######################################################################################################### ### Global mass (Gg) at 01Apr2019 (Trop only) ### ### ### ### Ref = GCC_14.2.0 ### ### Dev = GCHP_14.2.0 ### ### ### ### Dev and Ref show 320 differences ### ######################################################################################################### Ref Dev Dev - Ref % diff diffs A3O2 : 0.084187 0.085298 0.001111 1.319494 * ACET : 5191.148367 5216.661367 25.513000 0.491471 * ACTA : 379.897385 392.413325 12.515940 3.294558 * AERI : 5.886333 5.970440 0.084107 1.428847 * ALD2 : 254.906550 253.845705 -1.060845 -0.416170 * ALK4 : 753.124991 758.373276 5.248285 0.696868 * AONITA : 56.917562 58.260362 1.342800 2.359202 * AROMP4 : 0.100520 0.101163 0.000643 0.639683 * AROMP5 : 0.057394 0.059168 0.001774 3.091026 * AROMRO2 : 0.086564 0.085737 -0.000828 -0.956117 * ASOA1 : 6.849287 7.179873 0.330586 4.826571 * ASOA2 : 2.567689 2.813465 0.245777 9.571906 * ASOA3 : 3.266041 3.732841 0.466801 14.292559 * ASOAN : 43.529842 43.263905 -0.265937 -0.610931 * ASOG1 : 4.214983 4.207142 -0.007841 -0.186019 * ASOG2 : 7.327271 7.593611 0.266340 3.634918 * ASOG3 : 80.438749 82.505160 2.066411 2.568925 * ATO2 : 0.397474 0.396147 -0.001326 -0.333617 * ATOOH : 147.751166 149.686015 1.934849 1.309532 * B3O2 : 0.288136 0.288983 0.000847 0.293866 * BALD : 1.029240 1.018084 -0.011157 -1.083981 * BCPI : 92.014355 93.556007 1.541653 1.675448 * BCPO : 16.053505 16.055374 0.001869 0.011642 * BENZ : 183.175727 181.988839 -1.186888 -0.647950 * BENZO : 0.007129 0.007279 0.000150 2.105143 * BENZO2 : 0.252911 0.251928 -0.000983 -0.388540 * BENZP : 66.575918 66.660476 0.084559 0.127011 * BRO2 : 0.067146 0.066093 -0.001053 -1.568435 * BUTDI : 2162.407625 2162.302608 -0.105017 -0.004856 * BZCO3 : 0.001146 0.001143 -0.000003 -0.250155 * BZCO3H : 0.407522 0.403616 -0.003906 -0.958593 * BZPAN : 3.746639 3.941155 0.194516 5.191757 * Br : 0.450800 0.471703 0.020903 4.636826 * Br2 : 4.149824 4.251461 0.101637 2.449183 * BrCl : 3.689968 3.959196 0.269228 7.296213 * BrNO2 : 0.205500 0.223519 0.018019 8.768186 * BrNO3 : 13.008103 13.920936 0.912833 7.017417 * BrO : 4.669207 4.944170 0.274963 5.888862 * BrSALA : 0.330210 0.332265 0.002055 0.622292 * BrSALC : 4.500445 4.580400 0.079955 1.776601 * C2H2 : 194.998496 194.027918 -0.970578 -0.497736 * C2H4 : 99.341268 100.160588 0.819320 0.824753 * C2H6 : 1803.405065 1794.230694 -9.174371 -0.508725 * C3H8 : 534.231606 537.514663 3.283057 0.614538 * C4HVP1 : 0.000766 0.000827 0.000061 7.925995 * C4HVP2 : 0.001892 0.002069 0.000177 9.331746 * CCl4 : 1704.963433 1706.464456 1.501023 0.088038 * CFC11 : 4410.312629 4414.052749 3.740120 