixing | -1186.39167 | -1057.91111 | 128.48056 | -10.82952 | | WetDep | -740.39933 | -754.98446 | -14.58513 | 1.96990 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HAC +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2107.94134 | 2013.15763 | -94.78371 | -4.49651 | | Convection | -113.31776 | -119.51692 | -6.19915 | 5.47059 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -49.20866 | | Mixing | -1186.39486 | -1057.92157 | 128.47329 | -10.82888 | | WetDep | -740.39933 | -754.98446 | -14.58513 | 1.96990 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HAC +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2023.30822 | 1981.03890 | -42.26932 | -2.08912 | | Convection | -4.70607 | 6.86594 | 11.57201 | -245.89525 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -90.32923 | | Mixing | -1243.00303 | -1117.67618 | 125.32685 | -10.08259 | | WetDep | -221.46413 | -180.40573 | 41.05841 | -18.53953 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HAC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.40967 | -0.49697 | -0.08730 | 21.30886 | | Convection | 0.00103 | 0.00106 | 0.00003 | 2.97030 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -17.07655 | | Mixing | 0.00319 | 0.01046 | 0.00727 | 228.20513 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HBR budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HBR +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 151.75004 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -24.59603 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -57.24141 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -65.45133 | -65.45133 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HBR +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 152.07740 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -24.59603 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -57.24106 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -65.45133 | -65.45133 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HBR +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 62.49006 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 1.09844 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -56.71562 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -9.07078 | -9.07078 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.32736 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00035 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ HBr budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HBr +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 132.68432 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -20.48282 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -49.34523 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -59.54434 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HBr +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 132.98614 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -20.48282 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -49.34469 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -59.54434 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HBr +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 53.06538 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 1.01328 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -48.77935 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -7.56205 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HBr +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.30182 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00054 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ HC5A budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HC5A +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 64.40339 | 62.99479 | -1.40860 | -2.18715 | | Convection | -4.62335 | -4.97863 | -0.35528 | 7.68450 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -128.11575 | | Mixing | -31.03092 | -28.36115 | 2.66977 | -8.60358 | | WetDep | -24.39155 | -25.22027 | -0.82871 | 3.39754 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HC5A +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 64.40371 | 62.99532 | -1.40840 | -2.18683 | | Convection | -4.62338 | -4.97866 | -0.35528 | 7.68432 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -128.17465 | | Mixing | -31.03092 | -28.36116 | 2.66976 | -8.60356 | | WetDep | -24.39155 | -25.22027 | -0.82871 | 3.39754 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HC5A +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 108.97876 | 114.07497 | 5.09621 | 4.67633 | | Convection | -5.16683 | -6.36388 | -1.19706 | 23.16812 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -253.21531 | | Mixing | -42.85801 | -40.72348 | 2.13452 | -4.98045 | | WetDep | -11.62436 | -10.67768 | 0.94668 | -8.14394 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HC5A +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00032 | -0.00053 | -0.00020 | 63.49206 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00002 | -0.00001 | -19.58763 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -223.17986 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 300.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HCFC123 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCFC123 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00170 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -115.36254 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1.30955 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -187.02622 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCFC123 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.02609 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -25.42768 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.63085 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -260.82709 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCFC123 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.49124 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.76419 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -78.33643 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 21.20146 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCFC123 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.19127 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -25.42768 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.07218 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -260.82709 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ HCFC141B budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCFC141B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -7.01547 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCFC141B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -6.03008 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00133 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.08771 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCFC141B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -1.05358 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 10.95949 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 3.33740 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCFC141B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.98539 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00133 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.08771 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ HCFC141b budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCFC141b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -7.12345 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCFC141b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -6.13673 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00090 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.07653 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCFC141b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.06164 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 9.07463 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 2.98436 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCFC141b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.98672 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00090 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.07653 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ HCFC142B budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCFC142B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -2.48156 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCFC142B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -2.28037 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00035 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.02421 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCFC142B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.48026 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 2.45282 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.75377 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCFC142B +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.20119 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00035 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.02421 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ HCFC142b budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCFC142b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.49496 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCFC142b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.29370 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00024 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.02563 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCFC142b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.48407 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 2.02409 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.67867 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCFC142b +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.20126 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00024 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.02563 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ HCFC22 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCFC22 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -27.99079 | -28.20945 | -0.21867 | 0.78120 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -32.85447 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 3.85222 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -132.32990 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCFC22 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -26.85898 | -27.08446 | -0.22548 | 0.83950 | | Convection | -0.00156 | -0.00241 | -0.00085 | 54.20488 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 6.24944 | | Mixing | -0.08469 | -0.20469 | -0.12000 | 141.68654 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCFC22 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -6.43027 | -6.38270 | 0.04757 | -0.73979 | | Convection | -23.84137 | -28.62664 | -4.78527 | 20.07127 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -118.14638 | | Mixing | -7.52984 | -8.52408 | -0.99424 | 13.20400 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCFC22 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.13180 | -1.12499 | 0.00681 | -0.60213 | | Convection | 0.00156 | 0.00241 | 0.00085 | 54.20488 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.94905 | | Mixing | 0.08469 | 0.20469 | 0.12000 | 141.68654 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ HCL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCL +-------------+-----------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 4280.59554 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -703.72867 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -2155.82641 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -1250.00367 | -1250.00367 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-------------+-------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCL +-------------+-----------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 4285.87158 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -703.72802 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -2154.47053 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -1250.00367 | -1250.00367 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCL +-------------+-----------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 2515.81913 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -75.21901 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -2167.16857 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -309.00140 | -309.00140 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -5.27604 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00065 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -1.35587 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ HCOOH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCOOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1354.56696 | 1388.72359 | 34.15663 | 2.52159 | | Convection | -196.17273 | -219.60311 | -23.43038 | 11.94375 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 20.26078 | | Mixing | -104.78050 | -46.61668 | 58.16382 | -55.51016 | | WetDep | -821.62519 | -862.74413 | -41.11893 | 5.00459 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCOOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1355.00933 | 1389.10907 | 34.09974 | 2.51657 | | Convection | -196.17337 | -219.60379 | -23.43042 | 11.94373 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 18.70548 | | Mixing | -104.80534 | -46.66007 | 58.14526 | -55.47930 | | WetDep | -821.62519 | -862.74413 | -41.11893 | 5.00459 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCOOH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 814.19911 | 801.83995 | -12.35916 | -1.51795 | | Convection | -21.98344 | -22.30605 | -0.32261 | 1.46752 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -71.98217 | | Mixing | -197.41969 | -138.83155 | 58.58814 | -29.67695 | | WetDep | -236.93465 | -208.01884 | 28.91582 | -12.20413 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCOOH +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.44237 | -0.38548 | 0.05689 | -12.86031 | | Convection | 0.00063 | 0.00067 | 0.00004 | 6.45161 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 42.07148 | | Mixing | 0.02484 | 0.04339 | 0.01855 | 74.70177 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HCl budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HCl +-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 3680.31189 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -591.13534 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1880.48300 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -1079.47825 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HCl +-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 3682.16506 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -591.13468 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1879.21769 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -1079.47825 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HCl +-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 2279.40079 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -97.12102 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1908.75774 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -296.46411 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.85317 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00065 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1.26531 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ HI budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 3.24009 | 3.02111 | -0.21897 | -6.75830 | | Convection | -0.60158 | -0.59314 | 0.00843 | -1.40182 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.73890 | | Mixing | -0.90431 | -0.83694 | 0.06737 | -7.44988 | | WetDep | -1.67909 | -1.51909 | 0.16000 | -9.52888 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 3.23728 | 3.01959 | -0.21769 | -6.72443 | | Convection | -0.60158 | -0.59314 | 0.00843 | -1.40190 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.29848 | | Mixing | -0.90433 | -0.83698 | 0.06735 | -7.44752 | | WetDep | -1.67909 | -1.51909 | 0.16000 | -9.52888 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.83301 | 0.74945 | -0.08356 | -10.03125 | | Convection | 0.08870 | 0.09135 | 0.00265 | 2.98981 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -53.44968 | | Mixing | -0.82720 | -0.77353 | 0.05367 | -6.48808 | | WetDep | -0.12224 | -0.09209 | 0.03015 | -24.66663 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00281 | 0.00152 | -0.00129 | -45.80396 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.65010 | | Mixing | 0.00002 | 0.00004 | 0.00002 | 89.78102 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HMHP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HMHP +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 715.54452 | 723.42155 | 7.87704 | 1.10085 | | Convection | -90.91823 | -97.64749 | -6.72927 | 7.40145 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -226.85426 | | Mixing | -378.21087 | -365.17807 | 13.03280 | -3.44591 | | WetDep | -209.96548 | -223.01742 | -13.05195 | 6.21624 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HMHP +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 715.56013 | 723.44452 | 7.88439 | 1.10185 | | Convection | -90.91827 | -97.64753 | -6.72927 | 7.40145 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -226.16284 | | Mixing | -378.21100 | -365.17860 | 13.03239 | -3.44580 | | WetDep | -209.96548 | -223.01742 | -13.05195 | 6.21624 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HMHP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 357.21170 | 359.50981 | 2.29811 | 0.64335 | | Convection | -4.24785 | -0.36370 | 3.88415 | -91.43809 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -80.21377 | | Mixing | -387.95759 | -376.44758 | 11.51002 | -2.96682 | | WetDep | -55.54139 | -46.34585 | 9.19554 | -16.55619 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HMHP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01561 | -0.02297 | -0.00736 | 47.12042 | | Convection | 0.00004 | 0.00004 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -73.48742 | | Mixing | 0.00012 | 0.00053 | 0.00041 | 333.33333 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HMML budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HMML +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 229.42667 | 215.93572 | -13.49094 | -5.88029 | | Convection | -29.57060 | -30.41118 | -0.84058 | 2.84263 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -204.57056 | | Mixing | -86.98674 | -71.66327 | 15.32347 | -17.61587 | | WetDep | -97.68555 | -98.07680 | -0.39125 | 0.40052 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HMML +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 229.45820 | 215.97397 | -13.48422 | -5.87655 | | Convection | -29.57064 | -30.41122 | -0.84058 | 2.84263 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -185.42065 | | Mixing | -86.98714 | -71.66429 | 15.32284 | -17.61507 | | WetDep | -97.68555 | -98.07680 | -0.39125 | 0.40052 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HMML +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 193.29530 | 183.90803 | -9.38727 | -4.85644 | | Convection | -1.47612 | -0.27018 | 1.20594 | -81.69676 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -84.33874 | | Mixing | -97.44689 | -81.82250 | 15.62439 | -16.03375 | | WetDep | -25.49142 | -19.36723 | 6.12419 | -24.02452 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HMML +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03153 | -0.03825 | -0.00672 | 21.32210 | | Convection | 0.00004 | 0.00004 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 75.24669 | | Mixing | 0.00040 | 0.00103 | 0.00063 | 157.69231 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HNO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HNO2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -8.96594 | -8.76357 | 0.20237 | -2.25712 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -321.22620 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 16.10012 | | Mixing | 4.36747 | 4.61066 | 0.24319 | 5.56814 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HNO2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -8.87328 | -8.69423 | 0.17905 | -2.01788 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | 194.59265 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 18.81723 | | Mixing | 4.36446 | 4.60751 | 0.24305 | 5.56889 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HNO2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 6.86947 | 12.45492 | 5.58545 | 81.30822 | | Convection | -5.64519 | -8.73384 | -3.08865 | 54.71283 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -141.75746 | | Mixing | -10.97992 | -12.43673 | -1.45681 | 13.26796 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HNO2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.09266 | -0.06934 | 0.02332 | -25.16574 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 194.59265 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 6.76728 | | Mixing | 0.00302 | 0.00315 | 0.00014 | 4.47951 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HNO3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | 16119.68622 | 14795.37174 | -1324.31448 | -8.21551 | | Convection | -1394.11472 | -1390.40707 | 3.70765 | -0.26595 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -6.87883 | | Mixing | -7553.42607 | -6692.89395 | 860.53212 | -11.39261 | | WetDep | -6982.71762 | -6405.05880 | 577.65882 | -8.27269 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HNO3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | 14515.80328 | 13438.76737 | -1077.03591 | -7.41975 | | Convection | -1394.09739 | -1390.38582 | 3.71157 | -0.26623 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1.85260 | | Mixing | -7546.36061 | -6685.40410 | 860.95651 | -11.40890 | | WetDep | -6982.11733 | -6404.68019 | 577.43715 | -8.27023 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HNO3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 7545.17443 | 6767.89045 | -777.28397 | -10.30174 | | Convection | 181.81042 | 110.24374 | -71.56668 | -39.36335 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 17.28953 | | Mixing | -7198.53872 | -6264.41403 | 934.12470 | -12.97659 | | WetDep | -717.11504 | -545.65538 | 171.45965 | -23.90964 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HNO3 +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 1603.88294 | 1356.60437 | -247.27857 | -15.41749 | | Convection | -0.01733 | -0.02125 | -0.00392 | 22.64151 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -5.13639 | | Mixing | -7.06546 | -7.48984 | -0.42439 | 6.00648 | | WetDep | -0.60029 | -0.37861 | 0.22167 | -36.92810 | +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ HNO4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HNO4 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -28.83360 | -27.45081 | 1.38279 | -4.79577 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -15.76150 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -2.40584 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -57.70685 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HNO4 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -18.34766 | -14.97783 | 3.36984 | -18.36656 | | Convection | 0.00022 | 0.00024 | 0.00002 | 9.13023 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 4.80840 | | Mixing | 0.02902 | 0.02314 | -0.00588 | -20.25731 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HNO4 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -17.50373 | -15.48271 | 2.02102 | -11.54621 | | Convection | 6.38213 | 7.98435 | 1.60222 | 25.10483 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -171.63247 | | Mixing | -5.16983 | -4.41098 | 0.75885 | -14.67847 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HNO4 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10.48594 | -12.47298 | -1.98704 | 18.94960 | | Convection | -0.00022 | -0.00024 | -0.00002 | 9.13023 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.96795 | | Mixing | -0.02902 | -0.02314 | 0.00588 | -20.25731 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ HOBR budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HOBR +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 22.78842 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.78154 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -15.63619 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -8.28262 | -8.28262 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HOBR +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 12.94770 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.78149 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -15.62037 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -8.28262 | -8.28262 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HOBR +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 27.18604 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -5.76236 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -20.29919 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -4.08498 | -4.08498 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HOBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 9.84072 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00005 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.01582 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ HOBr budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HOBr +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 16.42875 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.57307 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -12.29313 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -6.19158 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HOBr +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 7.22211 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.57303 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -12.27912 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -6.19158 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HOBr +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 20.62721 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -4.36857 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -15.21791 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -3.04828 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HOBr +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 9.20663 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00004 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.01402 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ HOCL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HOCL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 22.54711 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.54775 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -7.87328 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -7.65043 | -7.65043 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HOCL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 14.91064 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.54773 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -7.84646 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -7.65043 | -7.65043 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HOCL +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 13.89989 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -2.64091 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -10.49162 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -3.37281 | -3.37281 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HOCL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 7.63647 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00002 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.02682 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ HOCl budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HOCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 20.48116 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.44025 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -6.51472 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -6.13457 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HOCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.39082 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.44020 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -6.48339 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -6.13457 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HOCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 11.79544 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -2.09315 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -8.44950 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -2.85174 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HOCl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.09035 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00004 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.03133 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ HOI budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HOI +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -81.97236 | -90.60952 | -8.63716 | 10.53668 | | Convection | -22.73703 | -23.23877 | -0.50174 | 2.20670 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 26.05005 | | Mixing | 143.60428 | 152.30462 | 8.70034 | 6.05855 | | WetDep | -38.73045 | -38.06195 | 0.66849 | -1.72602 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HOI +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -82.02933 | -90.65121 | -8.62188 | 10.51072 | | Convection | -22.73704 | -23.23877 | -0.50173 | 2.20668 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 54.22131 | | Mixing | 143.60233 | 152.30224 | 8.69992 | 6.05834 | | WetDep | -38.73045 | -38.06195 | 0.66849 | -1.72602 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HOI +-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -98.17800 | -106.00691 | -7.82891 | 7.97420 | | Convection | -11.97975 | -12.35415 | -0.37440 | 3.12525 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -111.14351 | | Mixing | 124.13997 | 131.62569 | 7.48571 | 6.03006 | | WetDep | -16.00169 | -14.60995 | 1.39174 | -8.69744 | +-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HOI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.05697 | 0.04169 | -0.01529 | -26.82927 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00001 | -200.