0.084804 * CFC113 : 1865.508414 1866.816435 1.308022 0.070116 * CFC114 : 387.691594 387.912353 0.220759 0.056942 * CFC115 : 188.747864 188.845417 0.097553 0.051684 * CFC12 : 8691.360307 8697.082940 5.722633 0.065843 * CH2Br2 : 17.693125 17.686422 -0.006703 -0.037885 * CH2Cl2 : 407.341613 411.670753 4.329140 1.062779 * CH2I2 : 0.044235 0.044216 -0.000019 -0.043794 * CH2IBr : 0.053758 0.053627 -0.000131 -0.244447 * CH2ICl : 0.214934 0.213944 -0.000991 -0.460913 * CH2O : 933.699671 944.173133 10.473461 1.121716 * CH2OO : 0.000002 0.000002 8.83142252e-08 4.364661 * CH3Br : 88.556121 88.884302 0.328181 0.370591 * CH3CCl3 : 27.637152 27.651729 0.014577 0.052744 * CH3CHOO : 0.000010 0.000010 -8.52926285e-08 -0.857653 * CH3Cl : 3808.941024 3824.186389 15.245365 0.400252 * CH3I : 4.391945 4.372479 -0.019466 -0.443228 * CH4 : 4268503.978986 4272599.654343 4095.675357 0.095951 * CHBr3 : 19.726999 19.626485 -0.100514 -0.509526 * CHCl3 : 143.481502 144.599370 1.117867 0.779102 * CLOCK : 1.14736684e+19 3.12246974e+18 -8.35119869e+18 -72.785777 * CO : 288059.970834 289153.497817 1093.526983 0.379618 * CO2 : 1.74910940e+09 1.74996475e+09 855352.067451 0.048902 * CSL : 0.393071 0.401276 0.008205 2.087419 * Cl : 0.000172 0.000178 0.000005 3.100430 * Cl2 : 0.947270 1.046175 0.098904 10.440993 * Cl2O2 : 0.000661 0.000120 -0.000541 -81.821989 * ClNO2 : 2.778697 3.089800 0.311103 11.196011 * ClNO3 : 2.886051 2.911738 0.025687 0.890037 * ClO : 0.265948 0.273174 0.007225 2.716833 * ClOO : 0.000019 0.000018 -7.98181779e-07 -4.212747 * DMS : 174.309421 180.523523 6.214103 3.564984 * DST1 : 4334.451305 3970.325941 -364.125364 -8.400726 * DST2 : 4040.122321 3611.917451 -428.204870 -10.598810 * DST3 : 6027.699899 5330.063401 -697.636498 -11.573843 * DST4 : 4087.991572 3538.949346 -549.042226 -13.430611 * EOH : 117.166526 117.589905 0.423379 0.361348 * ETHLN : 0.718754 0.729841 0.011088 1.542622 * ETHN : 2.460533 2.535587 0.075054 3.050307 * ETHP : 33.612869 34.450962 0.838094 2.493372 * ETNO3 : 24.705223 25.086429 0.381206 1.543017 * ETO : 6.29735012e-09 6.55104256e-09 2.53692444e-10 4.028559 * ETO2 : 0.217242 0.218488 0.001246 0.573406 * ETOO : 0.213593 0.212877 -0.000717 -0.335578 * ETP : 65.550191 64.607760 -0.942430 -1.437723 * FURA : 2.759899 2.728148 -0.031751 -1.150447 * GLYC : 117.398697 119.449010 2.050313 1.746453 * GLYX : 7.800552 7.904531 0.103978 1.332961 * H : 2.92541425e-10 2.96791758e-10 4.25033293e-12 1.452900 * H1211 : 77.148140 77.235001 0.086862 0.112591 * H1301 : 70.985276 71.043577 0.058301 0.082131 * H2 : 144874.414554 144945.257897 70.843343 0.048900 * H2402 : 14.461449 14.478182 0.016733 0.115705 * H2O : 1.27724224e+10 1.27749279e+10 2505483.087616 