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -17.26666 | | Mixing | 0.00195 | 0.00237 | 0.00042 | 21.46597 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HONIT budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HONIT +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 59.35957 | 51.51908 | -7.84049 | -13.20848 | | Convection | -5.24110 | -4.41023 | 0.83087 | -15.85291 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -432.18821 | | Mixing | -39.74239 | -34.63752 | 5.10487 | -12.84489 | | WetDep | -13.92043 | -12.09911 | 1.82131 | -13.08375 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HONIT +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 59.37852 | 51.53542 | -7.84309 | -13.20864 | | Convection | -5.24111 | -4.41025 | 0.83086 | -15.85281 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -396.13480 | | Mixing | -39.74262 | -34.63789 | 5.10473 | -12.84448 | | WetDep | -13.92043 | -12.09911 | 1.82131 | -13.08375 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HONIT +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 81.57450 | 81.14831 | -0.42618 | -0.52245 | | Convection | -4.59902 | -5.06359 | -0.46457 | 10.10152 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -164.71443 | | Mixing | -51.04856 | -45.36801 | 5.68056 | -11.12775 | | WetDep | -7.07196 | -5.62544 | 1.44652 | -20.45431 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HONIT +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01895 | -0.01635 | 0.00260 | -13.72338 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 40.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 30.05479 | | Mixing | 0.00023 | 0.00037 | 0.00013 | 57.14286 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HPALD1 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HPALD1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | 23.38435 | 20.51408 | -2.87027 | -12.27432 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.98475 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1925.70680 | | Mixing | -21.14598 | -18.31106 | 2.83492 | -13.40644 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ Trop [Gg] : HPALD1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | 23.38446 | 20.51420 | -2.87026 | -12.27420 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00002 | -0.00000 | 20.06923 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1895.50937 | | Mixing | -21.14598 | -18.31106 | 2.83492 | -13.40644 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ PBL [Gg] : HPALD1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 40.91011 | 39.95935 | -0.95075 | -2.32401 | | Convection | -2.36414 | -3.11117 | -0.74704 | 31.59864 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -121.82296 | | Mixing | -24.83748 | -22.29729 | 2.54019 | -10.22726 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HPALD1 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00011 | -0.00012 | -0.00001 | 12.79070 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00002 | 0.00000 | 20.06923 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -94.01048 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HPALD2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HPALD2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 72.76142 | 63.03761 | -9.72381 | -13.36396 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -7.55628 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -621.86712 | | Mixing | -66.07202 | -56.61231 | 9.45971 | -14.31727 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HPALD2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 72.76186 | 63.03810 | -9.72377 | -13.36383 | | Convection | -0.00006 | -0.00006 | -0.00000 | 0.81227 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -619.68316 | | Mixing | -66.07203 | -56.61231 | 9.45971 | -14.31728 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HPALD2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 162.57427 | 162.02066 | -0.55361 | -0.34053 | | Convection | -8.99602 | -11.98284 | -2.98682 | 33.20157 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -68.46166 | | Mixing | -82.42969 | -73.83223 | 8.59746 | -10.43006 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HPALD2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00045 | -0.00049 | -0.00004 | 7.95455 | | Convection | 0.00006 | 0.00006 | 0.00000 | 0.81227 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -115.46269 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | -0.00001 | -50.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HPALD3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HPALD3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 20.39258 | 18.79661 | -1.59597 | -7.82623 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 25.66748 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -123.72019 | | Mixing | -18.33405 | -16.69704 | 1.63701 | -8.92880 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HPALD3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 20.39269 | 18.79674 | -1.59595 | -7.82608 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00002 | -0.00000 | 14.47981 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -123.72222 | | Mixing | -18.33406 | -16.69705 | 1.63701 | -8.92879 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HPALD3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 36.05040 | 37.27053 | 1.22013 | 3.38451 | | Convection | -2.19449 | -2.57678 | -0.38228 | 17.42019 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -144.20651 | | Mixing | -21.85053 | -20.57993 | 1.27061 | -5.81499 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HPALD3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00011 | -0.00013 | -0.00002 | 17.97753 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00002 | 0.00000 | 14.47981 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -168.04711 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 100.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HPALD4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HPALD4 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 50.41463 | 46.26971 | -4.14492 | -8.22166 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 19.61490 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -148.17505 | | Mixing | -45.27700 | -41.12565 | 4.15135 | -9.16878 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HPALD4 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 50.41496 | 46.27005 | -4.14490 | -8.22157 | | Convection | -0.00004 | -0.00004 | 0.00000 | -4.19762 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -148.15836 | | Mixing | -45.27700 | -41.12566 | 4.15134 | -9.16876 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HPALD4 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 119.87424 | 124.13648 | 4.26224 | 3.55560 | | Convection | -6.24817 | -7.68428 | -1.43611 | 22.98441 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -117.91475 | | Mixing | -56.12807 | -52.93295 | 3.19512 | -5.69255 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HPALD4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00033 | -0.00034 | -0.00002 | 4.68750 | | Convection | 0.00004 | 0.00004 | -0.00000 | -4.19762 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -41.55897 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ HPETHNL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : HPETHNL +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 80.56020 | 79.48310 | -1.07710 | -1.33701 | | Convection | -12.62051 | -13.46443 | -0.84392 | 6.68691 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -93.30311 | | Mixing | -39.47227 | -36.65445 | 2.81782 | -7.13873 | | WetDep | -24.64468 | -25.46731 | -0.82264 | 3.33799 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : HPETHNL +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 80.56039 | 79.48335 | -1.07704 | -1.33693 | | Convection | -12.62052 | -13.46444 | -0.84392 | 6.68689 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -93.30033 | | Mixing | -39.47227 | -36.65445 | 2.81782 | -7.13873 | | WetDep | -24.64468 | -25.46731 | -0.82264 | 3.33799 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : HPETHNL +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 84.81374 | 86.60639 | 1.79265 | 2.11364 | | Convection | -3.61810 | -3.99801 | -0.37992 | 10.50041 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -114.33618 | | Mixing | -45.89119 | -43.57966 | 2.31152 | -5.03696 | | WetDep | -10.59172 | -9.40752 | 1.18420 | -11.18045 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : HPETHNL +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00019 | -0.00025 | -0.00006 | 28.94737 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | -0.00000 | -33.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -78.83111 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ I budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : I +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.09005 | 0.18135 | 0.09131 | 101.39794 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -48.56695 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 9.58908 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 383.57593 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : I +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.16346 | 0.25699 | 0.09354 | 57.22492 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 1.96355 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 10.95240 | | Mixing | -0.00044 | -0.00082 | -0.00037 | 83.63848 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : I +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.18316 | 1.32028 | 0.13712 | 11.58923 | | Convection | -0.49821 | -0.57484 | -0.07663 | 15.38106 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -86.58276 | | Mixing | -0.80067 | -0.82143 | -0.02076 | 2.59261 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : I +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.07341 | -0.07564 | -0.00223 | 3.04033 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 1.96355 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.28165 | | Mixing | 0.00044 | 0.00082 | 0.00037 | 83.63848 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ I2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : I2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -12.72679 | -13.24185 | -0.51506 | 4.04708 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 65.18110 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1.50753 | | Mixing | 12.72227 | 13.23708 | 0.51481 | 4.04655 | | WetDep | -0.00246 | -0.00254 | -0.00008 | 3.21002 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : I2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -12.72658 | -13.24152 | -0.51494 | 4.04620 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 64.94331 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.32009 | | Mixing | 12.72226 | 13.23707 | 0.51481 | 4.04654 | | WetDep | -0.00246 | -0.00254 | -0.00008 | 3.21002 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : I2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -11.53438 | -11.94201 | -0.40763 | 3.53408 | | Convection | -0.43685 | -0.46193 | -0.02507 | 5.73924 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -64.32388 | | Mixing | 12.02696 | 12.49922 | 0.47226 | 3.92664 | | WetDep | -0.00211 | -0.00208 | 0.00002 | -1.16424 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : I2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00021 | -0.00033 | -0.00012 | 57.92683 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 56.23273 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 15.15687 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 28.57143 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ I2O2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : I2O2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.11061 | 0.12865 | 0.01805 | 16.31797 | | Convection | -0.02194 | -0.02419 | -0.00225 | 10.26144 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.90219 | | Mixing | -0.04471 | -0.05013 | -0.00543 | 12.13506 | | WetDep | -0.03469 | -0.03885 | -0.00416 | 11.98402 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : I2O2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.10968 | 0.12845 | 0.01877 | 17.11383 | | Convection | -0.02194 | -0.02419 | -0.00225 | 10.26124 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 12.34246 | | Mixing | -0.04474 | -0.05019 | -0.00545 | 12.18685 | | WetDep | -0.03469 | -0.03885 | -0.00416 | 11.98402 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : I2O2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.08712 | 0.09310 | 0.00598 | 6.86478 | | Convection | -0.00919 | -0.01143 | -0.00224 | 24.34208 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 333.31549 | | Mixing | -0.06222 | -0.06775 | -0.00553 | 8.88280 | | WetDep | -0.01337 | -0.01297 | 0.00040 | -2.98003 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : I2O2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00093 | 0.00020 | -0.00072 | -77.92644 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 24.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.85580 | | Mixing | 0.00003 | 0.00006 | 0.00003 | 93.32168 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ I2O3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : I2O3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 5.99431 | 7.02464 | 1.03032 | 17.18831 | | Convection | -1.31804 | -1.57177 | -0.25373 | 19.25066 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -36.36081 | | Mixing | -3.00122 | -3.43598 | -0.43476 | 14.48625 | | WetDep | -1.69931 | -2.00320 | -0.30390 | 17.88362 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : I2O3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 5.99121 | 7.02162 | 1.03041 | 17.19873 | | Convection | -1.31804 | -1.57177 | -0.25373 | 19.25066 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -426.03420 | | Mixing | -3.00120 | -3.43598 | -0.43477 | 14.48666 | | WetDep | -1.69931 | -2.00320 | -0.30390 | 17.88362 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : I2O3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 5.46636 | 6.32558 | 0.85923 | 15.71845 | | Convection | -0.83441 | -0.94007 | -0.10566 | 12.66303 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 74.94487 | | Mixing | -3.83111 | -4.42402 | -0.59290 | 15.47599 | | WetDep | -0.92001 | -1.02442 | -0.10442 | 11.34942 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : I2O3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00310 | 0.00301 | -0.00009 | -2.92061 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -6.28363 | | Mixing | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 0.00001 | -76.19048 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ I2O4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : I2O4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.40885 | 0.61748 | 0.20862 | 51.02605 | | Convection | -0.07266 | -0.11023 | -0.03757 | 51.70372 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -20.32432 | | Mixing | -0.22852 | -0.32305 | -0.09453 | 41.36598 | | WetDep | -0.10861 | -0.18053 | -0.07192 | 66.22236 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : I2O4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.40902 | 0.61761 | 0.20859 | 50.99777 | | Convection | -0.07266 | -0.11023 | -0.03757 | 51.70373 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 2163.58950 | | Mixing | -0.22852 | -0.32305 | -0.09453 | 41.36657 | | WetDep | -0.10861 | -0.18053 | -0.07192 | 66.22236 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : I2O4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.45573 | 0.66241 | 0.20668 | 45.35156 | | Convection | -0.07173 | -0.09933 | -0.02760 | 38.48219 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -39.29515 | | Mixing | -0.29883 | -0.42165 | -0.12282 | 41.10178 | | WetDep | -0.07378 | -0.10986 | -0.03608 | 48.89530 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : I2O4 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00016 | -0.00013 | 0.00003 | -19.99510 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 100.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -9.29223 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -92.15686 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ IBR budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.15285 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00029 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.14151 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.08606 | -0.08606 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.15290 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00029 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.14151 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.08606 | -0.08606 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 3.07524 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -1.24903 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -1.43936 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.06148 | -0.06148 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IBR +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00005 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ IBr budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IBr +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.13460 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00018 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.13566 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.08047 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IBr +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.13464 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00018 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.13566 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.08047 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IBr +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 2.78427 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -1.19713 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -1.40623 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.06181 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IBr +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00005 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ ICHE budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ICHE +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 424.61954 | 432.53700 | 7.91746 | 1.86460 | | Convection | -43.44610 | -46.36120 | -2.91510 | 6.70969 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -79.58993 | | Mixing | -277.92548 | -277.13992 | 0.78557 | -0.28265 | | WetDep | -89.22059 | -94.42645 | -5.20586 | 5.83482 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ICHE +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 424.62212 | 432.54067 | 7.91856 | 1.86485 | | Convection | -43.44612 | -46.36122 | -2.91509 | 6.70967 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -79.68059 | | Mixing | -277.92552 | -277.14002 | 0.78550 | -0.28263 | | WetDep | -89.22059 | -94.42645 | -5.20586 | 5.83482 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ICHE +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 421.33828 | 432.63402 | 11.29574 | 2.68092 | | Convection | -4.13477 | -1.57546 | 2.55931 | -61.89726 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -71.92120 | | Mixing | -287.82914 | -286.36018 | 1.46896 | -0.51036 | | WetDep | -29.19333 | -23.39316 | 5.80016 | -19.86812 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ICHE +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00257 | -0.00368 | -0.00110 | 42.85714 | | Convection | 0.00002 | 0.00002 | -0.00001 | -25.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -12.51100 | | Mixing | 0.00004 | 0.00010 | 0.00006 | 150.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ICL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ICL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 3.92273 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00387 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -2.73933 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -1.48765 | -1.48765 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ICL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 3.89666 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00388 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -2.73929 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -1.48765 | -1.48765 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ICL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 18.09004 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -6.09889 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -9.23130 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -1.11508 | -1.11508 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ICL +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.02608 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00004 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ ICN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ICN +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 159.45898 | 127.18514 | -32.27384 | -20.23959 | | Convection | -11.95478 | -10.15208 | 1.80270 | -15.07933 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 21.11826 | | Mixing | -90.43519 | -68.05097 | 22.38422 | -24.75167 | | WetDep | -49.26198 | -42.41291 | 6.84907 | -13.90335 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ICN +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 159.45945 | 127.18557 | -32.27388 | -20.23955 | | Convection | -11.95480 | -10.15210 | 1.80270 | -15.07933 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 21.12214 | | Mixing | -90.43519 | -68.05097 | 22.38422 | -24.75167 | | WetDep | -49.26198 | -42.41291 | 6.84907 | -13.90335 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ICN +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 103.34505 | 71.21736 | -32.12769 | -31.08778 | | Convection | -3.29531 | -3.84537 | -0.55006 | 16.69225 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 406.39607 | | Mixing | -91.11423 | -68.92106 | 22.19317 | -24.35752 | | WetDep | -19.48903 | -15.01435 | 4.47468 | -22.95998 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ICN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00047 | -0.00043 | 0.00004 | -8.69565 | | Convection | 0.00002 | 0.00002 | -0.00000 | -13.88889 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 6.48101 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ICPDH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ICPDH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 106.99403 | 110.15870 | 3.16467 | 2.95780 | | Convection | -11.53973 | -12.43768 | -0.89795 | 7.78139 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -149.17672 | | Mixing | -65.72014 | -66.28267 | -0.56252 | 0.85594 | | WetDep | -25.61870 | -27.00364 | -1.38494 | 5.40596 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ICPDH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 106.99870 | 110.16328 | 3.16458 | 2.95759 | | Convection | -11.53973 | -12.43769 | -0.89795 | 7.78139 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -147.01905 | | Mixing | -65.72017 | -66.28278 | -0.56260 | 0.85606 | | WetDep | -25.61870 | -27.00364 | -1.38494 | 5.40596 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ICPDH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 101.14405 | 105.17704 | 4.03299 | 3.98737 | | Convection | -0.39186 | 0.48051 | 0.87238 | -222.62259 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -169.48569 | | Mixing | -66.96535 | -67.45297 | -0.48762 | 0.72817 | | WetDep | -6.80081 | -5.24981 | 1.55100 | -22.80609 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ICPDH +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00467 | -0.00458 | 0.00009 | -1.96937 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 11.44419 | | Mixing | 0.00003 | 0.00011 | 0.00008 | 266.66667 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ICl budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ICl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 3.75264 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00234 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -2.66165 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -1.42199 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ICl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 3.72678 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00234 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -2.66157 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -1.42199 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ICl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 16.56265 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -5.78309 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -8.95178 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -1.13126 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ICl +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.02587 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00008 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ IDC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IDC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 41.71676 | 38.57846 | -3.13830 | -7.52288 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 210.49115 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -61.26532 | | Mixing | -36.38099 | -33.00579 | 3.37520 | -9.27738 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IDC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 41.71786 | 38.58115 | -3.13670 | -7.51885 | | Convection | -0.00004 | -0.00004 | 0.00000 | -3.41266 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -61.06228 | | Mixing | -36.38100 | -33.00585 | 3.37515 | -9.27723 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IDC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 73.26609 | 80.16889 | 6.90280 | 9.42155 | | Convection | -4.17946 | -3.98936 | 0.19009 | -4.54831 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 56.57206 | | Mixing | -44.22293 | -41.30587 | 2.91706 | -6.59625 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IDC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00109 | -0.00269 | -0.00160 | 146.26168 | | Convection | 0.00004 | 0.00004 | -0.00000 | -3.41266 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -289.61943 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00006 | 0.00005 | 666.66667 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IDCHP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IDCHP +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 73.31104 | 71.38116 | -1.92988 | -2.63245 | | Convection | -7.27846 | -7.52711 | -0.24865 | 3.41621 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -132.38991 | | Mixing | -47.17622 | -44.63720 | 2.53902 | -5.38199 | | WetDep | -16.17993 | -16.42661 | -0.24668 | 1.52460 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IDCHP +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 73.31116 | 71.38147 | -1.92969 | -2.63219 | | Convection | -7.27847 | -7.52711 | -0.24865 | 3.41622 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -132.38834 | | Mixing | -47.17622 | -44.63721 | 2.53902 | -5.38198 | | WetDep | -16.17993 | -16.42661 | -0.24668 | 1.52460 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IDCHP +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 73.11790 | 72.39048 | -0.72742 | -0.99487 | | Convection | -0.57630 | -0.11799 | 0.45831 | -79.52550 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -19.06105 | | Mixing | -48.42130 | -45.80080 | 2.62050 | -5.41187 | | WetDep | -4.93016 | -3.69242 | 1.23774 | -25.10543 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IDCHP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00012 | -0.00031 | -0.00019 | 160.86957 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 16.66667 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -62.23404 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IDHDP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IDHDP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 199.62029 | 212.80449 | 13.18420 | 6.60464 | | Convection | -21.24941 | -23.75658 | -2.50717 | 11.79879 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 1628.05196 | | Mixing | -112.37292 | -116.74541 | -4.37249 | 3.89105 | | WetDep | -56.76139 | -62.00027 | -5.23888 | 9.22966 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IDHDP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 199.62916 | 212.81358 | 13.18443 | 6.60446 | | Convection | -21.24942 | -23.75659 | -2.50717 | 11.79879 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 1559.36921 | | Mixing | -112.37297 | -116.74560 | -4.37263 | 3.89118 | | WetDep | -56.76139 | -62.00027 | -5.23888 | 9.22966 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IDHDP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 173.40748 | 186.54290 | 13.13542 | 7.57489 | | Convection | 1.57637 | 3.73913 | 2.16275 | 137.19788 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -370.55018 | | Mixing | -112.89446 | -117.18408 | -4.28961 | 3.79967 | | WetDep | -10.90721 | -8.09629 | 2.81092 | -25.77119 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IDHDP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00887 | -0.00909 | -0.00022 | 2.53456 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00002 | 0.00000 | 20.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.85456 | | Mixing | 0.00005 | 0.00019 | 0.00014 | 280.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IDHPE budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IDHPE +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1062.10755 | 1098.48861 | 36.38106 | 3.42536 | | Convection | -120.85264 | -132.07809 | -11.22545 | 9.28854 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -235.79151 | | Mixing | -639.80787 | -642.13422 | -2.32635 | 0.36360 | | WetDep | -261.15360 | -280.01189 | -18.85829 | 7.22115 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IDHPE +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1062.12684 | 1098.51493 | 36.38808 | 3.42596 | | Convection | -120.85270 | -132.07814 | -11.22545 | 9.28854 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -235.24869 | | Mixing | -639.80803 | -642.13479 | -2.32676 | 0.36367 | | WetDep | -261.15360 | -280.01189 | -18.85829 | 7.22115 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IDHPE +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 939.06406 | 969.94135 | 30.87729 | 3.28809 | | Convection | -1.41291 | 7.63027 | 9.04318 | -640.04133 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -250.68569 | | Mixing | -645.28507 | -646.89793 | -1.61286 | 0.24995 | | WetDep | -66.70057 | -51.70557 | 14.99499 | -22.48106 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IDHPE +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01929 | -0.02632 | -0.00703 | 36.44068 | | Convection | 0.00005 | 0.00005 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 210.07511 | | Mixing | 0.00016 | 0.00057 | 0.00041 | 250.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IDN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IDN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 72.42328 | 65.65081 | -6.77248 | -9.35124 | | Convection | -3.00010 | -2.59509 | 0.40501 | -13.49996 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 26.85116 | | Mixing | -56.72785 | -51.96328 | 4.76457 | -8.39900 | | WetDep | -10.74034 | -9.38715 | 1.35319 | -12.59913 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IDN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 72.42664 | 65.65417 | -6.77247 | -9.35079 | | Convection | -3.00010 | -2.59509 | 0.40501 | -13.49994 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 26.58712 | | Mixing | -56.72788 | -51.96334 | 4.76453 | -8.39893 | | WetDep | -10.74034 | -9.38715 | 1.35319 | -12.59913 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IDN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 98.64266 | 94.96683 | -3.67583 | -3.72641 | | Convection | -2.04554 | -5.24495 | -3.19941 | 156.40928 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -183.85953 | | Mixing | -61.92987 | -57.01570 | 4.91417 | -7.93506 | | WetDep | -6.53550 | -5.38817 | 1.14733 | -17.55534 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IDN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00335 | -0.00336 | -0.00001 | 0.30488 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 3.84615 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 61.71158 | | Mixing | 0.00003 | 0.00007 | 0.00004 | 116.66667 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IEPOXA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IEPOXA +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2452.93263 | 2557.97368 | 105.04105 | 4.28226 | | Convection | -273.97378 | -298.22788 | -24.25410 | 8.85271 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -495.98271 | | Mixing | -1615.50220 | -1649.66946 | -34.16726 | 2.11496 | | WetDep | -565.24686 | -606.57615 | -41.32929 | 7.31172 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IEPOXA +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2453.00832 | 2558.05983 | 105.05151 | 4.28256 | | Convection | -273.97391 | -298.22800 | -24.25410 | 8.85270 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -645.56944 | | Mixing | -1615.50253 | -1649.67044 | -34.16791 | 2.11500 | | WetDep | -565.24686 | -606.57615 | -41.32929 | 7.31172 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IEPOXA +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2597.52112 | 2722.97646 | 125.45535 | 4.82981 | | Convection | -14.77913 | 5.22744 | 20.00657 | -135.37041 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 61.94096 | | Mixing | -1667.99616 | -1698.34869 | -30.35253 | 1.81970 | | WetDep | -164.33582 | -128.92103 | 35.41479 | -21.55025 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IEPOXA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.07569 | -0.08615 | -0.01046 | 13.82289 | | Convection | 0.00012 | 0.00012 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 15.04198 | | Mixing | 0.00033 | 0.00098 | 0.00065 | 200.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IEPOXB budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IEPOXB +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1378.04939 | 1431.08364 | 53.03425 | 3.84850 | | Convection | -151.50926 | -164.72375 | -13.21448 | 8.72190 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 93.06621 | | Mixing | -887.65567 | -901.10668 | -13.45102 | 1.51534 | | WetDep | -320.76302 | -343.73211 | -22.96909 | 7.16077 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IEPOXB +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1378.08012 | 1431.11633 | 53.03621 | 3.84856 | | Convection | -151.50932 | -164.72381 | -13.21448 | 8.72190 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 91.06473 | | Mixing | -887.65583 | -901.10750 | -13.45167 | 1.51541 | | WetDep | -320.76302 | -343.73211 | -22.96909 | 7.16077 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IEPOXB +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1422.43327 | 1483.39859 | 60.96531 | 4.28599 | | Convection | -6.12241 | 5.33410 | 11.45652 | -187.12420 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -262.64568 | | Mixing | -914.11778 | -925.27260 | -11.15482 | 1.22028 | | WetDep | -90.19882 | -70.05708 | 20.14173 | -22.33037 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IEPOXB +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03073 | -0.03270 | -0.00196 | 6.38298 | | Convection | 0.00006 | 0.00006 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 18.78632 | | Mixing | 0.00016 | 0.00082 | 0.00065 | 400.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IEPOXD budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IEPOXD +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 128.97438 | 132.95046 | 3.97608 | 3.08284 | | Convection | -14.13724 | -15.27044 | -1.13320 | 8.01574 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -109.41127 | | Mixing | -84.50508 | -85.25908 | -0.75400 | 0.89225 | | WetDep | -29.27124 | -31.07353 | -1.80228 | 6.15718 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IEPOXD +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 128.97786 | 132.95445 | 3.97659 | 3.08316 | | Convection | -14.13724 | -15.27045 | -1.13320 | 8.01574 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -108.83123 | | Mixing | -84.50509 | -85.25915 | -0.75406 | 0.89233 | | WetDep | -29.27124 | -31.07353 | -1.80228 | 6.15718 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IEPOXD +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 136.02459 | 141.32747 | 5.30288 | 3.89847 | | Convection | -0.79518 | 0.23162 | 1.02679 | -129.12745 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -95.91307 | | Mixing | -87.38257 | -87.91824 | -0.53567 | 0.61302 | | WetDep | -8.59112 | -6.67341 | 1.91771 | -22.32195 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IEPOXD +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00347 | -0.00398 | -0.00051 | 14.70588 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 28.42180 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00007 | 0.00006 | 600.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IHN1 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IHN1 +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.24499 | 18.19557 | -5.04942 | -21.72262 | | Convection | -1.96448 | -1.53765 | 0.42683 | -21.72734 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -363.33643 | | Mixing | -12.84411 | -9.62637 | 3.21774 | -25.05224 | | WetDep | -7.09771 | -5.95143 | 1.14629 | -16.15009 | +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IHN1 +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.24504 | 18.19563 | -5.04941 | -21.72253 | | Convection | -1.96448 | -1.53765 | 0.42683 | -21.72730 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -363.26142 | | Mixing | -12.84411 | -9.62637 | 3.21774 | -25.05224 | | WetDep | -7.09771 | -5.95143 | 1.14629 | -16.15009 | +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IHN1 +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 18.80262 | 13.43273 | -5.36989 | -28.55928 | | Convection | -0.30096 | 0.09120 | 0.39216 | -130.30115 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -23.37162 | | Mixing | -12.78377 | -9.58200 | 3.20177 | -25.04558 | | WetDep | -2.62671 | -1.95996 | 0.66675 | -25.38330 | +-------------+-----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IHN1 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00005 | -0.00006 | -0.00001 | 20.00000 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 5.88235 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 918.49530 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IHN2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IHN2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 81.55035 | 77.89975 | -3.65061 | -4.47650 | | Convection | -3.73829 | -3.41747 | 0.32081 | -8.58186 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -25.73851 | | Mixing | -65.59553 | -62.95500 | 2.64053 | -4.02548 | | WetDep | -10.07449 | -9.51798 | 0.55651 | -5.52394 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IHN2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 81.55105 | 77.90034 | -3.65071 | -4.47659 | | Convection | -3.73829 | -3.41747 | 0.32082 | -8.58188 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -25.58384 | | Mixing | -65.59554 | -62.95501 | 2.64053 | -4.02548 | | WetDep | -10.07449 | -9.51798 | 0.55651 | -5.52394 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IHN2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 132.25387 | 142.72419 | 10.47033 | 7.91684 | | Convection | -4.58437 | -9.44552 | -4.86114 | 106.03731 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -76.13327 | | Mixing | -82.13816 | -79.95335 | 2.18480 | -2.65991 | | WetDep | -7.89261 | -7.04942 | 0.84319 | -10.68326 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IHN2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00069 | -0.00059 | 0.00010 | -14.70588 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -27.27273 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -287.72151 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IHN3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IHN3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 73.19901 | 68.29580 | -4.90321 | -6.69847 | | Convection | -4.45459 | -4.23219 | 0.22240 | -4.99255 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -513.84817 | | Mixing | -54.55208 | -50.71668 | 3.83540 | -7.03071 | | WetDep | -12.32856 | -11.69647 | 0.63209 | -5.12701 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IHN3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 73.19946 | 68.29621 | -4.90324 | -6.69847 | | Convection | -4.45459 | -4.23219 | 0.22240 | -4.99260 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -512.00296 | | Mixing | -54.55209 | -50.71669 | 3.83540 | -7.03071 | | WetDep | -12.32856 | -11.69647 | 0.63209 | -5.12701 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IHN3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 126.10692 | 126.71653 | 0.60960 | 0.48340 | | Convection | -4.20308 | -6.53631 | -2.33323 | 55.51232 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 45.08884 | | Mixing | -68.12554 | -64.02792 | 4.09762 | -6.01481 | | WetDep | -8.52462 | -7.56061 | 0.96401 | -11.30856 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IHN3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00044 | -0.00041 | 0.00003 | -6.89655 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -40.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -135.81491 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IHN4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IHN4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.81205 | 7.60962 | -1.20244 | -13.64536 | | Convection | -0.62213 | -0.53021 | 0.09192 | -14.77540 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -142.26178 | | Mixing | -5.85003 | -5.03589 | 0.81413 | -13.91672 | | WetDep | -1.99933 | -1.76164 | 0.23769 | -11.88828 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IHN4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.81207 | 7.60963 | -1.20244 | -13.64533 | | Convection | -0.62213 | -0.53021 | 0.09192 | -14.77539 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -142.23636 | | Mixing | -5.85003 | -5.03589 | 0.81413 | -13.91672 | | WetDep | -1.99933 | -1.76164 | 0.23769 | -11.88828 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IHN4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 11.35328 | 10.41757 | -0.93571 | -8.24175 | | Convection | -0.32614 | -0.42725 | -0.10112 | 31.00396 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -113.85862 | | Mixing | -6.54377 | -5.72560 | 0.81817 | -12.50302 | | WetDep | -0.98536 | -0.81783 | 0.16752 | -17.00131 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IHN4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 5.55556 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -4.76190 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 515.53106 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ INDIOL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : INDIOL +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 3640.05055 | 3487.68288 | -152.36768 | -4.18587 | | Convection | -1193.86876 | -1120.79752 | 73.07124 | -6.12054 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -9.45347 | | Mixing | -548.62326 | -453.07877 | 95.54449 | -17.41532 | | WetDep | -1574.24938 | -1613.10073 | -38.85135 | 2.46793 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : INDIOL +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 3638.03031 | 3485.67767 | -152.35264 | -4.18778 | | Convection | -1193.86868 | -1120.79744 | 73.07124 | -6.12054 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -11.30362 | | Mixing | -548.62812 | -453.08964 | 95.53848 | -17.41407 | | WetDep | -1574.24333 | -1613.09762 | -38.85429 | 2.46812 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : INDIOL +-------------+-------------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 2460.81907 | 2250.86596 | -209.95311 | -8.53184 | | Convection | -199.00864 | -173.87369 | 25.13495 | -12.63008 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 1030.23302 | | Mixing | -1075.81866 | -885.78991 | 190.02875 | -17.66364 | | WetDep | -137.55115 | -85.43845 | 52.11270 | -37.88605 | +-------------+-------------+------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : INDIOL +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2.02024 | 2.00520 | -0.01504 | -0.74446 | | Convection | -0.00008 | -0.00008 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.06255 | | Mixing | 0.00486 | 0.01087 | 0.00601 | 123.52941 | | WetDep | -0.00605 | -0.00311 | 0.00294 | -48.64865 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ INO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : INO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00131 | 0.00037 | 0.00168 | -128.38793 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -22.16816 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 17.71701 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.35444 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : INO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00047 | 0.00135 | 0.00182 | -388.07155 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -11.67312 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 17.22588 | | Mixing | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 38.30417 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : INO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | 0.00845 | 0.01478 | 0.00633 | 74.93640 | | Convection | -0.00387 | -0.00552 | -0.00165 | 42.71356 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 20110.41624 | | Mixing | -0.01326 | -0.02111 | -0.00784 | 59.15324 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ Strat [Gg] : INO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00084 | -0.00098 | -0.00013 | 15.88000 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -11.67312 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 24.26342 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 38.30417 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ INPB budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : INPB +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 51.16414 | 41.30561 | -9.85853 | -19.26843 | | Convection | -4.29715 | -3.52407 | 0.77308 | -17.99046 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -130.04308 | | Mixing | -29.25571 | -22.74648 | 6.50923 | -22.24942 | | WetDep | -14.40523 | -12.30198 | 2.10324 | -14.60056 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : INPB +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 51.16439 | 41.30594 | -9.85845 | -19.26819 | | Convection | -4.29715 | -3.52408 | 0.77308 | -17.99043 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -130.01328 | | Mixing | -29.25571 | -22.74649 | 6.50922 | -22.24939 | | WetDep | -14.40523 | -12.30198 | 2.10324 | -14.60056 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : INPB +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 43.40379 | 34.38498 | -9.01881 | -20.77885 | | Convection | -0.85907 | -0.85180 | 0.00727 | -0.84636 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -83.95137 | | Mixing | -29.54716 | -23.04968 | 6.49748 | -21.99020 | | WetDep | -5.30830 | -3.96636 | 1.34195 | -25.28012 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : INPB +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00026 | -0.00033 | -0.00007 | 28.00000 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 5.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 2079.49309 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ INPD budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : INPD +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 59.70139 | 48.58044 | -11.12095 | -18.62763 | | Convection | -4.65931 | -3.88443 | 0.77488 | -16.63068 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -132.41532 | | Mixing | -35.14220 | -27.65260 | 7.48960 | -21.31226 | | WetDep | -16.13255 | -13.85106 | 2.28149 | -14.14216 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : INPD +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 59.70162 | 48.58069 | -11.12093 | -18.62751 | | Convection | -4.65932 | -3.88444 | 0.77487 | -16.63065 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -132.42099 | | Mixing | -35.14220 | -27.65260 | 7.48960 | -21.31226 | | WetDep | -16.13255 | -13.85106 | 2.28149 | -14.14216 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : INPD +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 74.77008 | 63.32965 | -11.44043 | -15.30082 | | Convection | -1.56572 | -2.80961 | -1.24390 | 79.44588 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -133.35504 | | Mixing | -36.59600 | -28.96181 | 7.63419 | -20.86072 | | WetDep | -6.43918 | -4.90787 | 1.53131 | -23.78109 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : INPD +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00023 | -0.00026 | -0.00003 | 11.11111 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 3.84615 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -151.70255 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.21822 | 0.31861 | 0.10039 | 46.00577 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -9.01916 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.53178 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -73.91224 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.20661 | 0.29644 | 0.08983 | 43.47560 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -58.42128 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1.39829 | | Mixing | 0.00060 | 0.00049 | -0.00010 | -17.40615 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 5.49649 | 5.95836 | 0.46187 | 8.40292 | | Convection | -2.51827 | -2.66332 | -0.14505 | 5.75992 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -108.54202 | | Mixing | -3.19658 | -3.41305 | -0.21646 | 6.77170 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IO +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.01160 | 0.02217 | 0.01056 | 91.06794 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -58.42127 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -16.82005 | | Mixing | -0.00060 | -0.00049 | 0.00010 | -17.40615 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ IONITA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.61884 | -1.96413 | -0.34529 | 21.32921 | | Convection | -2.11818 | -2.00312 | 0.11506 | -5.43204 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -292.97275 | | Mixing | -1.62391 | -1.42980 | 0.19411 | -11.95343 | | WetDep | -1.42123 | -1.42311 | -0.00189 | 0.13271 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.38838 | -1.73395 | -0.34557 | 24.89043 | | Convection | -2.11818 | -2.00312 | 0.11506 | -5.43205 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -298.82320 | | Mixing | -1.62391 | -1.42984 | 0.19407 | -11.95106 | | WetDep | -1.42123 | -1.42311 | -0.00189 | 0.13271 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 19.31077 | 20.06270 | 0.75193 | 3.89385 | | Convection | -2.13946 | -2.43239 | -0.29293 | 13.69197 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -131.03155 | | Mixing | -6.74545 | -6.06485 | 0.68060 | -10.08982 | | WetDep | -0.62450 | -0.50458 | 0.11992 | -19.20205 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.23046 | -0.23017 | 0.00029 | -0.12490 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -100.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -157.34298 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00004 | 0.00004 | 1086.36364 | | WetDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IONO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IONO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00657 | 0.04691 | 0.04035 | 614.55931 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 78.08371 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 12.17087 | | Mixing | -0.00014 | -0.00019 | -0.00005 | 33.79308 | | WetDep | -0.00000 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 14.31792 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IONO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.05794 | 0.09440 | 0.03646 | 62.93628 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 33.60191 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 13.09233 | | Mixing | -0.00048 | -0.00059 | -0.00011 | 22.82401 | | WetDep | -0.00000 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 14.31792 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IONO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00224 | -0.00199 | 0.00025 | -11.24850 | | Convection | 0.00189 | 0.00266 | 0.00077 | 40.70893 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -249.40696 | | Mixing | -0.00484 | -0.00569 | -0.00086 | 17.73959 | | WetDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.86731 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IONO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.05137 | -0.04749 | 0.00388 | -7.55813 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 33.67957 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 5.20303 | | Mixing | 0.00034 | 0.00040 | 0.00006 | 18.27736 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IONO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IONO2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 72.52025 | 67.47392 | -5.04633 | -6.95851 | | Convection | -10.02159 | -9.49280 | 0.52879 | -5.27654 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.72941 | | Mixing | -42.80406 | -39.01749 | 3.78656 | -8.84627 | | WetDep | -19.36611 | -18.29937 | 1.06674 | -5.50827 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IONO2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 72.60257 | 67.53830 | -5.06427 | -6.97534 | | Convection | -10.02158 | -9.49279 | 0.52880 | -5.27659 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.47971 | | Mixing | -42.80181 | -39.01538 | 3.78643 | -8.84642 | | WetDep | -19.36611 | -18.29937 | 1.06674 | -5.50827 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IONO2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 67.55823 | 62.68813 | -4.87010 | -7.20874 | | Convection | -4.38072 | -5.37204 | -0.99132 | 22.62908 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -284.34283 | | Mixing | -47.88711 | -44.22970 | 3.65741 | -7.63757 | | WetDep | -7.09262 | -6.14994 | 0.94269 | -13.29108 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IONO2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.08232 | -0.06438 | 0.01794 | -21.79471 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 37.50000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 89.44795 | | Mixing | -0.00225 | -0.00211 | 0.00014 | -6.02958 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ IPRNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : IPRNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 40.43348 | 37.71012 | -2.72336 | -6.73540 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.18930 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 7.50647 | | Mixing | -17.91663 | -15.38409 | 2.53254 | -14.13514 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : IPRNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 40.54686 | 37.81842 | -2.72844 | -6.72910 | | Convection | -0.00017 | -0.00016 | 0.00001 | -5.94157 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 6.88376 | | Mixing | -17.92001 | -15.38961 | 2.53040 | -14.12054 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : IPRNO3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 53.58026 | 49.72313 | -3.85713 | -7.19878 | | Convection | -2.68976 | -2.24695 | 0.44281 | -16.46286 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -148.53857 | | Mixing | -25.52909 | -21.68792 | 3.84117 | -15.04626 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : IPRNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.11338 | -0.10830 | 0.00508 | -4.48114 | | Convection | 0.00017 | 0.00016 | -0.00001 | -5.94157 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 16.94188 | | Mixing | 0.00338 | 0.00552 | 0.00214 | 63.19366 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ISALA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ISALA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 15.48286 | 16.58602 | 1.10316 | 7.12507 | | Convection | -8.74619 | -8.91402 | -0.16783 | 1.91893 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.42048 | | Mixing | -0.65864 | -0.66817 | -0.00953 | 1.44678 | | WetDep | -6.23008 | -7.07307 | -0.84299 | 13.53101 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ISALA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 15.48225 | 16.58556 | 1.10332 | 7.12634 | | Convection | -8.74619 | -8.91402 | -0.16783 | 1.91893 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.53278 | | Mixing | -0.65864 | -0.66818 | -0.00954 | 1.44776 | | WetDep | -6.23007 | -7.07306 | -0.84299 | 13.53103 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ISALA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 12.61855 | 13.23554 | 0.61699 | 4.88953 | | Convection | -4.22413 | -4.12201 | 0.10212 | -2.41756 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 142.02410 | | Mixing | -4.87284 | -4.84484 | 0.02800 | -0.57467 | | WetDep | -1.64278 | -1.77957 | -0.13679 | 8.32664 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ISALA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00061 | 0.00046 | -0.00015 | -25.15723 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -12.69278 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 107.18954 | | WetDep | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -12.50000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ISALC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ISALC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 24.46812 | 28.89640 | 4.42828 | 18.09817 | | Convection | -3.84625 | -4.89040 | -1.04415 | 27.14722 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -181.21228 | | Mixing | -5.43698 | -6.64862 | -1.21164 | 22.28524 | | WetDep | -15.26710 | -17.29265 | -2.02555 | 13.26744 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ISALC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 24.46808 | 28.89637 | 4.42829 | 18.09824 | | Convection | -3.84625 | -4.89040 | -1.04415 | 27.14722 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -173.56437 | | Mixing | -5.43698 | -6.64862 | -1.21164 | 22.28527 | | WetDep | -15.26710 | -17.29265 | -2.02556 | 13.26745 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ISALC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 21.64418 | 25.37287 | 3.72869 | 17.22721 | | Convection | -2.18364 | -2.82389 | -0.64025 | 29.32009 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -218.43496 | | Mixing | -7.68572 | -9.62471 | -1.93898 | 25.22838 | | WetDep | -11.80311 | -12.90854 | -1.10544 | 9.36564 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ISALC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00004 | 0.00003 | -0.00001 | -25.00000 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -32.43523 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -40.00000 | | WetDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -100.