0.019616 * H2O2 : 2741.027487 2768.177283 27.149796 0.990497 * HAC : 138.551748 143.988737 5.436989 3.924158 * HBr : 7.147556 7.437044 0.289488 4.050164 * HC5A : 3.499361 3.642772 0.143412 4.098223 * HCFC123 : 6.74987182e-23 6.94033137e-23 1.90459554e-24 nan * HCFC141b : 428.550170 429.089567 0.539397 0.125866 * HCFC142b : 325.643289 325.912484 0.269195 0.082666 * HCFC22 : 3063.071757 3066.127699 3.055941 0.099767 * HCOOH : 492.864379 513.153234 20.288854 4.116519 * HCl : 229.854749 240.030268 10.175518 4.426934 * HI : 0.332279 0.343390 0.011111 3.343955 * HMHP : 31.078224 31.547420 0.469196 1.509727 * HMML : 11.655362 11.933218 0.277857 2.383938 * HMS : 88.114397 87.229773 -0.884624 -1.003949 * HNO2 : 3.384296 3.550812 0.166516 4.920241 * HNO3 : 1181.665437 1184.361029 2.695592 0.228118 * HNO4 : 75.406263 77.326032 1.919769 2.545901 * HO2 : 24.566945 24.594164 0.027219 0.110795 * HOBr : 7.809294 8.132088 0.322794 4.133457 * HOCl : 3.852206 4.201776 0.349570 9.074550 * HOI : 9.977675 10.080227 0.102552 1.027814 * HONIT : 3.702592 3.754669 0.052078 1.406523 * HPALD1 : 2.045896 2.117582 0.071685 3.503867 * HPALD1OO : 0.004321 0.004416 0.000095 2.199573 * HPALD2 : 5.877444 6.062990 0.185546 3.156917 * HPALD2OO : 0.012672 0.012909 0.000237 1.866792 * HPALD3 : 1.872197 1.954665 0.082468 4.404881 * HPALD4 : 4.459063 4.634585 0.175521 3.936284 * HPETHNL : 3.474745 3.642138 0.167393 4.817410 * I : 0.868772 0.886289 0.017517 2.016252 * I2 : 0.035799 0.037305 0.001507 4.208781 * I2O2 : 0.013712 0.013543 -0.000169 -1.231854 * I2O3 : 0.065644 0.077990 0.012345 18.806637 * I2O4 : 0.002135 0.002675 0.000540 25.309006 * IBr : 0.109605 0.116553 0.006948 6.338838 * ICHE : 12.398262 13.281910 0.883648 7.127190 * ICHOO : 0.000370 0.000417 0.000047 12.734039 * ICN : 9.851513 9.807042 -0.044471 -0.451413 * ICNOO : 0.051211 0.050761 -0.000450 -0.878353 * ICPDH : 4.103504 4.344655 0.241151 5.876700 * ICl : 0.783509 0.840635 0.057126 7.291036 * IDC : 4.463828 4.694189 0.230361 5.160612 * IDCHP : 2.595962 2.737004 0.141042 5.433143 * IDHDP : 9.357486 9.969345 0.611859 6.538715 * IDHNBOO : 1.016752 1.007251 -0.009501 -0.934442 * IDHNDOO1 : 0.001710 0.001716 0.000005 0.312263 * IDHNDOO2 : 0.000902 0.000921 0.000019 2.157297 * IDHPE : 41.792442 43.622170 1.829729 4.378133 * IDN : 1.671132 1.707485 0.036353 2.175356 * IDNOO : 0.001257 0.001271 0.000015 1.155799 * IEPOXA : 81.915994 88.212063 6.296069 7.686007 * IEPOXAOO : 0.002323 0.002615 0.000292 12.573542 * IEPOXB : 48.283175 52.043384 3.760209 7.787824 * IEPOXBOO : 0.000924 0.001039 0.000116 12.532203 * IEPOXD : 4.503124 4.843640 0.340516 7.561769 * IHN1 : 1.747286 1.837555 0.090269 5.166215 * IHN2 : 1.702362 