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ISOP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ISOP +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -30761.97851 | -31614.60426 | -852.62574 | 2.77169 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 51.93059 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -76.56211 | | Mixing | 30772.32592 | 31625.87760 | 853.55168 | 2.77376 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ISOP +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -30761.97067 | -31614.60164 | -852.63098 | 2.77170 | | Convection | -0.00093 | -0.00072 | 0.00021 | -22.69748 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -76.57554 | | Mixing | 30772.32592 | 31625.87760 | 853.55168 | 2.77376 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ISOP +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -25953.27750 | -26375.28767 | -422.01017 | 1.62604 | | Convection | -608.92257 | -681.04647 | -72.12390 | 11.84451 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 51.29651 | | Mixing | 29408.37165 | 30193.73137 | 785.35972 | 2.67053 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ISOP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00785 | -0.00262 | 0.00523 | -66.66667 | | Convection | 0.00093 | 0.00072 | -0.00021 | -22.69748 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 631.22867 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ITCN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ITCN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 109.21487 | 100.66376 | -8.55111 | -7.82962 | | Convection | -6.11568 | -5.23752 | 0.87817 | -14.35925 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -109.56680 | | Mixing | -85.22066 | -79.62038 | 5.60029 | -6.57151 | | WetDep | -14.72002 | -12.82011 | 1.89990 | -12.90694 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ITCN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 109.21558 | 100.66447 | -8.55110 | -7.82956 | | Convection | -6.11569 | -5.23752 | 0.87817 | -14.35925 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -109.36831 | | Mixing | -85.22067 | -79.62039 | 5.60028 | -6.57150 | | WetDep | -14.72002 | -12.82011 | 1.89990 | -12.90694 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ITCN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 147.11516 | 147.08441 | -0.03075 | -0.02090 | | Convection | -3.36030 | -3.95107 | -0.59077 | 17.58071 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -180.43809 | | Mixing | -94.31673 | -88.15551 | 6.16122 | -6.53248 | | WetDep | -8.04046 | -6.20873 | 1.83173 | -22.78139 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ITCN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00070 | -0.00072 | -0.00001 | 1.44928 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -7.14286 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 164.02605 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00002 | 0.00001 | 200.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ ITHN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : ITHN +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 156.45095 | 141.29377 | -15.15718 | -9.68813 | | Convection | -11.11521 | -9.62102 | 1.49419 | -13.44276 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -166.75746 | | Mixing | -106.10247 | -97.01620 | 9.08627 | -8.56368 | | WetDep | -31.64911 | -27.33295 | 4.31616 | -13.63755 | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : ITHN +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 156.46460 | 141.30661 | -15.15800 | -9.68781 | | Convection | -11.11523 | -9.62104 | 1.49419 | -13.44274 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -159.67162 | | Mixing | -106.10261 | -97.01649 | 9.08612 | -8.56352 | | WetDep | -31.64911 | -27.33295 | 4.31616 | -13.63755 | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : ITHN +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 149.38923 | 149.62603 | 0.23681 | 0.15852 | | Convection | 0.06145 | 0.85797 | 0.79653 | 1296.25026 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -84.02636 | | Mixing | -111.80548 | -102.47686 | 9.32863 | -8.34362 | | WetDep | -9.97458 | -7.15626 | 2.81832 | -28.25501 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : ITHN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01365 | -0.01283 | 0.00082 | -5.98802 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 5.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 211.29169 | | Mixing | 0.00014 | 0.00030 | 0.00015 | 107.14286 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ LIMO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : LIMO +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -898.80771 | -905.35625 | -6.54854 | 0.72858 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 18.73553 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 572.05775 | | Mixing | 899.01042 | 905.53101 | 6.52059 | 0.72531 | | WetDep | -0.00247 | -0.00313 | -0.00065 | 26.28700 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : LIMO +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -898.80771 | -905.35625 | -6.54854 | 0.72858 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | 0.00000 | -37.15231 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 572.03860 | | Mixing | 899.01042 | 905.53101 | 6.52059 | 0.72531 | | WetDep | -0.00247 | -0.00313 | -0.00065 | 26.28700 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : LIMO +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -812.85950 | -809.43344 | 3.42606 | -0.42148 | | Convection | -33.77012 | -41.80654 | -8.03642 | 23.79742 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -56.41050 | | Mixing | 864.45246 | 869.93709 | 5.48464 | 0.63446 | | WetDep | -0.00227 | -0.00281 | -0.00053 | 23.45379 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : LIMO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | -0.00000 | -37.45714 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 6115.38462 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ LVOC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : LVOC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.14521 | 1.25958 | 0.11436 | 9.98616 | | Convection | -0.04295 | -0.04490 | -0.00195 | 4.54541 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -180.41221 | | Mixing | -0.89841 | -1.00696 | -0.10855 | 12.08240 | | WetDep | -0.13958 | -0.13811 | 0.00147 | -1.05284 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : LVOC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.14522 | 1.25958 | 0.11435 | 9.98523 | | Convection | -0.04295 | -0.04490 | -0.00195 | 4.54539 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -180.16600 | | Mixing | -0.89841 | -1.00696 | -0.10855 | 12.08241 | | WetDep | -0.13958 | -0.13811 | 0.00147 | -1.05284 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : LVOC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1.41933 | 1.72655 | 0.30722 | 21.64529 | | Convection | 0.02077 | -0.00140 | -0.02217 | -106.73538 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 16.67705 | | Mixing | -0.94877 | -1.05787 | -0.10910 | 11.49902 | | WetDep | -0.03335 | -0.02678 | 0.00656 | -19.68344 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : LVOC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | -110.90909 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -20.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 525.93516 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ LVOCOA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : LVOCOA +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 96.03735 | 101.44103 | 5.40368 | 5.62664 | | Convection | -35.40131 | -36.20020 | -0.79888 | 2.25664 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 16.88757 | | Mixing | -12.75855 | -11.71250 | 1.04605 | -8.19879 | | WetDep | -42.43839 | -47.05052 | -4.61212 | 10.86781 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : LVOCOA +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 96.03735 | 101.44101 | 5.40366 | 5.62662 | | Convection | -35.40131 | -36.20019 | -0.79888 | 2.25664 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 12.36173 | | Mixing | -12.75730 | -11.71143 | 1.04587 | -8.19820 | | WetDep | -42.43812 | -47.05034 | -4.61222 | 10.86811 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : LVOCOA +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 74.22123 | 76.04245 | 1.82122 | 2.45377 | | Convection | -3.86147 | -3.14170 | 0.71978 | -18.63992 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -313.32353 | | Mixing | -23.43832 | -21.30525 | 2.13307 | -9.10080 | | WetDep | -2.70060 | -1.59310 | 1.10751 | -41.00957 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : LVOCOA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00002 | 0.00002 | nan | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | -0.00000 | 50.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 31.62883 | | Mixing | -0.00125 | -0.00107 | 0.00018 | -14.25641 | | WetDep | -0.00027 | -0.00017 | 0.00010 | -35.84906 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MACR budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MACR +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 525.39614 | 538.61007 | 13.21393 | 2.51504 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 13.18065 | | EmisDryDep | 0.90185 | 0.90236 | 0.00052 | 0.05755 | | Mixing | -502.29416 | -515.64439 | -13.35023 | 2.65785 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MACR +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 525.44494 | 538.67742 | 13.23249 | 2.51834 | | Convection | -0.00075 | -0.00065 | 0.00010 | -13.51403 | | EmisDryDep | 0.87159 | 0.87110 | -0.00049 | -0.05588 | | Mixing | -502.29433 | -515.64513 | -13.35080 | 2.65796 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MACR +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1181.91331 | 1293.92427 | 112.01095 | 9.47709 | | Convection | -75.72758 | -83.08727 | -7.35970 | 9.71865 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -163.25042 | | Mixing | -672.47980 | -681.45042 | -8.97061 | 1.33396 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MACR +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.04880 | -0.06735 | -0.01855 | 38.02345 | | Convection | 0.00075 | 0.00065 | -0.00010 | -13.51403 | | EmisDryDep | 0.03026 | 0.03126 | 0.00101 | 3.32523 | | Mixing | 0.00016 | 0.00074 | 0.00057 | 350.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MACR1OOH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MACR1OOH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 52.11131 | 55.86240 | 3.75110 | 7.19824 | | Convection | -0.01714 | -0.02197 | -0.00483 | 28.16946 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -168.41787 | | Mixing | -24.94470 | -25.26664 | -0.32194 | 1.29060 | | WetDep | -21.12596 | -24.13161 | -3.00565 | 14.22730 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MACR1OOH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 52.11466 | 55.87082 | 3.75616 | 7.20749 | | Convection | -0.01718 | -0.02201 | -0.00483 | 28.13321 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -168.27350 | | Mixing | -24.94472 | -25.26683 | -0.32211 | 1.29129 | | WetDep | -21.12596 | -24.13161 | -3.00565 | 14.22730 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MACR1OOH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 53.27619 | 60.27358 | 6.99738 | 13.13417 | | Convection | -1.33669 | -0.56587 | 0.77081 | -57.66606 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -147.50562 | | Mixing | -28.14357 | -28.32821 | -0.18464 | 0.65606 | | WetDep | -6.82282 | -6.09762 | 0.72520 | -10.62906 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MACR1OOH +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00336 | -0.00842 | -0.00506 | 150.83714 | | Convection | 0.00004 | 0.00004 | 0.00000 | 10.71653 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -67.94330 | | Mixing | 0.00002 | 0.00019 | 0.00017 | 744.44444 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MAP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MAP +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2399.11239 | 2355.04336 | -44.06903 | -1.83689 | | Convection | -100.86229 | -105.81306 | -4.95077 | 4.90844 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -31.33645 | | Mixing | -963.59429 | -916.01999 | 47.57430 | -4.93717 | | WetDep | -1220.66094 | -1196.46559 | 24.19535 | -1.98215 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MAP +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2401.41774 | 2357.15678 | -44.26095 | -1.84312 | | Convection | -100.86430 | -105.81520 | -4.95090 | 4.90847 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -33.53141 | | Mixing | -963.61897 | -916.07034 | 47.54863 | -4.93438 | | WetDep | -1220.66094 | -1196.46559 | 24.19535 | -1.98215 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MAP +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1840.22722 | 1798.23107 | -41.99615 | -2.28212 | | Convection | 16.19795 | 22.01335 | 5.81540 | 35.90209 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -132.86578 | | Mixing | -952.11562 | -915.13313 | 36.98249 | -3.88424 | | WetDep | -335.66575 | -283.58357 | 52.08218 | -15.51608 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MAP +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.30535 | -2.11343 | 0.19192 | -8.32506 | | Convection | 0.00201 | 0.00215 | 0.00013 | 6.59898 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -14.68795 | | Mixing | 0.02468 | 0.05035 | 0.02567 | 103.97351 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ MCRDH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MCRDH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 181.23760 | 180.48282 | -0.75477 | -0.41645 | | Convection | -25.50744 | -27.27278 | -1.76534 | 6.92088 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -159.33895 | | Mixing | -82.97950 | -76.13535 | 6.84416 | -8.24801 | | WetDep | -62.28634 | -65.97547 | -3.68913 | 5.92286 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MCRDH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 181.24297 | 180.48953 | -0.75344 | -0.41571 | | Convection | -25.50746 | -27.27280 | -1.76534 | 6.92089 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -160.05295 | | Mixing | -82.97953 | -76.13549 | 6.84404 | -8.24786 | | WetDep | -62.28634 | -65.97547 | -3.68913 | 5.92286 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MCRDH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | 164.54522 | 164.45041 | -0.09481 | -0.05762 | | Convection | -0.73297 | 0.85828 | 1.59125 | -217.09570 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2479.80398 | | Mixing | -87.26804 | -80.37882 | 6.88922 | -7.89432 | | WetDep | -15.44349 | -11.75553 | 3.68796 | -23.88036 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+-------------+ Strat [Gg] : MCRDH +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00537 | -0.00670 | -0.00133 | 24.71483 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00002 | 0.00000 | 20.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 11.66987 | | Mixing | 0.00003 | 0.00014 | 0.00012 | 460.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MCRENOL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MCRENOL +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 18.44719 | 19.20251 | 0.75532 | 4.09450 | | Convection | -0.00385 | -0.00430 | -0.00045 | 11.77358 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 41.26488 | | Mixing | -11.05737 | -11.39357 | -0.33619 | 3.04043 | | WetDep | -5.89849 | -6.33741 | -0.43891 | 7.44111 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MCRENOL +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 18.44729 | 19.20261 | 0.75532 | 4.09446 | | Convection | -0.00386 | -0.00431 | -0.00045 | 11.72821 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 41.09276 | | Mixing | -11.05738 | -11.39357 | -0.33619 | 3.04042 | | WetDep | -5.89849 | -6.33741 | -0.43891 | 7.44111 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MCRENOL +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 24.95328 | 28.18229 | 3.22901 | 12.94022 | | Convection | -1.54889 | -1.60506 | -0.05617 | 3.62625 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -216.65875 | | Mixing | -14.19054 | -14.73756 | -0.54702 | 3.85480 | | WetDep | -2.62109 | -2.52410 | 0.09700 | -3.70071 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MCRENOL +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00010 | -0.00010 | 0.00000 | -3.65854 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | -0.00000 | -3.36945 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2229.61460 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -50.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MCRHN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MCRHN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.57623 | 10.05246 | -0.52377 | -4.95235 | | Convection | -0.78404 | -0.75599 | 0.02805 | -3.57747 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -80.54588 | | Mixing | -7.51253 | -7.06572 | 0.44681 | -5.94748 | | WetDep | -1.91552 | -1.88418 | 0.03134 | -1.63596 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MCRHN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.57644 | 10.05268 | -0.52376 | -4.95216 | | Convection | -0.78404 | -0.75599 | 0.02805 | -3.57750 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -80.46235 | | Mixing | -7.51253 | -7.06573 | 0.44681 | -5.94746 | | WetDep | -1.91552 | -1.88418 | 0.03134 | -1.63596 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MCRHN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 13.14554 | 13.58133 | 0.43579 | 3.31508 | | Convection | -0.36412 | -0.43329 | -0.06917 | 18.99651 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -79.33659 | | Mixing | -8.58776 | -8.19544 | 0.39232 | -4.56834 | | WetDep | -1.04916 | -0.93412 | 0.11503 | -10.96430 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MCRHN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00021 | -0.00022 | -0.00001 | 4.62963 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -25.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 58.03532 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 66.66667 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MCRHNB budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MCRHNB +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.75460 | 19.82597 | -3.92863 | -16.53840 | | Convection | -1.31043 | -1.12454 | 0.18589 | -14.18526 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -129.77816 | | Mixing | -16.90046 | -13.90029 | 3.00017 | -17.75198 | | WetDep | -4.59222 | -3.97576 | 0.61647 | -13.42416 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MCRHNB +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.75470 | 19.82609 | -3.92861 | -16.53824 | | Convection | -1.31043 | -1.12455 | 0.18589 | -14.18524 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -129.80950 | | Mixing | -16.90046 | -13.90029 | 3.00017 | -17.75198 | | WetDep | -4.59222 | -3.97576 | 0.61647 | -13.42416 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MCRHNB +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 20.69520 | 19.67294 | -1.02226 | -4.93960 | | Convection | -1.17481 | -2.51608 | -1.34127 | 114.16939 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -105.74079 | | Mixing | -19.08948 | -16.05124 | 3.03825 | -15.91581 | | WetDep | -2.69549 | -2.16924 | 0.52625 | -19.52331 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MCRHNB +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00010 | -0.00012 | -0.00002 | 21.79487 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -5.71429 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -210.30600 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MCRHP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MCRHP +-------------+------------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 202.98858 | 195.59899 | -7.38959 | -3.64040 | | Convection | -25.42115 | -26.34616 | -0.92500 | 3.63872 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -75.12341 | | Mixing | -107.39223 | -97.71623 | 9.67600 | -9.00997 | | WetDep | -61.28638 | -62.35695 | -1.07057 | 1.74684 | +-------------+------------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MCRHP +-------------+------------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 202.99238 | 195.60504 | -7.38734 | -3.63922 | | Convection | -25.42117 | -26.34617 | -0.92500 | 3.63871 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -75.00811 | | Mixing | -107.39226 | -97.71636 | 9.67590 | -9.00987 | | WetDep | -61.28638 | -62.35695 | -1.07057 | 1.74684 | +-------------+------------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MCRHP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 222.97688 | 221.94017 | -1.03671 | -0.46494 | | Convection | -4.60263 | -4.31399 | 0.28864 | -6.27120 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 5.33986 | | Mixing | -121.23547 | -111.52368 | 9.71178 | -8.01068 | | WetDep | -21.73546 | -17.78234 | 3.95312 | -18.18741 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MCRHP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00380 | -0.00605 | -0.00225 | 59.13978 | | Convection | 0.00002 | 0.00002 | -0.00000 | -14.28571 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.45222 | | Mixing | 0.00003 | 0.00013 | 0.00010 | 333.33333 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MEK budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MEK +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -119.28404 | -115.42363 | 3.86041 | -3.23631 | | Convection | -0.01065 | -0.01516 | -0.00451 | 42.32662 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00559 | 0.00617 | 0.00058 | 10.34022 | | Mixing | 174.88146 | 165.56418 | -9.31729 | -5.32777 | | WetDep | -74.33056 | -77.68756 | -3.35700 | 4.51631 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MEK +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -118.26839 | -114.37881 | 3.88958 | -3.28877 | | Convection | -0.01300 | -0.01727 | -0.00427 | 32.82016 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00559 | 0.00617 | 0.00058 | 10.34022 | | Mixing | 174.87266 | 165.54591 | -9.32675 | -5.33345 | | WetDep | -74.33056 | -77.68756 | -3.35700 | 4.51631 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MEK +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 670.71328 | 686.44977 | 15.73650 | 2.34623 | | Convection | -159.60740 | -162.24086 | -2.63346 | 1.64996 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -68.11564 | | Mixing | -185.43927 | -151.82813 | 33.61114 | -18.12515 | | WetDep | -28.02352 | -25.44888 | 2.57463 | -9.18740 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MEK +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.01565 | -1.04482 | -0.02917 | 2.87209 | | Convection | 0.00235 | 0.00211 | -0.00024 | -10.27215 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00881 | 0.01827 | 0.00946 | 107.42459 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MENO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MENO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 27.74608 | 26.70787 | -1.03822 | -3.74185 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -27.11638 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 40.81758 | | Mixing | 22.80730 | 24.64543 | 1.83813 | 8.05938 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MENO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 26.89390 | 25.86604 | -1.02786 | -3.82190 | | Convection | -0.00010 | -0.00016 | -0.00006 | 60.15862 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 51.47657 | | Mixing | 22.80179 | 24.63686 | 1.83507 | 8.04792 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MENO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 13.01128 | 12.19350 | -0.81778 | -6.28515 | | Convection | -7.69105 | -7.37054 | 0.32051 | -4.16728 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -137.71321 | | Mixing | 14.33241 | 15.87590 | 1.54349 | 10.76921 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MENO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.85218 | 0.84183 | -0.01036 | -1.21544 | | Convection | 0.00010 | 0.00016 | 0.00006 | 60.15862 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.26691 | | Mixing | 0.00551 | 0.00857 | 0.00306 | 55.49374 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MGLY budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MGLY +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 717.14291 | 680.95623 | -36.18668 | -5.04595 | | Convection | -108.14241 | -110.24525 | -2.10284 | 1.94451 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -104.24390 | | Mixing | -301.51719 | -261.53634 | 39.98085 | -13.25989 | | WetDep | -298.45618 | -299.34573 | -0.88956 | 0.29805 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MGLY +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 717.15043 | 680.96677 | -36.18366 | -5.04548 | | Convection | -108.14253 | -110.24537 | -2.10284 | 1.94451 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -103.74929 | | Mixing | -301.51728 | -261.53663 | 39.98065 | -13.25982 | | WetDep | -298.45618 | -299.34573 | -0.88956 | 0.29805 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MGLY +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 652.98195 | 640.43550 | -12.54646 | -1.92141 | | Convection | -28.70849 | -31.64716 | -2.93868 | 10.23627 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -68.27074 | | Mixing | -370.28549 | -328.35038 | 41.93511 | -11.32508 | | WetDep | -107.64411 | -89.97308 | 17.67103 | -16.41616 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MGLY +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00752 | -0.01054 | -0.00302 | 40.21739 | | Convection | 0.00011 | 0.00011 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -18.82197 | | Mixing | 0.00008 | 0.00029 | 0.00020 | 250.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MOH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MOH +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -3058.26199 | -2877.35032 | 180.91166 | -5.91551 | | Convection | -3.68445 | -4.45698 | -0.77252 | 20.96706 | | EmisDryDep | 0.03020 | 0.04513 | 0.01493 | 49.44196 | | Mixing | 5329.80904 | 5215.16456 | -114.64448 | -2.15101 | | WetDep | -3561.56807 | -3583.69985 | -22.13178 | 0.62141 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MOH +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -3007.78860 | -2831.03284 | 176.75576 | -5.87660 | | Convection | -3.69601 | -4.46571 | -0.76970 | 20.82501 | | EmisDryDep | 0.03020 | 0.04513 | 0.01493 | 49.44196 | | Mixing | 5329.20712 | 5214.41813 | -114.78899 | -2.15396 | | WetDep | -3561.56807 | -3583.69985 | -22.13178 | 0.62141 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MOH +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -797.78941 | -553.42019 | 244.36922 | -30.63079 | | Convection | -291.04272 | -394.71396 | -103.67124 | 35.62063 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.88987 | | Mixing | 4311.51942 | 4310.84262 | -0.67679 | -0.01570 | | WetDep | -1200.17822 | -1085.12195 | 115.05628 | -9.58660 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MOH +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -50.47339 | -46.31749 | 4.15590 | -8.23385 | | Convection | 0.01156 | 0.00873 | -0.00283 | -24.44899 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.60192 | 0.74643 | 0.14451 | 24.00869 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ MONITA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.24026 | -1.38343 | -0.14317 | 11.54382 | | Convection | -0.33033 | -0.28350 | 0.04683 | -14.17793 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -215.47193 | | Mixing | -0.49412 | -0.41686 | 0.07726 | -15.63540 | | WetDep | -0.20331 | -0.19694 | 0.00637 | -3.13154 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1.20861 | -1.35179 | -0.14318 | 11.84637 | | Convection | -0.33033 | -0.28350 | 0.04683 | -14.17793 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -213.75329 | | Mixing | -0.49412 | -0.41687 | 0.07725 | -15.63421 | | WetDep | -0.20331 | -0.19694 | 0.00637 | -3.13155 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2.61330 | 2.66200 | 0.04870 | 1.86366 | | Convection | -0.58384 | -0.78961 | -0.20578 | 35.24535 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -144.50123 | | Mixing | -1.76575 | -1.48999 | 0.27576 | -15.61743 | | WetDep | -0.12206 | -0.10458 | 0.01748 | -14.31946 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MONITA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03165 | -0.03164 | 0.00000 | -0.01059 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -100.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -371.89547 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 2940.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MONITS budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MONITS +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 109.64553 | 89.98162 | -19.66391 | -17.93407 | | Convection | -7.00596 | -5.62214 | 1.38382 | -19.75204 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -355.87598 | | Mixing | -82.61720 | -67.20892 | 15.40828 | -18.65021 | | WetDep | -20.93298 | -18.43604 | 2.49694 | -11.92825 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MONITS +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 109.64844 | 89.98427 | -19.66417 | -17.93383 | | Convection | -7.00597 | -5.62215 | 1.38382 | -19.75202 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -338.27867 | | Mixing | -82.61723 | -67.20897 | 15.40826 | -18.65018 | | WetDep | -20.93298 | -18.43604 | 2.49694 | -11.92825 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MONITS +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 154.08472 | 147.79277 | -6.29195 | -4.08343 | | Convection | -11.06182 | -21.30369 | -10.24188 | 92.58766 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -113.59099 | | Mixing | -105.40773 | -87.47767 | 17.93006 | -17.01019 | | WetDep | -15.28476 | -12.72993 | 2.55483 | -16.71490 | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MONITS +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00291 | -0.00266 | 0.00026 | -8.77193 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | -0.00000 | -8.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 70.68612 | | Mixing | 0.00003 | 0.00005 | 0.00002 | 66.66667 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MONITU budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MONITU +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 24.46117 | 20.39971 | -4.06146 | -16.60371 | | Convection | -1.20381 | -0.95886 | 0.24495 | -20.34819 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -126.24026 | | Mixing | -19.10467 | -15.70817 | 3.39650 | -17.77837 | | WetDep | -4.25710 | -3.92073 | 0.33637 | -7.90137 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MONITU +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 24.46120 | 20.39973 | -4.06146 | -16.60370 | | Convection | -1.20382 | -0.95886 | 0.24495 | -20.34820 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -126.16983 | | Mixing | -19.10467 | -15.70817 | 3.39650 | -17.77837 | | WetDep | -4.25710 | -3.92073 | 0.33637 | -7.90137 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MONITU +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 32.97174 | 32.52146 | -0.45028 | -1.36566 | | Convection | -2.32796 | -5.88382 | -3.55586 | 152.74584 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -100.28238 | | Mixing | -24.22110 | -20.23688 | 3.98422 | -16.44937 | | WetDep | -3.63612 | -3.24217 | 0.39395 | -10.83441 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MONITU +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00003 | -0.00003 | 0.00000 | -8.33333 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -30.76923 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -32.75927 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MP +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 6173.14179 | 6190.24013 | 17.09834 | 0.27698 | | Convection | -20.23397 | -22.93260 | -2.69864 | 13.33717 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 212.21565 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -73.30945 | | WetDep | -5913.56848 | -5942.68431 | -29.11583 | 0.49236 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MP +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+-------------| | Chemistry | 6182.72414 | 6197.40891 | 14.68477 | 0.23751 | | Convection | -20.24182 | -22.93996 | -2.69814 | 13.32952 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -1749.06292 | | Mixing | -0.11737 | -0.20714 | -0.08977 | 76.48593 | | WetDep | -5913.56848 | -5942.68431 | -29.11583 | 0.49236 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+-------------+ PBL [Gg] : MP +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 1510.52867 | 1647.44503 | 136.91636 | 9.06414 | | Convection | 461.01175 | 393.32841 | -67.68334 | -14.68148 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -96.86969 | | Mixing | 233.74606 | 108.78046 | -124.96560 | -53.46212 | | WetDep | -1888.20841 | -1840.66779 | 47.54062 | -2.51776 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -9.58234 | -7.16877 | 2.41357 | -25.18766 | | Convection | 0.00786 | 0.00736 | -0.00050 | -6.37191 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -17.54329 | | Mixing | 0.11737 | 0.20714 | 0.08977 | 76.48593 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MPAN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MPAN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 50.69112 | 48.57528 | -2.11584 | -4.17399 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 23.73848 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -115.32558 | | Mixing | -41.31892 | -39.74249 | 1.57644 | -3.81529 | | WetDep | -0.18836 | -0.20727 | -0.01890 | 10.03522 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MPAN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 50.70005 | 48.59386 | -2.10619 | -4.15422 | | Convection | -0.00013 | -0.00011 | 0.00002 | -14.56741 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -115.30836 | | Mixing | -41.31897 | -39.74286 | 1.57611 | -3.81450 | | WetDep | -0.18836 | -0.20727 | -0.01890 | 10.03522 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MPAN +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 96.24958 | 102.77093 | 6.52135 | 6.77545 | | Convection | -6.59414 | -5.95011 | 0.64403 | -9.76677 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -581.87622 | | Mixing | -62.89453 | -59.40117 | 3.49336 | -5.55431 | | WetDep | -0.08935 | -0.08545 | 0.00390 | -4.36843 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MPAN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00893 | -0.01858 | -0.00965 | 108.06636 | | Convection | 0.00012 | 0.00010 | -0.00002 | -15.63963 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -110.31775 | | Mixing | 0.00005 | 0.00038 | 0.00032 | 600.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MPN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MPN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.20357 | -2.01307 | -1.80950 | 888.88652 | | Convection | -0.00586 | -0.00603 | -0.00017 | 2.94417 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.21940 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -153.88899 | | WetDep | -1.36800 | -1.47785 | -0.10985 | 8.02983 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MPN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -34.41159 | -33.78651 | 0.62509 | -1.81650 | | Convection | -0.00372 | -0.00398 | -0.00026 | 6.96977 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.06320 | | Mixing | 0.16545 | 0.18310 | 0.01765 | 10.67002 | | WetDep | -1.36800 | -1.47785 | -0.10985 | 8.02983 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MPN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | 0.00717 | -0.18610 | -0.19327 | -2694.35518 | | Convection | 0.23051 | 0.63002 | 0.39952 | 173.32175 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -54.97037 | | Mixing | -0.35108 | -0.31884 | 0.03224 | -9.18231 | | WetDep | -0.49395 | -0.48862 | 0.00532 | -1.07727 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ Strat [Gg] : MPN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 34.20802 | 31.77344 | -2.43458 | -7.11700 | | Convection | -0.00214 | -0.00205 | 0.00009 | -4.05413 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -6.97459 | | Mixing | -0.16545 | -0.18310 | -0.01765 | 10.67002 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MSA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MSA +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 361.59602 | 402.04498 | 40.44896 | 11.18623 | | Convection | -128.00978 | -137.35865 | -9.34887 | 7.30324 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 23.57902 | | Mixing | -59.99410 | -63.82657 | -3.83247 | 6.38808 | | WetDep | -173.82044 | -194.57982 | -20.75938 | 11.94300 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MSA +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 361.21998 | 401.71811 | 40.49813 | 11.21149 | | Convection | -128.00968 | -137.35824 | -9.34856 | 7.30301 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 23.92728 | | Mixing | -59.98651 | -63.82147 | -3.83497 | 6.39305 | | WetDep | -173.81731 | -194.57724 | -20.75993 | 11.94353 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MSA +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 193.67612 | 207.59112 | 13.91500 | 7.18468 | | Convection | -46.42166 | -46.12937 | 0.29229 | -0.62964 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 2.99943 | | Mixing | -108.72247 | -114.66421 | -5.94174 | 5.46505 | | WetDep | -26.55251 | -31.36201 | -4.80950 | 18.11316 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MSA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.37604 | 0.32687 | -0.04917 | -13.07467 | | Convection | -0.00010 | -0.00041 | -0.00031 | 300.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 21.93035 | | Mixing | -0.00759 | -0.00509 | 0.00249 | -32.86195 | | WetDep | -0.00313 | -0.00257 | 0.00055 | -17.64706 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MTPA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MTPA +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -8596.85054 | -8478.56609 | 118.28445 | -1.37590 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 27.42925 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -146.53231 | | Mixing | 8600.85964 | 8481.68784 | -119.17180 | -1.38558 | | WetDep | -0.03768 | -0.04621 | -0.00853 | 22.62968 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MTPA +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -8596.84793 | -8478.56413 | 118.28379 | -1.37590 | | Convection | -0.00037 | -0.00021 | 0.00015 | -41.61158 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -146.53085 | | Mixing | 8600.85964 | 8481.68784 | -119.17180 | -1.38558 | | WetDep | -0.03768 | -0.04621 | -0.00853 | 22.62968 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MTPA +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -7099.78384 | -6829.96447 | 269.81937 | -3.80039 | | Convection | -358.46969 | -452.65528 | -94.18559 | 26.27435 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -8.05102 | | Mixing | 7995.38038 | 7869.71071 | -125.66966 | -1.57178 | | WetDep | -0.03080 | -0.03609 | -0.00529 | 17.18698 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MTPA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00262 | -0.00196 | 0.00065 | -25.00000 | | Convection | 0.00037 | 0.00021 | -0.00015 | -41.78110 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -710.41667 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MTPO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MTPO +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -3844.23114 | -3790.87011 | 53.36104 | -1.38808 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -17.24865 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 112.63218 | | Mixing | 3844.27332 | 3790.87272 | -53.40060 | -1.38909 | | WetDep | -0.00128 | -0.00163 | -0.00036 | 27.94681 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MTPO +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -3844.23114 | -3790.87011 | 53.36104 | -1.38808 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -65.43120 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 112.63227 | | Mixing | 3844.27332 | 3790.87272 | -53.40060 | -1.38909 | | WetDep | -0.00128 | -0.00163 | -0.00036 | 27.94681 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MTPO +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -3689.63463 | -3643.88277 | 45.75186 | -1.24001 | | Convection | -82.57455 | -75.89589 | 6.67865 | -8.08803 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -87.43901 | | Mixing | 3781.07394 | 3728.22196 | -52.85197 | -1.39780 | | WetDep | -0.00125 | -0.00159 | -0.00034 | 27.03356 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MTPO +-------------+---------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -66.02534 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -300.00000 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+---------+----------+----------+------------+ MVK budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MVK +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1112.67837 | 1114.64451 | 1.96613 | 0.17670 | | Convection | -0.00143 | -0.00186 | -0.00043 | 30.12144 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -42.58407 | | Mixing | -967.21963 | -962.57959 | 4.64004 | -0.47973 | | WetDep | -70.67551 | -81.65741 | -10.98191 | 15.53849 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MVK +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1112.71565 | 1114.71423 | 1.99858 | 0.17961 | | Convection | -0.00314 | -0.00334 | -0.00020 | 6.42439 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -42.48898 | | Mixing | -967.21987 | -962.58098 | 4.63889 | -0.47961 | | WetDep | -70.67551 | -81.65741 | -10.98191 | 15.53849 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MVK +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2831.24601 | 3024.25788 | 193.01187 | 6.81721 | | Convection | -163.15372 | -178.02363 | -14.86991 | 9.11405 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -96.83539 | | Mixing | -1341.33958 | -1317.64055 | 23.69903 | -1.76682 | | WetDep | -30.72621 | -29.95600 | 0.77021 | -2.50668 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MVK +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03727 | -0.06972 | -0.03245 | 87.06140 | | Convection | 0.00172 | 0.00149 | -0.00023 | -13.27568 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 937.76107 | | Mixing | 0.00025 | 0.00139 | 0.00114 | 466.66667 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MVKDH budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MVKDH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 856.44439 | 854.35402 | -2.09037 | -0.24408 | | Convection | -117.64965 | -126.93246 | -9.28281 | 7.89022 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 14.75692 | | Mixing | -379.90743 | -346.96053 | 32.94690 | -8.67235 | | WetDep | -306.25162 | -323.67168 | -17.42006 | 5.68815 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MVKDH +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 856.49867 | 854.40944 | -2.08923 | -0.24393 | | Convection | -117.64971 | -126.93254 | -9.28283 | 7.89023 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 9.50409 | | Mixing | -379.90784 | -346.96176 | 32.94609 | -8.67213 | | WetDep | -306.25162 | -323.67168 | -17.42006 | 5.68815 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MVKDH +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 718.23436 | 712.79746 | -5.43690 | -0.75698 | | Convection | 0.77455 | 8.14503 | 7.37048 | 951.58336 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 262.35909 | | Mixing | -394.88189 | -361.90437 | 32.97751 | -8.35123 | | WetDep | -69.22241 | -52.10138 | 17.12104 | -24.73337 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MVKDH +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.05427 | -0.05542 | -0.00114 | 2.10843 | | Convection | 0.00006 | 0.00008 | 0.00002 | 33.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -48.20834 | | Mixing | 0.00041 | 0.00123 | 0.00082 | 200.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MVKHC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MVKHC +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 364.90993 | 344.62282 | -20.28711 | -5.55949 | | Convection | -49.34699 | -50.38980 | -1.04281 | 2.11321 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -103.33655 | | Mixing | -179.27557 | -153.63906 | 25.63651 | -14.30006 | | WetDep | -122.28908 | -126.21073 | -3.92165 | 3.20687 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MVKHC +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 364.91214 | 344.62698 | -20.28515 | -5.55891 | | Convection | -49.34702 | -50.38983 | -1.04281 | 2.11321 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -103.28271 | | Mixing | -179.27557 | -153.63916 | 25.63641 | -14.30000 | | WetDep | -122.28908 | -126.21073 | -3.92165 | 3.20687 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MVKHC +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 314.49811 | 306.05904 | -8.43907 | -2.68334 | | Convection | -6.11393 | -3.93677 | 2.17716 | -35.60981 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -121.09374 | | Mixing | -197.88278 | -171.23344 | 26.64934 | -13.46723 | | WetDep | -38.91797 | -29.77632 | 9.14165 | -23.48954 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MVKHC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00221 | -0.00417 | -0.00196 | 88.88889 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00003 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 326.49893 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00009 | 0.00009 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MVKHCB budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MVKHCB +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 265.33879 | 257.72260 | -7.61619 | -2.87036 | | Convection | -35.84204 | -37.57124 | -1.72920 | 4.82449 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -13.91781 | | Mixing | -123.05283 | -109.23938 | 13.81345 | -11.22563 | | WetDep | -92.89912 | -96.59312 | -3.69400 | 3.97635 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MVKHCB +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 265.34621 | 257.73290 | -7.61331 | -2.86920 | | Convection | -35.84207 | -37.57126 | -1.72920 | 4.82449 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -14.11001 | | Mixing | -123.05288 | -109.23962 | 13.81326 | -11.22547 | | WetDep | -92.89912 | -96.59312 | -3.69400 | 3.97635 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MVKHCB +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 226.20058 | 221.57540 | -4.62518 | -2.04473 | | Convection | -1.51707 | 0.27711 | 1.79418 | -118.26617 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -480.25038 | | Mixing | -130.56882 | -116.75065 | 13.81817 | -10.58306 | | WetDep | -24.13953 | -18.35472 | 5.78481 | -23.96405 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MVKHCB +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00742 | -0.01030 | -0.00288 | 38.84298 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00003 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -57.09048 | | Mixing | 0.00004 | 0.00023 | 0.00019 | 475.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MVKHP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MVKHP +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 441.96600 | 446.54436 | 4.57837 | 1.03591 | | Convection | -62.89418 | -66.76903 | -3.87485 | 6.16090 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -49.34037 | | Mixing | -223.82232 | -212.18285 | 11.63947 | -5.20032 | | WetDep | -137.22105 | -148.72581 | -11.50476 | 8.38410 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MVKHP +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 441.97409 | 446.56267 | 4.58858 | 1.03820 | | Convection | -62.89422 | -66.76906 | -3.87484 | 6.16089 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -49.33072 | | Mixing | -223.82236 | -212.18322 | 11.63914 | -5.20017 | | WetDep | -137.22105 | -148.72581 | -11.50476 | 8.38410 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MVKHP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 420.32783 | 432.39248 | 12.06465 | 2.87030 | | Convection | -8.35537 | -6.11430 | 2.24107 | -26.82188 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -523.73875 | | Mixing | -242.57000 | -231.40755 | 11.16245 | -4.60174 | | WetDep | -42.86249 | -35.35420 | 7.50829 | -17.51715 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MVKHP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | -0.00809 | -0.01831 | -0.01022 | 126.26263 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00003 | -0.00001 | -16.66667 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -1943.75000 | | Mixing | 0.00004 | 0.00037 | 0.00033 | 800.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ MVKN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MVKN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 47.34553 | 42.53438 | -4.81115 | -10.16178 | | Convection | -3.78698 | -3.56283 | 0.22415 | -5.91893 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.11759 | | Mixing | -34.46786 | -30.65460 | 3.81326 | -11.06325 | | WetDep | -10.98996 | -10.29454 | 0.69542 | -6.32779 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MVKN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 47.34750 | 42.53678 | -4.81072 | -10.16046 | | Convection | -3.78698 | -3.56283 | 0.22415 | -5.91894 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.79159 | | Mixing | -34.46788 | -30.65463 | 3.81324 | -11.06318 | | WetDep | -10.98996 | -10.29454 | 0.69542 | -6.32779 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MVKN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 72.51483 | 74.14912 | 1.63429 | 2.25373 | | Convection | -2.05496 | -2.32281 | -0.26785 | 13.03411 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -130.72851 | | Mixing | -42.97540 | -38.92820 | 4.04720 | -9.41748 | | WetDep | -5.92534 | -4.88858 | 1.03675 | -17.49694 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MVKN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00197 | -0.00240 | -0.00043 | 21.81818 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | -0.00000 | -14.28571 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -140.87831 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00003 | 0.00002 | 160.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ MVKPC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : MVKPC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 136.00416 | 137.14522 | 1.14106 | 0.83899 | | Convection | -19.32692 | -20.61868 | -1.29176 | 6.68376 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -206.13621 | | Mixing | -70.77829 | -67.41471 | 3.36358 | -4.75228 | | WetDep | -40.41127 | -43.42670 | -3.01543 | 7.46185 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : MVKPC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 136.00535 | 137.14784 | 1.14250 | 0.84004 | | Convection | -19.32693 | -20.61869 | -1.29176 | 6.68376 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -206.06830 | | Mixing | -70.77830 | -67.41476 | 3.36354 | -4.75222 | | WetDep | -40.41127 | -43.42670 | -3.01543 | 7.46185 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : MVKPC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 113.64824 | 118.50729 | 4.85904 | 4.27551 | | Convection | -2.67219 | -1.93021 | 0.74198 | -27.76666 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -18.55581 | | Mixing | -76.50447 | -73.35088 | 3.15359 | -4.12210 | | WetDep | -13.09418 | -11.01189 | 2.08229 | -15.90240 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : MVKPC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00119 | -0.00263 | -0.00144 | 121.55172 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -112.34011 | | Mixing | 0.00001 | 0.00005 | 0.00004 | 400.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ N2O budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : N2O +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1475.87850 | -1484.39171 | -8.51321 | 0.57682 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -83.02315 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 5.16455 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -172.52410 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : N2O +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -16.90546 | -16.79072 | 0.11474 | -0.67869 | | Convection | -0.07731 | -0.07842 | -0.00111 | 1.43362 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 7.45327 | | Mixing | -27.69359 | -89.08292 | -61.38933 | 221.67343 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : N2O +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.61493 | -0.62252 | -0.00759 | 1.23355 | | Convection | -284.24896 | -337.71283 | -53.46387 | 18.80882 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -139.67771 | | Mixing | -84.75913 | -98.18446 | -13.42533 | 15.83939 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : N2O +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1458.97304 | -1467.60099 | -8.62794 | 0.59137 | | Convection | 0.07731 | 0.07842 | 0.00111 | 1.43362 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.73161 | | Mixing | 27.69359 | 89.08292 | 61.38933 | 221.67343 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ N2O5 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : N2O5 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -200.43150 | -189.24133 | 11.19018 | -5.58304 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -98.16498 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -14.63062 | | Mixing | -55.59354 | -62.02549 | -6.43195 | 11.56961 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : N2O5 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 44.68873 | 54.20080 | 9.51207 | 21.28516 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00006 | -0.00006 | 1145.03243 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 7.76102 | | Mixing | -55.56137 | -61.98282 | -6.42146 | 11.55741 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : N2O5 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 96.83624 | 87.29091 | -9.54534 | -9.85719 | | Convection | -4.92066 | 16.64325 | 21.56392 | -438.23193 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -25.19477 | | Mixing | -59.27118 | -65.46980 | -6.19863 | 10.45808 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : N2O5 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -245.12023 | -243.44212 | 1.67811 | -0.68461 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00006 | 0.00006 | 1145.03242 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -11.84567 | | Mixing | -0.03217 | -0.04267 | -0.01050 | 32.63459 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ NH3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NH3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -2505.23909 | -2677.72092 | -172.48183 | 6.88485 | | Convection | -461.82137 | -466.55099 | -4.72962 | 1.02412 | | EmisDryDep | 0.05964 | 0.10379 | 0.04415 | 74.02991 | | Mixing | 4380.48331 | 4528.73072 | 148.24741 | 3.38427 | | WetDep | -1382.72727 | -1345.88946 | 36.83781 | -2.66414 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NH3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -2505.23909 | -2677.72092 | -172.48183 | 6.88485 | | Convection | -461.82186 | -466.55157 | -4.72970 | 1.02414 | | EmisDryDep | 0.05964 | 0.10379 | 0.04415 | 74.02991 | | Mixing | 4380.48266 | 4528.72974 | 148.24709 | 3.38426 | | WetDep | -1382.72727 | -1345.88946 | 36.83781 | -2.66414 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NH3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -1592.90369 | -1572.14871 | 20.75498 | -1.30297 | | Convection | -589.58157 | -762.15226 | -172.57068 | 29.27003 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -88.83794 | | Mixing | 3528.51736 | 3688.90487 | 160.38751 | 4.54546 | | WetDep | -807.54275 | -733.92607 | 73.61668 | -9.11613 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NH3 +-------------+---------+---------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------+---------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Convection | 0.00049 | 0.00057 | 0.00008 | 16.66667 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00065 | 0.00098 | 0.00033 | 50.