1.771851 0.069488 4.081865 * IHN3 : 1.353321 1.442245 0.088924 6.570826 * IHN4 : 0.384727 0.405432 0.020705 5.381722 * IHOO1 : 0.469148 0.493732 0.024584 5.240201 * IHOO4 : 0.092971 0.099334 0.006363 6.844488 * IHPNBOO : 0.001453 0.001475 0.000021 1.479118 * IHPNDOO : 0.006023 0.006202 0.000178 2.963263 * IHPOO1 : 0.004994 0.005575 0.000581 11.634249 * IHPOO2 : 0.001135 0.001245 0.000110 9.695769 * IHPOO3 : 0.007551 0.008380 0.000829 10.981699 * INA : 1.54086532e-09 1.51390189e-09 -2.69634318e-11 -1.749889 * INDIOL : 519.516622 519.385734 -0.130888 -0.025194 * INO : 0.003086 0.003139 0.000053 1.714622 * INO2B : 0.990739 0.958009 -0.032730 -3.303592 * INO2D : 0.779724 0.754515 -0.025209 -3.233057 * INPB : 3.520549 3.756883 0.236334 6.712998 * INPD : 3.749745 4.011161 0.261416 6.971563 * IO : 1.683031 1.715576 0.032544 1.933664 * IONITA : 0.335121 0.339238 0.004117 1.228585 * IONO : 0.151664 0.153834 0.002170 1.430975 * IONO2 : 2.882999 2.925000 0.042001 1.456853 * IPRNO3 : 61.480019 61.855361 0.375342 0.610510 * ISALA : 0.944475 0.964079 0.019604 2.075633 * ISALC : 0.484305 0.517799 0.033494 6.915885 * ISOP : 126.519210 131.637671 5.118461 4.045600 * ISOPNOO1 : 0.002303 0.002456 0.000154 6.686976 * ISOPNOO2 : 0.001512 0.001621 0.000108 7.168796 * ITCN : 2.879964 3.072004 0.192040 6.668135 * ITHN : 7.965308 8.301201 0.335894 4.216956 * KO2 : 0.936198 0.913323 -0.022875 -2.443349 * LBRO2H : 0.185596 0.176450 -0.009147 -4.928274 * LBRO2N : 0.176864 0.179931 0.003067 1.734051 * LCH4 : 20.298649 20.757480 0.458830 2.260397 * LCO : 80.062951 80.926372 0.863421 1.078427 * LIMO : 1.230704 1.257347 0.026643 2.164872 * LIMO2 : 0.027174 0.027060 -0.000114 -0.419239 * LISOPNO3 : 0.799929 0.791417 -0.008513 -1.064192 * LISOPOH : 3.067965 3.290060 0.222095 7.239172 * LNRO2H : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan LNRO2N : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan LOx : 163.594516 166.696488 3.101972 1.896134 * LTRO2H : 0.080304 0.079780 -0.000524 -0.652773 * LTRO2N : 0.223871 0.229799 0.005927 2.647707 * LVOC : 0.080001 0.081797 0.001796 2.245113 * LVOCOA : 13.947385 14.778057 0.830672 5.955752 * LXRO2H : 0.043182 0.042956 -0.000226 -0.523481 * LXRO2N : 0.300469 0.308909 0.008441 2.809207 * MACR : 57.502053 59.649800 2.147746 3.735078 * MACR1OO : 0.039584 0.041909 0.002324 5.871928 * MACR1OOH : 4.420198 4.678921 0.258722 5.853187 * MACRNO2 : 0.000371 0.000381 0.000011 2.912326 * MAP : 436.054571 445.668503 9.613932 2.204754 * MCO3 : 1.239700 1.252084 0.012383 0.998881 * MCRDH : 9.279299 9.864708 0.585410 6.308773 * MCRENOL : 1.281710 1.326994 0.045284 3.533073 * MCRHN : 0.287337 0.306146 0.018809 6.546044 * MCRHNB : 0.881413 0.917374 