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+---------+---------+---------+------------+ NH4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NH4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 2652.60601 | 2835.23386 | 182.62784 | 6.88485 | | Convection | -795.32296 | -835.36850 | -40.04555 | 5.03513 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.94390 | | Mixing | -386.08006 | -350.16864 | 35.91143 | -9.30155 | | WetDep | -1559.83843 | -1719.78684 | -159.94841 | 10.25417 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NH4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 2652.60601 | 2835.23386 | 182.62784 | 6.88485 | | Convection | -795.32255 | -835.36818 | -40.04563 | 5.03514 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -5.87787 | | Mixing | -386.05407 | -350.14975 | 35.90432 | -9.30033 | | WetDep | -1559.82715 | -1719.78030 | -159.95315 | 10.25454 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NH4 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1686.60388 | 1664.62822 | -21.97566 | -1.30295 | | Convection | -146.35588 | -100.12210 | 46.23378 | -31.58997 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -82.44267 | | Mixing | -864.92033 | -780.12716 | 84.79317 | -9.80358 | | WetDep | -195.78768 | -157.69228 | 38.09540 | -19.45751 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NH4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Convection | -0.00041 | -0.00033 | 0.00008 | -20.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 5.93063 | | Mixing | -0.02599 | -0.01888 | 0.00711 | -27.35849 | | WetDep | -0.01128 | -0.00654 | 0.00474 | -42.02899 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ NIT budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NIT +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 1226.57527 | 1663.80952 | 437.23425 | 35.64675 | | Convection | -410.98768 | -558.25677 | -147.26909 | 35.83297 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -12.19684 | | Mixing | -269.88746 | -286.80250 | -16.91504 | 6.26744 | | WetDep | -567.36315 | -858.64838 | -291.28524 | 51.34018 | +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NIT +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 2154.62469 | 2284.64872 | 130.02403 | 6.03465 | | Convection | -410.98743 | -558.25644 | -147.26901 | 35.83297 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -8.35698 | | Mixing | -270.65742 | -287.74560 | -17.08818 | 6.31358 | | WetDep | -567.24945 | -858.52202 | -291.27257 | 51.34823 | +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NIT +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1216.91185 | 1300.20332 | 83.29147 | 6.84450 | | Convection | -199.23947 | -76.66389 | 122.57558 | -61.52174 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -27.49109 | | Mixing | -946.04165 | -937.72543 | 8.31622 | -0.87905 | | WetDep | -175.01989 | -183.61806 | -8.59817 | 4.91268 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NIT +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -928.04942 | -620.83919 | 307.21022 | -33.10279 | | Convection | -0.00025 | -0.00033 | -0.00008 | 33.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -60.65106 | | Mixing | 0.76995 | 0.94310 | 0.17314 | 22.48733 | | WetDep | -0.11370 | -0.12637 | -0.01267 | 11.14306 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ NITS budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NITS +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 848.80088 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -212.82078 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -351.55112 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -217.59887 | -217.59887 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NITS +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 848.83971 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -212.82076 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -351.55136 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -217.59883 | -217.59883 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NITS +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 887.39329 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -82.18754 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -520.50296 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -37.60746 | -37.60746 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NITS +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.03883 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00002 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00025 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.00004 | -0.00004 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ NITs budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NITs +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 659.06925 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -156.88588 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -305.21904 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -154.30072 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NITs +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 659.11702 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -156.88588 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -305.21924 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -154.30069 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NITs +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 681.59354 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -76.13157 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -445.33055 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -34.03706 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+------------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NITs +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.04778 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00020 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.00002 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ NO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NO +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10333.02591 | -10302.21188 | 30.81402 | -0.29821 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -13.09292 | | EmisDryDep | 1885.52756 | 1817.78385 | -67.74371 | -3.59283 | | Mixing | 8409.12648 | 8453.17230 | 44.04582 | 0.52379 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NO +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10277.08031 | -10247.39885 | 29.68146 | -0.28881 | | Convection | 0.00080 | 0.00080 | -0.00000 | -0.27631 | | EmisDryDep | 1868.38835 | 1800.40171 | -67.98663 | -3.63878 | | Mixing | 8405.11804 | 8449.60916 | 44.49113 | 0.52933 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NO +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -7918.81646 | -8036.94462 | -118.12816 | 1.49174 | | Convection | -358.45673 | -261.45205 | 97.00468 | -27.06175 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -161.15724 | | Mixing | 8049.19621 | 8081.18661 | 31.99040 | 0.39744 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NO +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -55.94560 | -54.81304 | 1.13257 | -2.02441 | | Convection | -0.00080 | -0.00080 | 0.00000 | -0.27631 | | EmisDryDep | 17.13921 | 17.38214 | 0.24293 | 1.41737 | | Mixing | 4.00845 | 3.56314 | -0.44531 | -11.10930 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ NO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NO2 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -356.58317 | -409.17767 | -52.59450 | 14.74957 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -213.17992 | | EmisDryDep | 2.86693 | 3.41468 | 0.54775 | 19.10587 | | Mixing | 125.81438 | 194.56004 | 68.74565 | 54.64054 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NO2 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -155.89942 | -217.94021 | -62.04079 | 39.79539 | | Convection | -0.00066 | -0.00079 | -0.00013 | 19.53141 | | EmisDryDep | 2.86693 | 3.41468 | 0.54775 | 19.10587 | | Mixing | 123.29725 | 192.53430 | 69.23704 | 56.15457 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NO2 +-------------+------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 2224.22778 | 2617.14337 | 392.91559 | 17.66526 | | Convection | -603.98231 | -1057.10640 | -453.12409 | 75.02274 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -8.00367 | | Mixing | -933.69900 | -899.10736 | 34.59164 | -3.70480 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NO2 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -200.68375 | -191.23746 | 9.44629 | -4.70705 | | Convection | 0.00066 | 0.00079 | 0.00013 | 19.53141 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 2.51713 | 2.02574 | -0.49139 | -19.52184 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ NO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 5.72024 | 6.09122 | 0.37099 | 6.48549 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -19.71024 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.65851 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -112.91576 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 6.45554 | 6.81603 | 0.36048 | 5.58412 | | Convection | -0.00004 | -0.00008 | -0.00005 | 117.37166 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1640.90902 | | Mixing | 0.00203 | 0.00159 | -0.00044 | -21.66956 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NO3 +-------------+----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 29.63370 | 12.46850 | -17.16520 | -57.92460 | | Convection | -1.87461 | 13.80811 | 15.68272 | -836.58728 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -158.81424 | | Mixing | 1.00847 | 1.19430 | 0.18584 | 18.42764 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.73530 | -0.72480 | 0.01050 | -1.42809 | | Convection | 0.00004 | 0.00008 | 0.00005 | 117.37166 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.25074 | | Mixing | -0.00203 | -0.00159 | 0.00044 | -21.66956 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ NPRNO3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : NPRNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.28226 | 9.54839 | -0.73387 | -7.13726 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -15.63864 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 16.09463 | | Mixing | -4.90979 | -4.23884 | 0.67095 | -13.66551 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : NPRNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 10.30568 | 9.57021 | -0.73547 | -7.13657 | | Convection | -0.00005 | -0.00005 | 0.00000 | -2.71734 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 15.88793 | | Mixing | -4.91040 | -4.23989 | 0.67051 | -13.65481 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : NPRNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 15.09565 | 14.17609 | -0.91956 | -6.09154 | | Convection | -0.81980 | -0.71798 | 0.10182 | -12.42009 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -52.10155 | | Mixing | -7.16132 | -6.15791 | 1.00341 | -14.01152 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : NPRNO3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.02342 | -0.02182 | 0.00160 | -6.83497 | | Convection | 0.00005 | 0.00005 | -0.00000 | -2.71734 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 18.86016 | | Mixing | 0.00061 | 0.00105 | 0.00044 | 72.83237 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ O3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : O3 +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | 45481.84239 | 35139.05170 | -10342.79069 | -22.74048 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -39.66610 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -21.44157 | | Mixing | -75302.57779 | -72942.88646 | 2359.69132 | -3.13361 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : O3 +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | 23191.15134 | 20861.22452 | -2329.92682 | -10.04662 | | Convection | 2.74526 | 2.69354 | -0.05172 | -1.88390 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.02891 | | Mixing | -74329.22003 | -71804.00149 | 2525.21854 | -3.39734 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : O3 +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | 36816.57495 | 26604.22548 | -10212.34947 | -27.73846 | | Convection | 17820.22174 | 20144.73552 | 2324.51378 | 13.04425 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -56.46067 | | Mixing | -49660.51781 | -44217.31849 | 5443.19932 | -10.96082 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : O3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | 22290.69105 | 14277.82718 | -8012.86387 | -35.94713 | | Convection | -2.74526 | -2.69354 | 0.05172 | -1.88390 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -10.25242 | | Mixing | -973.35776 | -1138.88498 | -165.52721 | 17.00579 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+ OCLO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : OCLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -2.89236 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : OCLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.39642 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00070 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : OCLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.39553 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.17174 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.16242 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : OCLO +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -2.49594 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00001 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -0.00070 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ OCPI budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : OCPI +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1588.83623 | 1597.70402 | 8.86779 | 0.55813 | | Convection | -1060.69095 | -1038.51331 | 22.17764 | -2.09087 | | EmisDryDep | 0.54559 | 0.56789 | 0.02230 | 4.08820 | | Mixing | 1230.27303 | 1272.60112 | 42.32809 | 3.44054 | | WetDep | -1687.48011 | -1760.27525 | -72.79513 | 4.31384 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : OCPI +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1588.81629 | 1597.65694 | 8.84065 | 0.55643 | | Convection | -1060.69087 | -1038.51314 | 22.17772 | -2.09088 | | EmisDryDep | 0.49099 | 0.51244 | 0.02146 | 4.36985 | | Mixing | 1230.25415 | 1272.57872 | 42.32457 | 3.44031 | | WetDep | -1687.47439 | -1760.27247 | -72.79807 | 4.31403 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : OCPI +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 782.36842 | 747.92105 | -34.44737 | -4.40296 | | Convection | -463.91755 | -464.52188 | -0.60433 | 0.13027 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -93.45559 | | Mixing | 416.39091 | 515.22471 | 98.83380 | 23.73582 | | WetDep | -194.60021 | -157.02692 | 37.57329 | -19.30794 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : OCPI +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.01994 | 0.04708 | 0.02714 | 136.06557 | | Convection | -0.00008 | -0.00016 | -0.00008 | 100.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.05460 | 0.05545 | 0.00085 | 1.55538 | | Mixing | 0.01888 | 0.02240 | 0.00351 | 18.61472 | | WetDep | -0.00572 | -0.00278 | 0.00294 | -51.42857 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ OCPO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : OCPO +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1588.83623 | -1597.70402 | -8.86779 | 0.55813 | | Convection | -115.99914 | -112.09004 | 3.90909 | -3.36993 | | EmisDryDep | 0.09192 | 0.11443 | 0.02251 | 24.48365 | | Mixing | 1720.61485 | 1724.60842 | 3.99357 | 0.23210 | | WetDep | -3.73640 | -3.99284 | -0.25644 | 6.86327 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : OCPO +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1588.81629 | -1597.65694 | -8.84065 | 0.55643 | | Convection | -115.99919 | -112.09007 | 3.90912 | -3.36996 | | EmisDryDep | 0.09192 | 0.11443 | 0.02251 | 24.48365 | | Mixing | 1720.61485 | 1724.60777 | 3.99292 | 0.23206 | | WetDep | -3.73640 | -3.99284 | -0.25644 | 6.86327 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : OCPO +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -782.36842 | -747.92105 | 34.44737 | -4.40296 | | Convection | -284.70065 | -300.41383 | -15.71318 | 5.51919 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -91.19936 | | Mixing | 1310.23841 | 1330.18942 | 19.95101 | 1.52270 | | WetDep | -2.21442 | -2.11327 | 0.10115 | -4.56793 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : OCPO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01994 | -0.04708 | -0.02714 | 136.06557 | | Convection | 0.00005 | 0.00002 | -0.00003 | -60.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00065 | 0.00065 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ OCS budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : OCS +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -25.15746 | -25.12547 | 0.03199 | -0.12717 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -112.35355 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.39351 | | Mixing | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 114.17717 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : OCS +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -19.50434 | -19.50384 | 0.00051 | -0.00260 | | Convection | -0.00013 | -0.00007 | 0.00006 | -47.07952 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 5.63480 | | Mixing | -0.07635 | -0.20397 | -0.12762 | 167.14952 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : OCS +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -3.87063 | -3.84520 | 0.02544 | -0.65721 | | Convection | 0.16684 | 0.19927 | 0.03243 | 19.43937 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -89.01550 | | Mixing | 0.09704 | 0.10328 | 0.00624 | 6.42954 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : OCS +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.65312 | -5.62163 | 0.03149 | -0.55696 | | Convection | 0.00013 | 0.00007 | -0.00006 | -47.07952 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -5.75138 | | Mixing | 0.07635 | 0.20397 | 0.12762 | 167.14952 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ OClO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : OClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.59218 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : OClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.39059 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00504 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : OClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.22478 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.11318 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.10172 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : OClO +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.20159 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -0.00504 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ OIO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : OIO +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.03798 | 0.06318 | 0.10116 | -266.34950 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.87335 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -12.64594 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 148.22559 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : OIO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | -0.01090 | 0.09192 | 0.10282 | -943.45675 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 17878.83370 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -37.96635 | | Mixing | 0.00016 | 0.00003 | -0.00013 | -81.91751 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ PBL [Gg] : OIO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2.18679 | 2.90791 | 0.72112 | 32.97609 | | Convection | -1.05414 | -1.27726 | -0.22312 | 21.16564 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -49.18704 | | Mixing | -1.01373 | -1.26213 | -0.24840 | 24.50380 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : OIO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | -0.02708 | -0.02874 | -0.00166 | 6.13913 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 17878.84961 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -9.56369 | | Mixing | -0.00016 | -0.00003 | 0.00013 | -81.91751 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ PAN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PAN +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 846.31301 | 812.85696 | -33.45605 | -3.95315 | | Convection | -0.00313 | -0.00494 | -0.00181 | 57.87767 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.80252 | | Mixing | -947.16800 | -876.10882 | 71.05917 | -7.50228 | | WetDep | -20.83080 | -22.06564 | -1.23484 | 5.92797 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PAN +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 883.44451 | 850.27977 | -33.16474 | -3.75403 | | Convection | -0.00473 | -0.00539 | -0.00066 | 13.94609 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1.23411 | | Mixing | -947.43806 | -876.49896 | 70.93910 | -7.48747 | | WetDep | -20.83080 | -22.06564 | -1.23484 | 5.92797 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PAN +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1932.07080 | 1929.91308 | -2.15773 | -0.11168 | | Convection | -61.40075 | -20.84436 | 40.55640 | -66.05195 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1255.71650 | | Mixing | -1316.49392 | -1169.46041 | 147.03352 | -11.16857 | | WetDep | -6.85459 | -6.35331 | 0.50128 | -7.31304 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PAN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -37.13149 | -37.42281 | -0.29132 | 0.78455 | | Convection | 0.00160 | 0.00045 | -0.00115 | -71.97344 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.89395 | | Mixing | 0.27006 | 0.39014 | 0.12007 | 44.46126 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PFE budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PFE +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -1.99397 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00038 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 6.19016 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -3.31955 | -3.31955 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PFE +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -1.99397 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00038 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 6.19014 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -3.31955 | -3.31955 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PFE +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -1.32004 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 4.03917 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.43692 | -0.43692 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PFE +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00002 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ PIP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PIP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.53499 | 22.68181 | -0.85317 | -3.62513 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -16.49195 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 41.85800 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -89.47533 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PIP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 23.68935 | 22.88642 | -0.80293 | -3.38941 | | Convection | -0.00164 | -0.00141 | 0.00023 | -13.84456 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 41.46108 | | Mixing | -0.00121 | -0.00401 | -0.00280 | 232.14489 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PIP +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1246.38863 | 1352.81245 | 106.42381 | 8.53857 | | Convection | -160.33240 | -155.55132 | 4.78108 | -2.98198 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -90.71022 | | Mixing | -328.67793 | -304.09620 | 24.58173 | -7.47897 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PIP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.15437 | -0.20461 | -0.05024 | 32.54790 | | Convection | 0.00164 | 0.00141 | -0.00023 | -13.84456 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1.19049 | | Mixing | 0.00121 | 0.00401 | 0.00280 | 232.14489 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 293.61371 | 291.22119 | -2.39252 | -0.81485 | | Convection | -0.21038 | -0.22871 | -0.01833 | 8.71380 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -140.16957 | | Mixing | -163.54451 | -156.13745 | 7.40706 | -4.52908 | | WetDep | -142.26558 | -147.05236 | -4.78678 | 3.36468 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 293.65401 | 291.28372 | -2.37029 | -0.80717 | | Convection | -0.21064 | -0.22896 | -0.01832 | 8.69611 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -140.05472 | | Mixing | -163.54479 | -156.13859 | 7.40620 | -4.52855 | | WetDep | -142.26558 | -147.05236 | -4.78678 | 3.36468 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PP +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 408.50929 | 414.09602 | 5.58673 | 1.36759 | | Convection | -18.30395 | -15.30847 | 2.99548 | -16.36520 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -67.38354 | | Mixing | -205.76666 | -194.53014 | 11.23652 | -5.46081 | | WetDep | -54.19125 | -46.75240 | 7.43886 | -13.72705 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.04030 | -0.06253 | -0.02223 | 55.17241 | | Convection | 0.00026 | 0.00025 | -0.00001 | -5.51409 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -256.11330 | | Mixing | 0.00029 | 0.00114 | 0.00086 | 300.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PPN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PPN +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 128.97109 | 122.66774 | -6.30335 | -4.88741 | | Convection | -0.00005 | -0.00007 | -0.00002 | 49.73896 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -1.30439 | | Mixing | -109.83843 | -101.13939 | 8.69904 | -7.91985 | | WetDep | -0.96323 | -0.99246 | -0.02924 | 3.03537 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PPN +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 128.64441 | 122.33899 | -6.30541 | -4.90143 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00002 | 0.00002 | 396.90404 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.02056 | | Mixing | -109.84510 | -101.15392 | 8.69118 | -7.91221 | | WetDep | -0.96323 | -0.99246 | -0.02924 | 3.03537 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PPN +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 144.42538 | 131.97452 | -12.45087 | -8.62097 | | Convection | -12.85858 | -8.96976 | 3.88883 | -30.24303 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 76.79257 | | Mixing | -162.39087 | -139.39264 | 22.99823 | -14.16227 | | WetDep | -0.44629 | -0.40679 | 0.03950 | -8.84991 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PPN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.32669 | 0.32875 | 0.00206 | 0.63176 | | Convection | -0.00005 | -0.00010 | -0.00004 | 77.42686 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.18857 | | Mixing | 0.00667 | 0.01453 | 0.00786 | 117.76417 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PROPNN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PROPNN +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 160.51008 | 136.67196 | -23.83811 | -14.85147 | | Convection | -1.08054 | -1.08952 | -0.00898 | 0.83067 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 29.27490 | | Mixing | -106.94618 | -86.41925 | 20.52693 | -19.19370 | | WetDep | -45.88673 | -42.77292 | 3.11381 | -6.78586 | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PROPNN +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 160.52022 | 136.68852 | -23.83171 | -14.84654 | | Convection | -1.08067 | -1.08968 | -0.00900 | 0.83325 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 29.56704 | | Mixing | -106.94625 | -86.41955 | 20.52671 | -19.19348 | | WetDep | -45.88673 | -42.77292 | 3.11381 | -6.78586 | +-------------+------------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PROPNN +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 124.88302 | 115.29196 | -9.59106 | -7.68003 | | Convection | -5.86940 | -7.71467 | -1.84527 | 31.43884 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -34.71358 | | Mixing | -124.53369 | -102.72731 | 21.80637 | -17.51042 | | WetDep | -21.69268 | -17.56873 | 4.12395 | -19.01079 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PROPNN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01015 | -0.01655 | -0.00641 | 63.14199 | | Convection | 0.00013 | 0.00016 | 0.00003 | 22.05346 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.87570 | | Mixing | 0.00007 | 0.00030 | 0.00022 | 314.28571 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PRPE budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PRPE +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2995.98199 | -2930.87353 | 65.10846 | -2.17319 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 38.30190 | | EmisDryDep | 2.99257 | 2.99319 | 0.00062 | 0.02068 | | Mixing | 3001.16812 | 2934.12377 | -67.04435 | -2.23394 | | WetDep | -0.00718 | -0.00842 | -0.00124 | 17.28178 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PRPE +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2995.86887 | -2930.75060 | 65.11827 | -2.17360 | | Convection | -0.00050 | -0.00038 | 0.00012 | -23.25369 | | EmisDryDep | 2.89212 | 2.88939 | -0.00274 | -0.09460 | | Mixing | 3001.16812 | 2934.12377 | -67.04435 | -2.23394 | | WetDep | -0.00718 | -0.00842 | -0.00124 | 17.28178 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PRPE +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2200.12725 | -2082.38309 | 117.74416 | -5.35170 | | Convection | -265.44392 | -313.14777 | -47.70385 | 17.97135 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -56.71286 | | Mixing | 2549.80410 | 2503.19269 | -46.61142 | -1.82804 | | WetDep | -0.00483 | -0.00523 | -0.00040 | 8.24944 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PRPE +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.11313 | -0.12293 | -0.00981 | 8.67052 | | Convection | 0.00050 | 0.00038 | -0.00012 | -23.28425 | | EmisDryDep | 0.10045 | 0.10381 | 0.00335 | 3.33969 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PRPN budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PRPN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.17674 | 8.84259 | 0.66585 | 8.14324 | | Convection | -0.00092 | -0.00102 | -0.00010 | 11.07731 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -136.97916 | | Mixing | -5.43758 | -5.57785 | -0.14027 | 2.57959 | | WetDep | -1.89203 | -2.42234 | -0.53030 | 28.02820 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PRPN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 8.17706 | 8.84319 | 0.66613 | 8.14636 | | Convection | -0.00093 | -0.00104 | -0.00012 | 12.84661 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -137.03171 | | Mixing | -5.43758 | -5.57785 | -0.14027 | 2.57970 | | WetDep | -1.89203 | -2.42234 | -0.53030 | 28.02820 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PRPN +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -15.58452 | -16.95742 | -1.37290 | 8.80936 | | Convection | -1.76227 | -0.98124 | 0.78102 | -44.31929 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -14.82817 | | Mixing | -5.99723 | -5.98377 | 0.01346 | -0.22439 | | WetDep | -0.93511 | -0.96346 | -0.02835 | 3.03133 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PRPN +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00032 | -0.00060 | -0.00028 | 87.15415 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00003 | 0.00002 | 167.01200 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 65.26878 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 300.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PYAC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : PYAC +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -112.66632 | -116.67689 | -4.01057 | 3.55969 | | Convection | -13.92312 | -14.45897 | -0.53585 | 3.84865 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.38922 | | Mixing | -43.19553 | -38.74982 | 4.44571 | -10.29207 | | WetDep | -39.33727 | -39.15558 | 0.18169 | -0.46188 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : PYAC +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -112.64144 | -116.64898 | -4.00754 | 3.55778 | | Convection | -13.92313 | -14.45898 | -0.53585 | 3.84865 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 7.96812 | | Mixing | -43.19560 | -38.74990 | 4.44569 | -10.29201 | | WetDep | -39.33727 | -39.15558 | 0.18169 | -0.46188 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : PYAC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2.32757 | -2.86419 | -0.53662 | 23.05483 | | Convection | -1.98842 | -1.87113 | 0.11729 | -5.89841 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -80.80273 | | Mixing | -46.45167 | -42.42636 | 4.02531 | -8.66558 | | WetDep | -11.23230 | -9.79542 | 1.43688 | -12.79239 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : PYAC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.02488 | -0.02791 | -0.00303 | 12.19713 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -588.07985 | | Mixing | 0.00006 | 0.00008 | 0.00002 | 33.33333 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ R4N2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : R4N2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 51.70290 | 41.01572 | -10.68718 | -20.67037 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00002 | -0.00001 | 50.60806 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 59.07480 | | Mixing | -44.73181 | -34.20064 | 10.53116 | -23.54290 | | WetDep | -0.10383 | -0.09995 | 0.00387 | -3.72830 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : R4N2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 51.92015 | 41.18588 | -10.73426 | -20.67457 | | Convection | -0.00021 | -0.00014 | 0.00007 | -32.38899 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 62.09788 | | Mixing | -44.73578 | -34.20705 | 10.52873 | -23.53536 | | WetDep | -0.10383 | -0.09995 | 0.00387 | -3.72830 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : R4N2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 104.58609 | 96.77639 | -7.80970 | -7.46725 | | Convection | -0.04719 | -0.02377 | 0.02342 | -49.63577 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -92.72501 | | Mixing | -54.95745 | -43.18041 | 11.77704 | -21.42938 | | WetDep | -0.03541 | -0.03123 | 0.00418 | -11.79386 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : R4N2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.21725 | -0.17016 | 0.04708 | -21.67196 | | Convection | 0.00019 | 0.00012 | -0.00007 | -37.80802 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 34.09496 | | Mixing | 0.00397 | 0.00641 | 0.00244 | 61.38996 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ R4P budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : R4P +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 131.88063 | 126.00734 | -5.87329 | -4.45349 | | Convection | -0.25784 | -0.25899 | -0.00115 | 0.44492 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 58.22800 | | Mixing | -54.50719 | -49.61225 | 4.89494 | -8.98036 | | WetDep | -78.19739 | -77.14376 | 1.05363 | -1.34739 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : R4P +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 131.89220 | 126.03733 | -5.85486 | -4.43913 | | Convection | -0.25805 | -0.25924 | -0.00118 | 0.45893 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 194.86149 | | Mixing | -54.50811 | -49.61398 | 4.89414 | -8.97873 | | WetDep | -78.19739 | -77.14376 | 1.05363 | -1.34739 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : R4P +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 104.59216 | 101.20961 | -3.38255 | -3.23404 | | Convection | 2.50656 | 2.76277 | 0.25622 | 10.22180 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -133.32023 | | Mixing | -54.95210 | -51.26071 | 3.69139 | -6.71746 | | WetDep | -23.59667 | -19.81221 | 3.78446 | -16.03812 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : R4P +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01157 | -0.03000 | -0.01843 | 159.36396 | | Convection | 0.00021 | 0.00025 | 0.00004 | 17.63255 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -16.98007 | | Mixing | 0.00092 | 0.00173 | 0.00081 | 87.77778 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RA3P budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RA3P +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 57.02191 | 57.30666 | 0.28475 | 0.49937 | | Convection | -0.08461 | -0.09174 | -0.00713 | 8.42494 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1308.58808 | | Mixing | -22.90059 | -22.23789 | 0.66270 | -2.89382 | | WetDep | -28.54958 | -29.10527 | -0.55569 | 1.94641 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RA3P +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 57.00206 | 57.30739 | 0.30534 | 0.53566 | | Convection | -0.08468 | -0.09181 | -0.00713 | 8.42231 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -229.21509 | | Mixing | -22.90108 | -22.23890 | 0.66218 | -2.89147 | | WetDep | -28.54958 | -29.10527 | -0.55569 | 1.94641 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RA3P +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 46.45838 | 46.68963 | 0.23125 | 0.49775 | | Convection | 0.61329 | 0.82009 | 0.20680 | 33.71972 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -86.47634 | | Mixing | -23.49500 | -23.24885 | 0.24615 | -1.04769 | | WetDep | -8.27878 | -7.35917 | 0.91961 | -11.10807 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RA3P +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.01986 | -0.00073 | -0.02059 | -103.67893 | | Convection | 0.00006 | 0.00007 | 0.00000 | 4.97835 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -25.90200 | | Mixing | 0.00049 | 0.00101 | 0.00052 | 106.77083 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RB3P budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RB3P +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 147.48061 | 149.10033 | 1.61973 | 1.09826 | | Convection | -0.21212 | -0.22726 | -0.01514 | 7.13722 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 27.20791 | | Mixing | -62.10911 | -60.78593 | 1.32317 | -2.13040 | | WetDep | -70.11762 | -72.14257 | -2.02495 | 2.88794 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RB3P +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 147.49149 | 149.13914 | 1.64765 | 1.11712 | | Convection | -0.21227 | -0.22741 | -0.01514 | 7.13346 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 55.22831 | | Mixing | -62.11042 | -60.78849 | 1.32192 | -2.12834 | | WetDep | -70.11762 | -72.14257 | -2.02495 | 2.88794 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RB3P +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 130.96528 | 133.66256 | 2.69727 | 2.05953 | | Convection | -0.25296 | 0.55509 | 0.80806 | -319.43657 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -176.65707 | | Mixing | -65.85067 | -65.31460 | 0.53607 | -0.81407 | | WetDep | -21.26251 | -18.90641 | 2.35610 | -11.08101 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RB3P +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.01088 | -0.03881 | -0.02792 | 256.61972 | | Convection | 0.00015 | 0.00015 | 0.00000 | 1.80000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -20.25381 | | Mixing | 0.00131 | 0.00256 | 0.00125 | 95.70313 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RCHO budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RCHO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2.78058 | 1.52332 | -1.25726 | -45.21579 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 19.38044 | | EmisDryDep | 0.62107 | 0.62036 | -0.00071 | -0.11372 | | Mixing | 7.38876 | 7.70250 | 0.31374 | 4.24623 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RCHO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2.82421 | 1.56463 | -1.25957 | -44.59914 | | Convection | -0.00051 | -0.00049 | 0.00002 | -3.65413 | | EmisDryDep | 0.60032 | 0.59892 | -0.00140 | -0.23349 | | Mixing | 7.38810 | 7.70124 | 0.31314 | 4.23850 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RCHO +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 257.13028 | 272.95757 | 15.82729 | 6.15536 | | Convection | -89.33031 | -112.44243 | -23.11212 | 25.87266 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -107.18880 | | Mixing | -210.64119 | -190.49104 | 20.15014 | -9.56610 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RCHO +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.04362 | -0.04131 | 0.00231 | -5.29336 | | Convection | 0.00051 | 0.00049 | -0.00002 | -3.65413 | | EmisDryDep | 0.02075 | 0.02144 | 0.00070 | 3.35193 | | Mixing | 0.00066 | 0.00126 | 0.00060 | 91.06796 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RIPA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RIPA +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2205.84157 | 2353.54788 | 147.70631 | 6.69614 | | Convection | -338.01902 | -372.68112 | -34.66210 | 10.25448 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -67.05547 | | Mixing | -1282.41666 | -1340.75090 | -58.33424 | 4.54877 | | WetDep | -553.38210 | -603.92247 | -50.54037 | 9.13300 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RIPA +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2205.84321 | 2353.55049 | 147.70729 | 6.69618 | | Convection | -338.01912 | -372.68120 | -34.66208 | 10.25447 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -67.02496 | | Mixing | -1282.41666 | -1340.75098 | -58.33432 | 4.54878 | | WetDep | -553.38210 | -603.92247 | -50.54037 | 9.13300 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RIPA +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2820.73904 | 3081.65483 | 260.91579 | 9.24991 | | Convection | -76.35740 | -76.38700 | -0.02960 | 0.03876 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -100.62461 | | Mixing | -1423.08963 | -1492.39618 | -69.30654 | 4.87015 | | WetDep | -209.24444 | -188.84870 | 20.39574 | -9.74733 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RIPA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00163 | -0.00262 | -0.00098 | 60.00000 | | Convection | 0.00010 | 0.00008 | -0.00002 | -20.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -102.76730 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00008 | 0.00008 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RIPB budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RIPB +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 442.51888 | 468.26782 | 25.74895 | 5.81872 | | Convection | -64.51288 | -70.40816 | -5.89528 | 9.13814 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -114.12126 | | Mixing | -269.04674 | -279.36538 | -10.31864 | 3.83526 | | WetDep | -108.24141 | -117.18676 | -8.94536 | 8.26426 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RIPB +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 442.51928 | 468.26831 | 25.74903 | 5.81874 | | Convection | -64.51291 | -70.40818 | -5.89527 | 9.13813 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -114.12442 | | Mixing | -269.04674 | -279.36538 | -10.31864 | 3.83526 | | WetDep | -108.24141 | -117.18676 | -8.94536 | 8.26426 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RIPB +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 620.86927 | 675.23226 | 54.36299 | 8.75595 | | Convection | -17.25695 | -18.61717 | -1.36022 | 7.88216 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -105.43608 | | Mixing | -306.71693 | -319.48392 | -12.76699 | 4.16247 | | WetDep | -43.42216 | -39.29448 | 4.12768 | -9.50594 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RIPB +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00041 | -0.00049 | -0.00008 | 20.00000 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00002 | -0.00001 | -20.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -766.89189 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RIPC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RIPC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 75.23677 | 80.34727 | 5.11051 | 6.79257 | | Convection | -11.10993 | -12.19393 | -1.08400 | 9.75705 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -62.58513 | | Mixing | -44.62206 | -47.01637 | -2.39431 | 5.36575 | | WetDep | -16.99205 | -18.50088 | -1.50883 | 8.87960 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RIPC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 75.23679 | 80.34729 | 5.11051 | 6.79256 | | Convection | -11.10993 | -12.19393 | -1.08400 | 9.75705 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -62.58519 | | Mixing | -44.62206 | -47.01637 | -2.39431 | 5.36575 | | WetDep | -16.99205 | -18.50088 | -1.50883 | 8.87960 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RIPC +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 98.69088 | 108.19242 | 9.50153 | 9.62757 | | Convection | -2.93612 | -3.10629 | -0.17017 | 5.79576 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -114.72953 | | Mixing | -49.68225 | -52.51180 | -2.82955 | 5.69530 | | WetDep | -6.97499 | -6.41348 | 0.56150 | -8.05026 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RIPC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00002 | -0.00002 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -350.00000 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RIPD budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RIPD +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 28.67273 | 30.28046 | 1.60773 | 5.60719 | | Convection | -4.31479 | -4.68953 | -0.37475 | 8.68520 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -96.96670 | | Mixing | -18.42666 | -19.10304 | -0.67638 | 3.67065 | | WetDep | -7.00199 | -7.52143 | -0.51944 | 7.41845 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RIPD +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 28.67274 | 30.28047 | 1.60773 | 5.60717 | | Convection | -4.31479 | -4.68954 | -0.37475 | 8.68519 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -96.96184 | | Mixing | -18.42666 | -19.10304 | -0.67638 | 3.67065 | | WetDep | -7.00199 | -7.52143 | -0.51944 | 7.41845 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RIPD +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 41.43659 | 45.06037 | 3.62378 | 8.74536 | | Convection | -1.21468 | -1.32333 | -0.10865 | 8.94471 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -199.25958 | | Mixing | -20.92402 | -21.76766 | -0.84364 | 4.03192 | | WetDep | -2.88952 | -2.62201 | 0.26751 | -9.25792 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RIPD +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | 0.00000 | -20.00000 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -25.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -352.47748 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ RP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : RP +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 143.86662 | 138.70206 | -5.16456 | -3.58983 | | Convection | -0.12243 | -0.12928 | -0.00685 | 5.59258 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -813.32973 | | Mixing | -63.46283 | -58.77029 | 4.69253 | -7.39414 | | WetDep | -87.32023 | -85.88676 | 1.43346 | -1.64162 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : RP +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 143.99975 | 138.83106 | -5.16869 | -3.58937 | | Convection | -0.12266 | -0.12951 | -0.00685 | 5.58684 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -608.84318 | | Mixing | -63.46482 | -58.77433 | 4.69049 | -7.39069 | | WetDep | -87.32023 | -85.88676 | 1.43346 | -1.64162 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : RP +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 114.38660 | 107.94293 | -6.44367 | -5.63324 | | Convection | 4.63106 | 5.67602 | 1.04496 | 22.56412 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 1.10082 | | Mixing | -62.75746 | -58.00122 | 4.75623 | -7.57875 | | WetDep | -21.61194 | -18.10018 | 3.51175 | -16.24915 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : RP +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.13313 | -0.12900 | 0.00413 | -3.10054 | | Convection | 0.00022 | 0.00023 | 0.00001 | 2.46404 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.34956 | | Mixing | 0.00199 | 0.00404 | 0.00204 | 102.56410 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ SALA budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SALA +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -68.39295 | -76.31372 | -7.92077 | 11.58126 | | Convection | -2315.26624 | -2495.30282 | -180.03657 | 7.77606 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -137.40204 | | Mixing | 4406.50715 | 5082.30323 | 675.79609 | 15.33632 | | WetDep | -2049.64266 | -2511.78877 | -462.14612 | 22.54764 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SALA +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -68.32123 | -76.25627 | -7.93505 | 11.61432 | | Convection | -2315.26624 | -2495.30233 | -180.03608 | 7.77604 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -127.16836 | | Mixing | 4406.50257 | 5082.29735 | 675.79478 | 15.33631 | | WetDep | -2049.64184 | -2511.78796 | -462.14612 | 22.54765 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SALA +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -10.24025 | -7.75104 | 2.48920 | -24.30805 | | Convection | -1458.13933 | -1473.63348 | -15.49415 | 1.06260 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -88.98160 | | Mixing | 2956.21992 | 3512.75037 | 556.53045 | 18.82575 | | WetDep | -621.36644 | -719.68587 | -98.31942 | 15.82310 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SALA +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.07173 | -0.05745 | 0.01428 | -19.90741 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00049 | -0.00049 | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 8.21715 | | Mixing | 0.00458 | 0.00589 | 0.00131 | 28.57143 | | WetDep | -0.00082 | -0.00082 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ SALAAL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SALAAL +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -4626.32394 | -5317.88048 | -691.55654 | 14.94829 | | Convection | -7.37337 | -7.36273 | 0.01064 | -0.14427 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 9045.36770 | | Mixing | 4637.94386 | 5331.80018 | 693.85633 | 14.96043 | | WetDep | -2.42214 | -4.77888 | -2.35673 | 97.29951 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SALAAL +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -4626.32394 | -5317.88048 | -691.55654 | 14.94829 | | Convection | -7.37337 | -7.36273 | 0.01064 | -0.14427 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 9045.36770 | | Mixing | 4637.94386 | 5331.80018 | 693.85633 | 14.96043 | | WetDep | -2.42214 | -4.77888 | -2.35673 | 97.29951 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SALAAL +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -4567.20363 | -5248.13778 | -680.93416 | 14.90921 | | Convection | -30.07992 | -19.59852 | 10.48140 | -34.84517 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 1471.33507 | | Mixing | 4605.38554 | 5283.45624 | 678.07070 | 14.72343 | | WetDep | -1.91102 | -3.54130 | -1.63028 | 85.30916 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SALAAL +-------------+---------+---------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------+---------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+---------+---------+---------+------------+ SALACL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SALACL +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -1563.77070 | -1721.02436 | -157.25366 | 10.05606 | | Convection | -485.26857 | -554.86422 | -69.59565 | 14.34168 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 54.32791 | | Mixing | 2499.95977 | 2874.48817 | 374.52840 | 14.98138 | | WetDep | -395.56681 | -542.16430 | -146.59748 | 37.06011 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SALACL +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -1558.41847 | -1715.89692 | -157.47844 | 10.10502 | | Convection | -485.26849 | -554.86414 | -69.59565 | 14.34168 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 49.56234 | | Mixing | 2499.93117 | 2874.45450 | 374.52333 | 14.98135 | | WetDep | -395.56567 | -542.16303 | -146.59736 | 37.06018 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SALACL +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -1147.11945 | -1220.30726 | -73.18780 | 6.38014 | | Convection | -443.49548 | -465.91809 | -22.42261 | 5.05588 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -108.80769 | | Mixing | 2068.14265 | 2373.88371 | 305.74106 | 14.78336 | | WetDep | -152.28847 | -186.84922 | -34.56074 | 22.69426 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SALACL +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -5.35222 | -5.12744 | 0.22478 | -4.19976 | | Convection | -0.00008 | -0.00008 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -313.67103 | | Mixing | 0.02861 | 0.03368 | 0.00507 | 17.71429 | | WetDep | -0.00114 | -0.00127 | -0.00012 | 10.71429 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ SALC budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SALC +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -17892.02064 | -22223.75197 | -4331.73133 | 24.21041 | | Convection | -28735.71660 | -32860.21458 | -4124.49798 | 14.35321 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 835.06284 | | Mixing | 200120.12955 | 227706.35220 | 27586.22265 | 13.78483 | | WetDep | -153851.66932 | -172466.10990 | -18614.44057 | 12.09895 | +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SALC +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -17891.53021 | -22223.38317 | -4331.85296 | 24.21175 | | Convection | -28735.71660 | -32860.21719 | -4124.50059 | 14.35322 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 820.05561 | | Mixing | 200120.10862 | 227706.35220 | 27586.24358 | 13.78484 | | WetDep | -153851.65886 | -172466.10990 | -18614.45104 | 12.09896 | +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SALC +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -7543.68221 | -8614.08097 | -1070.39876 | 14.18934 | | Convection | -25849.57058 | -28789.37615 | -2939.80556 | 11.37274 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -176.77763 | | Mixing | 170783.30047 | 191868.56505 | 21085.26458 | 12.34621 | | WetDep | -132388.58295 | -146701.09462 | -14312.51168 | 10.81099 | +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SALC +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------| | Chemistry | -0.49043 | -0.36880 | 0.12163 | -24.80000 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00262 | 0.00262 | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -1503.84542 | | Mixing | 0.02092 | 0.00000 | -0.02092 | -100.00000 | | WetDep | -0.01046 | 0.00000 | 0.01046 | -100.