0.035960 4.079832 * MCRHP : 8.196409 8.519513 0.323105 3.942027 * MCROHOO : 0.002965 0.003245 0.000281 9.464001 * MCT : 0.896514 0.903402 0.006888 0.768352 * MEK : 287.738280 285.536709 -2.201570 -0.765130 * MENO3 : 50.415350 50.823207 0.407857 0.808993 * MGLY : 37.347111 38.132918 0.785807 2.104062 * MO2 : 23.623170 23.667931 0.044761 0.189479 * MOH : 1872.634232 1897.092569 24.458338 1.306093 * MONITA : 0.081055 0.076872 -0.004184 -5.161636 * MONITS : 2.766059 2.813301 0.047242 1.707911 * MONITU : 0.367181 0.368984 0.001802 0.490885 * MP : 2158.625204 2156.124191 -2.501013 -0.115861 * MPAN : 6.582885 6.772995 0.190110 2.887937 * MPN : 71.164904 70.887874 -0.277030 -0.389280 * MSA : 42.423926 43.040676 0.616750 1.453779 * MTPA : 31.929488 32.701719 0.772231 2.418550 * MTPO : 0.966119 0.994678 0.028560 2.956122 * MVK : 122.476443 125.879343 3.402900 2.778412 * MVKDH : 49.048008 52.041859 2.993851 6.103919 * MVKHC : 13.045064 13.583247 0.538183 4.125565 * MVKHCB : 12.349677 12.940108 0.590430 4.780936 * MVKHP : 15.111088 15.758467 0.647378 4.284127 * MVKN : 1.507483 1.610171 0.102687 6.811842 * MVKOHOO : 0.507289 0.515254 0.007966 1.570231 * MVKPC : 4.706459 4.912497 0.206038 4.377778 * N : 1.34906125e-11 1.20863733e-11 -1.40423916e-12 -10.409010 * N2 : 3.13818296e+12 3.13971743e+12 1.53447608e+09 0.048897 * N2O : 2081727.459176 2083179.822367 1452.363191 0.069767 * N2O5 : 33.365221 34.722719 1.357498 4.068603 * NAP : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan NH3 : 190.620546 192.030076 1.409529 0.739443 * NH4 : 513.329945 529.103899 15.773953 3.072868 * NIT : 385.015089 440.299596 55.284507 14.359050 * NITs : 24.169400 26.820237 2.650837 10.967742 * NO : 53.818520 56.646416 2.827895 5.254502 * NO2 : 339.330243 345.678405 6.348162 1.870792 * NO3 : 13.726338 14.023217 0.296879 2.162841 * NPHEN : 1.037576 1.054109 0.016532 1.593373 * NPRNO3 : 14.574676 14.653811 0.079134 0.542959 * NRO2 : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan O : 0.001042 0.000997 -0.000046 -4.367566 * O1D : 3.02618114e-09 2.89211137e-09 -1.34069767e-10 -4.430329 * O2 : 9.61621866e+11 9.62092085e+11 4.70218954e+08 0.048899 * O3 : 318031.271890 311420.306343 -6610.965546 -2.078716 * OCPI : 306.308264 310.501358 4.193093 1.368913 * OCPO : 34.625859 34.676112 0.050253 0.145132 * OCS : 4290.506551 4294.753964 4.247413 0.098996 * OClO : 0.025399 0.024529 -0.000870 -3.426988 * OH : 0.203997 0.204993 0.000996 0.488243 * OIO : 0.136151 0.147951 0.011800 8.666792 * OLND : 0.716494 0.694276 -0.022218 -3.100903 * OLNN : 0.103597 0.100063 -0.003533 -3.410702 * OTHRO2 : 0.394742 0.391008 -0.003733 -0.945763 * PAN : 1786.926980 1868.124379 81.197399 4.543969 * PCO : 43.511006 44.731165 1.220159 2.804254 * PH2O2 : 30.320407 30.641987 0.321580 1.060607 * PHEN : 1.567610 1.538543 -0.029067 -1.854199 * PIO2 : 0.251447 0.249677 -0.001769 -0.703602 * PIP : 119.017510 121.142131 2.124621 1.785133 * PO2 : 0.204327 0.202474 -0.001853 -0.906903 * POx : 140.298299 144.314857 4.016559 2.862871 * PP : 24.430989 24.987318 0.556328 2.277142 * PPN : 371.857828 383.482101 11.624273 3.125999 * PRN1 : 0.391372 0.404367 0.012995 3.320476 * PROPNN : 10.323245 10.367445 0.044200 0.428160 * PRPE : 37.531878 37.620724 0.088846 0.236722 * PRPN : 1.271707 1.292568 0.020861 1.640393 * PSO4 : 4.350366 4.343248 -0.007118 -0.163626 * PYAC : 2.900940 2.973742 0.072803 2.509621 * R4N1 : 0.308071 0.306039 -0.002032 -0.659635 * R4N2 : 27.745526 27.541069 -0.204457 -0.736900 * R4O2 : 0.538593 0.543097 0.004505 0.836358 * R4P : 35.204654 34.488627 -0.716026 -2.033897 * RA3P : 15.987118 15.750701 -0.236417 -1.478798 * RB3P : 35.469190 35.059188 -0.410002 -1.155939 * RCHO : 58.581918 57.946860 -0.635058 -1.084051 * RCO3 : 0.183931 0.181689 -0.002243 -1.219373 * RCOOH : 1.06274699e-07 1.06326671e-07 5.19722298e-11 0.048904 * RIPA : 73.854848 77.908852 4.054005 5.489152 * RIPB : 13.934342 14.677660 0.743318 5.334432 * RIPC : 2.274700 2.399046 0.124346 5.466459 * RIPD : 0.893680 0.941372 0.047692 5.336535 * ROH : 3.423264 3.363773 -0.059491 -1.737831 * RP : 46.251492 45.787871 -0.463621 -1.002391 * SALA : 296.758847 292.140693 -4.618154 -1.556198 * SALAAL : 0.765820 0.783769 0.017948 2.343651 * SALACL : 35.769527 36.483210 0.713683 1.995225 * SALC : 2843.537161 2972.696856 129.159695 4.542219 * SALCAL : 69.043097 70.346259 1.303163 1.887463 * SALCCL : 1479.484944 1538.568869 59.083926 3.993547 * SO2 : 346.441077 362.761583 16.320507 4.710904 * SO4 : 1465.457422 1470.275547 4.818125 0.328780 * SO4s : 0.428243 0.447790 0.019547 4.564566 * SOAGX : 48.263789 49.813994 1.550205 3.211942 * SOAIE : 270.977601 248.676886 -22.300715 -8.229726 * SOAP : 140.915456 141.615097 0.699641 0.496497 * SOAS : 952.266779 979.010523 26.743744 2.808430 * TOLU : 39.077050 39.221273 0.144223 0.369073 * TRO2 : 0.046864 0.047363 0.000499 1.064735 * TSOA0 : 41.267458 41.856500 0.589042 1.427377 * TSOA1 : 13.033003 13.286645 0.253642 1.946153 * TSOA2 : 50.942686 52.511164 1.568478 3.078908 * TSOA3 : 16.159115 16.815367 0.656252 4.061190 * TSOG0 : 6.246523 6.398457 0.151934 2.432299 * TSOG1 : 9.376666 9.627450 0.250784 2.674558 * TSOG2 : 183.132558 188.844017 5.711459 3.118757 * TSOG3 : 390.016891 403.430755 13.413864 3.439303 * XRO2 : 0.033197 0.032879 -0.000318 -0.957872 * XYLE : 16.009044 15.904345 -0.104698 -0.653995 * pFe : 1.195316 1.199147 0.003831 0.320520 *