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+-------------+ SALCAL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SALCAL +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -218626.28325 | -249209.38440 | -30583.10115 | 13.98876 | | Convection | -4131.49772 | -4552.99980 | -421.50208 | 10.20216 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -81.44405 | | Mixing | 256210.01055 | 293909.82975 | 37699.81920 | 14.71442 | | WetDep | -33147.27419 | -39856.17707 | -6708.90288 | 20.23968 | +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SALCAL +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -218626.28325 | -249209.36347 | -30583.08023 | 13.98875 | | Convection | -4131.49772 | -4552.99980 | -421.50208 | 10.20216 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -81.44405 | | Mixing | 256210.01055 | 293909.82975 | 37699.81920 | 14.71442 | | WetDep | -33147.27419 | -39856.17707 | -6708.90288 | 20.23968 | +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SALCAL +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -208604.02433 | -237782.40930 | -29178.38497 | 13.98745 | | Convection | -6611.22890 | -6459.63905 | 151.58985 | -2.29291 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -89.81018 | | Mixing | 249553.72620 | 285677.03498 | 36123.30878 | 14.47516 | | WetDep | -31448.50945 | -37434.03508 | -5985.52563 | 19.03278 | +-------------+---------------+---------------+--------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SALCAL +-------------+---------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+---------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | -0.02092 | -0.02092 | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+---------+----------+----------+------------+ SALCCL budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SALCCL +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -11489.10404 | -14220.72939 | -2731.62535 | 23.77579 | | Convection | -15360.48145 | -17547.47221 | -2186.99076 | 14.23777 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -34.90049 | | Mixing | 110944.66387 | 126200.23391 | 15255.57004 | 13.75061 | | WetDep | -82408.26836 | -92509.90628 | -10101.63791 | 12.25804 | +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SALCCL +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------| | Chemistry | -11489.03342 | -14220.66923 | -2731.63582 | 23.77603 | | Convection | -15360.48145 | -17547.47352 | -2186.99207 | 14.23778 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -35.54264 | | Mixing | 110944.66387 | 126200.23391 | 15255.57004 | 13.75061 | | WetDep | -82408.26836 | -92509.90628 | -10101.63791 | 12.25804 | +-------------+--------------+--------------+--------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SALCCL +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------| | Chemistry | -5420.50878 | -6202.92068 | -782.41191 | 14.43429 | | Convection | -14057.71318 | -15662.59791 | -1604.88472 | 11.41640 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 85.77567 | | Mixing | 95035.08296 | 106763.86980 | 11728.78684 | 12.34153 | | WetDep | -71495.55652 | -79424.40521 | -7928.84869 | 11.08999 | +-------------+--------------+--------------+-------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SALCCL +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.07062 | -0.06016 | 0.01046 | -14.81481 | | Convection | 0.00000 | 0.00131 | 0.00131 | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -410.60751 | | Mixing | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ SO2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SO2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -4345.84394 | -4406.66245 | -60.81851 | 1.39946 | | Convection | -994.40349 | -1078.06802 | -83.66453 | 8.41354 | | EmisDryDep | 1628.91562 | 1632.83856 | 3.92295 | 0.24083 | | Mixing | 4220.15890 | 4385.08322 | 164.92431 | 3.90801 | | WetDep | -906.13309 | -896.82784 | 9.30525 | -1.02692 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SO2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -4276.65935 | -4338.09547 | -61.43613 | 1.43654 | | Convection | -994.40202 | -1078.06581 | -83.66379 | 8.41348 | | EmisDryDep | 1626.77554 | 1630.66432 | 3.88878 | 0.23905 | | Mixing | 4220.10659 | 4385.07046 | 164.96387 | 3.90900 | | WetDep | -906.11380 | -896.81485 | 9.29896 | -1.02625 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SO2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | -1861.22889 | -1713.31170 | 147.91719 | -7.94729 | | Convection | -634.91416 | -825.57389 | -190.65973 | 30.02921 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 48.74842 | | Mixing | 3084.50096 | 3261.31296 | 176.81200 | 5.73227 | | WetDep | -169.34950 | -143.61313 | 25.73637 | -15.19719 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SO2 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -69.18459 | -68.56697 | 0.61761 | -0.89271 | | Convection | -0.00147 | -0.00221 | -0.00074 | 50.00000 | | EmisDryDep | 2.14007 | 2.17424 | 0.03417 | 1.59652 | | Mixing | 0.05231 | 0.01275 | -0.03956 | -75.62500 | | WetDep | -0.01929 | -0.01300 | 0.00629 | -32.62712 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ SO4 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SO4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 10003.29630 | 10399.58506 | 396.28877 | 3.96158 | | Convection | -3347.13946 | -3442.07815 | -94.93869 | 2.83641 | | EmisDryDep | 0.86140 | 0.92450 | 0.06310 | 7.32573 | | Mixing | -1196.41287 | -1108.40117 | 88.01169 | -7.35630 | | WetDep | -6827.26972 | -7146.71665 | -319.44694 | 4.67899 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SO4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 9905.42811 | 10302.18180 | 396.75369 | 4.00542 | | Convection | -3347.11788 | -3442.06016 | -94.94228 | 2.83654 | | EmisDryDep | 0.79588 | 0.85797 | 0.06208 | 7.80073 | | Mixing | -1194.24419 | -1105.98409 | 88.26010 | -7.39046 | | WetDep | -6826.69036 | -7146.36943 | -319.67907 | 4.68278 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SO4 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 4830.03961 | 4711.59528 | -118.44433 | -2.45224 | | Convection | -586.40784 | -520.63877 | 65.76907 | -11.21559 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -89.74452 | | Mixing | -2180.34544 | -1938.17502 | 242.17042 | -11.10697 | | WetDep | -477.38969 | -405.43847 | 71.95123 | -15.07180 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SO4 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 97.86819 | 97.40326 | -0.46493 | -0.47505 | | Convection | -0.02158 | -0.01798 | 0.00360 | -16.66667 | | EmisDryDep | 0.06552 | 0.06654 | 0.00102 | 1.55547 | | Mixing | -2.16868 | -2.41708 | -0.24840 | 11.45409 | | WetDep | -0.57936 | -0.34722 | 0.23214 | -40.06772 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ SO4S budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SO4S +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 52.32227 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -13.00695 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -34.22603 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -6.39321 | -6.39321 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SO4S +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 52.32231 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -13.00695 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -34.22603 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -6.39321 | -6.39321 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SO4S +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | 68.84161 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | -12.75554 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | -47.38202 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | -2.99401 | -2.99401 | -inf | +-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SO4S +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | nan | -0.00004 | nan | nan | | Convection | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | nan | -0.00000 | nan | nan | | Mixing | nan | 0.00000 | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-----------+----------+-----------+------------+ SO4s budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SO4s +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 45.31679 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -11.91195 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -29.60389 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -5.23807 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SO4s +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 45.31681 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -11.91195 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -29.60389 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -5.23807 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SO4s +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 58.56099 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -11.95164 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | -41.15974 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -2.45673 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+-----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SO4s +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00003 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ SOAGX budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SOAGX +-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 160.75588 | 171.30271 | 10.54682 | 6.56077 | | Convection | -55.66212 | -58.57502 | -2.91290 | 5.23319 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -24.18029 | | Mixing | -24.56987 | -21.99089 | 2.57898 | -10.49653 | | WetDep | -93.21521 | -102.68226 | -9.46705 | 10.15612 | +-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SOAGX +-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 160.75588 | 171.30271 | 10.54682 | 6.56077 | | Convection | -55.66211 | -58.57501 | -2.91290 | 5.23318 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -22.70113 | | Mixing | -24.56967 | -21.99088 | 2.57879 | -10.49584 | | WetDep | -93.21460 | -102.68195 | -9.46735 | 10.15651 | +-------------+-----------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SOAGX +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 114.63970 | 113.81618 | -0.82351 | -0.71835 | | Convection | -7.81936 | -8.15996 | -0.34060 | 4.35581 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -107.52980 | | Mixing | -43.64150 | -39.82743 | 3.81407 | -8.73955 | | WetDep | -8.62226 | -6.16546 | 2.45679 | -28.49364 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SOAGX +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00002 | -0.00001 | 50.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -28.49821 | | Mixing | -0.00020 | -0.00001 | 0.00019 | -96.10390 | | WetDep | -0.00061 | -0.00032 | 0.00030 | -48.33333 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ SOAIE budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SOAIE +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1473.22855 | 1620.35059 | 147.12204 | 9.98637 | | Convection | -495.75780 | -533.59633 | -37.83853 | 7.63246 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 27.89604 | | Mixing | -188.67854 | -184.42424 | 4.25429 | -2.25478 | | WetDep | -744.44374 | -826.34574 | -81.90200 | 11.00177 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SOAIE +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 1473.22855 | 1620.35059 | 147.12204 | 9.98637 | | Convection | -495.75780 | -533.59629 | -37.83849 | 7.63245 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 10.83316 | | Mixing | -188.67598 | -184.42604 | 4.24994 | -2.25251 | | WetDep | -744.44047 | -826.34411 | -81.90364 | 11.00204 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SOAIE +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 563.79666 | 608.48572 | 44.68906 | 7.92645 | | Convection | -34.96652 | -30.17936 | 4.78715 | -13.69068 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -46.71638 | | Mixing | -280.20148 | -269.73639 | 10.46510 | -3.73485 | | WetDep | -38.02075 | -19.15144 | 18.86931 | -49.62898 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SOAIE +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00004 | -0.00004 | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -89.85935 | | Mixing | -0.00255 | 0.00180 | 0.00435 | -170.40000 | | WetDep | -0.00327 | -0.00163 | 0.00163 | -50.00000 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ SOAP budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SOAP +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -4846.23719 | -4863.43624 | -17.19904 | 0.35489 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 34.69368 | | EmisDryDep | 4.77516 | 4.73588 | -0.03928 | -0.82255 | | Mixing | 4857.49811 | 4872.33459 | 14.83648 | 0.30543 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SOAP +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -4845.82262 | -4862.95496 | -17.13234 | 0.35355 | | Convection | -0.00181 | -0.00186 | -0.00004 | 2.46625 | | EmisDryDep | 4.58617 | 4.54141 | -0.04476 | -0.97598 | | Mixing | 4857.49550 | 4872.32871 | 14.83321 | 0.30537 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SOAP +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -2247.54215 | -2083.20358 | 164.33857 | -7.31192 | | Convection | -474.04823 | -550.69818 | -76.64995 | 16.16923 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -87.62656 | | Mixing | 3914.24881 | 3980.83935 | 66.59054 | 1.70123 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SOAP +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.41458 | -0.48128 | -0.06670 | 16.08833 | | Convection | 0.00181 | 0.00186 | 0.00004 | 2.46625 | | EmisDryDep | 0.18898 | 0.19447 | 0.00548 | 2.90090 | | Mixing | 0.00262 | 0.00589 | 0.00327 | 125.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ SOAS budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : SOAS +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 4846.23719 | 4863.43624 | 17.19904 | 0.35489 | | Convection | -1988.45992 | -1942.78261 | 45.67731 | -2.29712 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.73460 | | Mixing | 348.31093 | 453.15687 | 104.84594 | 30.10125 | | WetDep | -3083.80357 | -3215.04320 | -131.23964 | 4.25577 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : SOAS +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 4845.82262 | 4862.95496 | 17.13234 | 0.35355 | | Convection | -1988.45845 | -1942.78130 | 45.67715 | -2.29711 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.08945 | | Mixing | 348.25919 | 453.08257 | 104.82338 | 30.09924 | | WetDep | -3083.76760 | -3215.02228 | -131.25468 | 4.25631 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : SOAS +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 2247.54215 | 2083.20358 | -164.33857 | -7.31192 | | Convection | -338.67076 | -317.68110 | 20.98965 | -6.19766 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -171.70110 | | Mixing | -465.48729 | -268.03844 | 197.44885 | -42.41767 | | WetDep | -227.29935 | -154.09021 | 73.20914 | -32.20825 | +-------------+------------+------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : SOAS +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.41458 | 0.48128 | 0.06670 | 16.08833 | | Convection | -0.00147 | -0.00131 | 0.00016 | -11.11111 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.60716 | | Mixing | 0.05174 | 0.07430 | 0.02256 | 43.60190 | | WetDep | -0.03596 | -0.02092 | 0.01504 | -41.81818 | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ TOLU budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TOLU +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -744.03742 | -753.08274 | -9.04532 | 1.21571 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 64.19526 | | EmisDryDep | 0.08798 | 0.10505 | 0.01707 | 19.40818 | | Mixing | 746.08275 | 754.16806 | 8.08531 | 1.08370 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TOLU +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -743.97456 | -753.00296 | -9.02840 | 1.21354 | | Convection | -0.00041 | -0.00040 | 0.00001 | -2.08229 | | EmisDryDep | 0.08798 | 0.10505 | 0.01707 | 19.40818 | | Mixing | 746.08218 | 754.16675 | 8.08457 | 1.08360 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TOLU +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -493.01818 | -470.94242 | 22.07575 | -4.47768 | | Convection | -86.77790 | -102.46290 | -15.68500 | 18.07488 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 334.16197 | | Mixing | 579.94921 | 594.65204 | 14.70284 | 2.53519 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TOLU +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.06286 | -0.07978 | -0.01692 | 26.91808 | | Convection | 0.00041 | 0.00040 | -0.00001 | -2.08229 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00057 | 0.00131 | 0.00074 | 128.57143 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ TSOA0 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOA0 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 467.46687 | 484.06228 | 16.59540 | 3.55007 | | Convection | -203.98697 | -204.99142 | -1.00444 | 0.49240 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -18.32355 | | Mixing | -76.67628 | -70.76004 | 5.91624 | -7.71586 | | WetDep | -172.97104 | -191.67927 | -18.70824 | 10.81582 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOA0 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 467.51105 | 484.09395 | 16.58290 | 3.54706 | | Convection | -203.98697 | -204.99139 | -1.00442 | 0.49239 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -23.57544 | | Mixing | -76.67436 | -70.75910 | 5.91526 | -7.71478 | | WetDep | -172.96993 | -191.67864 | -18.70871 | 10.81616 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOA0 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 432.92493 | 437.70171 | 4.77679 | 1.10337 | | Convection | -43.06224 | -42.36860 | 0.69364 | -1.61078 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 125.11843 | | Mixing | -185.66565 | -172.86958 | 12.79607 | -6.89199 | | WetDep | -18.81425 | -13.98263 | 4.83163 | -25.68068 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOA0 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.04418 | -0.03167 | 0.01251 | -28.30712 | | Convection | 0.00000 | -0.00002 | -0.00002 | nan | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -7.51447 | | Mixing | -0.00192 | -0.00094 | 0.00098 | -50.93333 | | WetDep | -0.00110 | -0.00063 | 0.00047 | -42.59259 | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ TSOA1 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOA1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 161.71294 | 171.10023 | 9.38729 | 5.80491 | | Convection | -68.78215 | -71.84327 | -3.06112 | 4.45046 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 11.54319 | | Mixing | -31.63535 | -30.02219 | 1.61316 | -5.09923 | | WetDep | -55.20583 | -62.18121 | -6.97538 | 12.63523 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOA1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 161.88619 | 171.20278 | 9.31659 | 5.75502 | | Convection | -68.78214 | -71.84326 | -3.06112 | 4.45046 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 17.67750 | | Mixing | -31.63472 | -30.02240 | 1.61233 | -5.09670 | | WetDep | -55.20521 | -62.18086 | -6.97565 | 12.63585 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOA1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | 173.86715 | 176.60003 | 2.73288 | 1.57182 | | Convection | -17.33417 | -16.64206 | 0.69210 | -3.99271 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 290.57305 | | Mixing | -84.62971 | -80.89595 | 3.73376 | -4.41188 | | WetDep | -7.49673 | -5.88185 | 1.61489 | -21.54122 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+---------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOA1 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.17325 | -0.10255 | 0.07070 | -40.80911 | | Convection | -0.00001 | -0.00001 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -7.48335 | | Mixing | -0.00063 | 0.00020 | 0.00083 | -131.98381 | | WetDep | -0.00061 | -0.00035 | 0.00027 | -43.33333 | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ TSOA2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOA2 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 483.38458 | 525.76167 | 42.37709 | 8.76674 | | Convection | -209.71601 | -224.44511 | -14.72910 | 7.02335 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -12.44792 | | Mixing | -102.89583 | -98.91702 | 3.97880 | -3.86683 | | WetDep | -145.49785 | -171.58357 | -26.08572 | 17.92859 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOA2 +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 487.18341 | 528.15746 | 40.97405 | 8.41040 | | Convection | -209.71587 | -224.44498 | -14.72912 | 7.02337 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -11.83349 | | Mixing | -102.89126 | -98.92190 | 3.96936 | -3.85782 | | WetDep | -145.49362 | -171.58083 | -26.08721 | 17.93014 | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOA2 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 629.84610 | 640.40807 | 10.56198 | 1.67691 | | Convection | -56.39650 | -51.11516 | 5.28135 | -9.36467 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -70.13029 | | Mixing | -298.48687 | -286.44674 | 12.04013 | -4.03372 | | WetDep | -20.66619 | -15.06797 | 5.59822 | -27.08877 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOA2 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -3.79883 | -2.39579 | 1.40304 | -36.93344 | | Convection | -0.00014 | -0.00012 | 0.00002 | -14.28571 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -17.43738 | | Mixing | -0.00457 | 0.00487 | 0.00944 | -206.71141 | | WetDep | -0.00423 | -0.00274 | 0.00149 | -35.26570 | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ TSOA3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOA3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 144.96217 | 159.66737 | 14.70521 | 10.14417 | | Convection | -57.86295 | -63.00006 | -5.13711 | 8.87806 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -5.76628 | | Mixing | -39.12591 | -38.23144 | 0.89448 | -2.28615 | | WetDep | -40.86121 | -48.84073 | -7.97952 | 19.52834 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOA3 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 148.02480 | 162.28339 | 14.25859 | 9.63257 | | Convection | -57.86286 | -62.99998 | -5.13713 | 8.87811 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.75807 | | Mixing | -39.12648 | -38.23774 | 0.88874 | -2.27146 | | WetDep | -40.85882 | -48.83896 | -7.98014 | 19.53101 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOA3 +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 217.27605 | 218.92066 | 1.64462 | 0.75692 | | Convection | -23.10777 | -22.01385 | 1.09392 | -4.73401 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 9.82786 | | Mixing | -118.85978 | -113.83654 | 5.02325 | -4.22620 | | WetDep | -6.28709 | -4.48386 | 1.80324 | -28.68159 | +-------------+------------+------------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOA3 +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------| | Chemistry | -3.06263 | -2.61601 | 0.44662 | -14.58282 | | Convection | -0.00009 | -0.00007 | 0.00002 | -22.22222 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -11.99887 | | Mixing | 0.00056 | 0.00630 | 0.00573 | 1015.83710 | | WetDep | -0.00240 | -0.00177 | 0.00062 | -26.01279 | +-------------+----------+----------+---------+------------+ TSOG0 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOG0 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 99.61162 | 93.76952 | -5.84210 | -5.86488 | | Convection | -15.51606 | -15.16016 | 0.35591 | -2.29379 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 2.89591 | | Mixing | -34.19418 | -28.18694 | 6.00724 | -17.56802 | | WetDep | -49.26764 | -49.65773 | -0.39010 | 0.79179 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOG0 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 99.56740 | 93.73780 | -5.82960 | -5.85493 | | Convection | -15.51608 | -15.16017 | 0.35591 | -2.29380 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -73.88824 | | Mixing | -34.19394 | -28.18659 | 6.00735 | -17.56847 | | WetDep | -49.26764 | -49.65773 | -0.39010 | 0.79179 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOG0 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 52.88952 | 49.18841 | -3.70111 | -6.99781 | | Convection | -1.97676 | -3.34938 | -1.37262 | 69.43807 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -118.02647 | | Mixing | -34.16183 | -28.25518 | 5.90665 | -17.29020 | | WetDep | -8.81677 | -8.31778 | 0.49899 | -5.65958 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOG0 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.04422 | 0.03172 | -0.01250 | -28.25786 | | Convection | 0.00001 | 0.00001 | -0.00000 | -10.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -13.45776 | | Mixing | -0.00023 | -0.00035 | -0.00011 | 47.82609 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ TSOG1 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOG1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 163.25158 | 161.74030 | -1.51128 | -0.92574 | | Convection | -24.36201 | -25.47593 | -1.11392 | 4.57236 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 88.77832 | | Mixing | -61.42576 | -53.40427 | 8.02149 | -13.05884 | | WetDep | -76.30550 | -80.83723 | -4.53173 | 5.93894 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOG1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 163.07831 | 161.63772 | -1.44060 | -0.88338 | | Convection | -24.36204 | -25.47595 | -1.11391 | 4.57231 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -123.87280 | | Mixing | -61.42503 | -53.40347 | 8.02155 | -13.05910 | | WetDep | -76.30550 | -80.83723 | -4.53173 | 5.93894 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOG1 +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 110.78955 | 110.03430 | -0.75525 | -0.68170 | | Convection | -4.72827 | -8.14599 | -3.41772 | 72.28271 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -79.30454 | | Mixing | -66.24969 | -58.52274 | 7.72694 | -11.66337 | | WetDep | -18.26622 | -17.27976 | 0.98646 | -5.40047 | +-------------+-----------+-----------+----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOG1 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.17326 | 0.10258 | -0.07068 | -40.79491 | | Convection | 0.00003 | 0.00002 | -0.00001 | -33.33333 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -6.99298 | | Mixing | -0.00074 | -0.00080 | -0.00006 | 8.33333 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ TSOG2 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOG2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2877.56677 | 2781.26632 | -96.30045 | -3.34659 | | Convection | -457.36970 | -478.15194 | -20.78224 | 4.54386 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 42.73906 | | Mixing | -1211.60442 | -1037.31159 | 174.29283 | -14.38529 | | WetDep | -1186.55278 | -1225.89325 | -39.34047 | 3.31553 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOG2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2873.76790 | 2778.87073 | -94.89716 | -3.30219 | | Convection | -457.37011 | -478.15231 | -20.78220 | 4.54385 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 191.39984 | | Mixing | -1211.57924 | -1037.29083 | 174.28841 | -14.38523 | | WetDep | -1186.55278 | -1225.89325 | -39.34047 | 3.31553 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOG2 +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | 2356.63693 | 2271.84180 | -84.79513 | -3.59814 | | Convection | -92.00924 | -118.87759 | -26.86835 | 29.20180 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -146.34096 | | Mixing | -1359.93741 | -1182.40432 | 177.53309 | -13.05450 | | WetDep | -336.11016 | -290.43117 | 45.67899 | -13.59048 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOG2 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 3.79887 | 2.39559 | -1.40328 | -36.93950 | | Convection | 0.00041 | 0.00037 | -0.00004 | -10.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -3.12532 | | Mixing | -0.02518 | -0.02076 | 0.00441 | -17.53247 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ TSOG3 budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : TSOG3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 5943.74298 | 5699.34617 | -244.39681 | -4.11183 | | Convection | -903.68372 | -944.61760 | -40.93388 | 4.52967 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -4.53330 | | Mixing | -2659.18595 | -2273.83442 | 385.35153 | -14.49133 | | WetDep | -2331.75187 | -2390.98826 | -59.23639 | 2.54042 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : TSOG3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 5940.68008 | 5696.72924 | -243.95084 | -4.10645 | | Convection | -903.68438 | -944.61842 | -40.93404 | 4.52968 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -2.65789 | | Mixing | -2659.12219 | -2273.79109 | 385.33110 | -14.49091 | | WetDep | -2331.75187 | -2390.98826 | -59.23639 | 2.54042 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : TSOG3 +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------| | Chemistry | 5290.82282 | 5058.46835 | -232.35447 | -4.39165 | | Convection | -218.95501 | -265.86152 | -46.90651 | 21.42290 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 302.84784 | | Mixing | -3096.82480 | -2693.29942 | 403.52538 | -13.03029 | | WetDep | -720.01184 | -608.76498 | 111.24686 | -15.45070 | +-------------+-------------+-------------+------------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : TSOG3 +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | 3.06290 | 2.61693 | -0.44596 | -14.56020 | | Convection | 0.00065 | 0.00082 | 0.00016 | 25.00000 | | EmisDryDep | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 0.00000 | -7.00085 | | Mixing | -0.06376 | -0.04332 | 0.02043 | -32.05128 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ XYLE budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : XYLE +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -599.20372 | -613.83876 | -14.63503 | 2.44241 | | Convection | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | 11.33224 | | EmisDryDep | 0.09135 | 0.10934 | 0.01799 | 19.69507 | | Mixing | 593.13715 | 607.41576 | 14.27862 | 2.40730 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : XYLE +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -599.19951 | -613.83300 | -14.63348 | 2.44217 | | Convection | -0.00008 | -0.00010 | -0.00002 | 22.95715 | | EmisDryDep | 0.09135 | 0.10934 | 0.01799 | 19.69507 | | Mixing | 593.13711 | 607.41568 | 14.27857 | 2.40730 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : XYLE +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------| | Chemistry | -492.85658 | -488.66692 | 4.18966 | -0.85008 | | Convection | -42.37120 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | -0.00000 | -0.00000 | -519.85968 | | Mixing | 507.91024 | 524.60042 | 16.69018 | 3.28605 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+------------+------------+-----------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : XYLE +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------| | Chemistry | -0.00421 | -0.00576 | -0.00155 | 36.89320 | | Convection | 0.00008 | 0.00010 | 0.00002 | 22.95715 | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | | Mixing | 0.00004 | 0.00008 | 0.00004 | 100.00000 | | WetDep | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | 0.00000 | nan | +-------------+----------+----------+----------+------------+ pFe budgets (Ref=GC_12.8.0; Dev=GCHP_12.9.0) Full [Gg] : pFe +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -2.03241 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00032 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 6.04823 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -3.14720 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Trop [Gg] : pFe +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -2.03241 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00032 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 6.04822 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -3.14720 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ PBL [Gg] : pFe +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | -1.15481 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 3.69253 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.56125 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ Strat [Gg] : pFe +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+ | Operation | Ref | Dev | Diff | Pct_diff | |-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------| | Chemistry | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Convection | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | EmisDryDep | 0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | | Mixing | 0.00001 | nan | nan | nan | | WetDep | -0.00000 | nan | nan | nan | +-------------+----------+-------+--------+------------+