######################################################################################################### ### Global mass (Gg) at 01Oct2019 (Trop only) ### ### ### ### Ref = GCHP_14.0.0 ### ### Dev = GCHP_14.2.0 ### ### ### ### Dev and Ref show 318 differences ### ######################################################################################################### Ref Dev Dev - Ref % diff diffs A3O2 : 0.069993 0.063463 -0.006530 -9.329825 * ACET : 5635.803406 5795.823406 160.019999 2.839347 * ACTA : 400.706974 548.088408 147.381434 36.780352 * AERI : 6.606672 5.827979 -0.778693 -11.786465 * ALD2 : 309.638581 286.558194 -23.080387 -7.453977 * ALK4 : 580.717192 533.080356 -47.636837 -8.203104 * AONITA : 50.876764 82.361728 31.484964 61.884760 * AROMP4 : 0.094586 0.091397 -0.003189 -3.371739 * AROMP5 : 0.050550 0.048766 -0.001784 -3.529479 * AROMRO2 : 0.122958 0.088085 -0.034873 -28.361947 * ASOA1 : 8.073537 7.999841 -0.073696 -0.912804 * ASOA2 : 2.637164 2.763010 0.125847 4.772041 * ASOA3 : 4.893712 4.529630 -0.364082 -7.439789 * ASOAN : 64.117536 53.268125 -10.849411 -16.921129 * ASOG1 : 5.379404 5.123662 -0.255742 -4.754093 * ASOG2 : 7.464860 7.738100 0.273240 3.660355 * ASOG3 : 104.762836 98.819250 -5.943585 -5.673372 * ATO2 : 0.366084 0.395589 0.029505 8.059634 * ATOOH : 167.732196 161.675232 -6.056963 -3.611092 * B3O2 : 0.265486 0.223422 -0.042064 -15.844167 * BALD : 1.146580 1.007024 -0.139556 -12.171483 * BCPI : 112.627048 113.718326 1.091278 0.968931 * BCPO : 19.103091 19.167055 0.063964 0.334835 * BENZ : 283.614083 181.200209 -102.413873 -36.110292 * BENZO : 0.010381 0.008946 -0.001435 -13.824419 * BENZO2 : 0.476969 0.280004 -0.196965 -41.295155 * BENZP : 92.998454 77.716429 -15.282025 -16.432558 * BRO2 : 0.076902 0.054839 -0.022064 -28.690718 * BUTDI : nan 4319.965297 nan nan BZCO3 : 0.001324 0.001245 -0.000080 -6.027013 * BZCO3H : 0.547745 0.470865 -0.076880 -14.035772 * BZPAN : 1.780077 1.975939 0.195862 11.003014 * Br : 0.301695 0.620893 0.319197 105.801263 * Br2 : 2.024211 5.695811 3.671600 181.384237 * BrCl : 1.609628 4.674733 3.065105 190.423242 * BrNO2 : 0.111991 0.269248 0.157257 140.419501 * BrNO3 : 6.455430 14.493749 8.038320 124.520290 * BrO : 2.269194 5.652936 3.383743 149.116543 * BrSALA : 0.154814 0.423010 0.268196 173.237388 * BrSALC : 0.106860 4.728394 4.621534 4324.836008 * C2H2 : 203.798708 193.290833 -10.507875 -5.156007 * C2H4 : 141.797027 128.310611 -13.486416 -9.511071 * C2H6 : 2000.826339 1643.227044 -357.599295 -17.872580 * C3H8 : 388.428722 383.573025 -4.855697 -1.250087 * C4HVP1 : 0.000778 0.000661 -0.000117 -15.029651 * C4HVP2 : 0.001816 0.001547 -0.000269 -14.817889 * CCl4 : 1689.804022 1699.435855 9.631834 0.569997 * CFC11 : 4380.191884 4405.102754 24.910870 0.568716 * CFC113 : 1852.014964 1862.527162 10.512198 0.567609 * CFC114 : 385.898326 388.063059 2.164732 0.560959 * CFC115 : 188.339973 189.381845 1.041872 0.553187 * CFC12 : 8631.849622 8680.774984 48.925361 0.566800 * CH2Br2 : 17.973162 16.086843 -1.886319 -10.495198 * CH2Cl2 : 377.728718 375.780228 -1.948490 -0.515844 * CH2I2 : 0.046934 0.047019 0.000084 0.180002 * CH2IBr : 0.057368 0.057561 0.000193 0.336393 * CH2ICl : 0.226589 0.227706 0.001117 0.492908 * CH2O : 980.825343 1079.700915 98.875571 10.080854 * CH2OO : 0.000002 0.000002 -6.08713879e-08 -2.897400 * CH3Br : 88.899009 89.138518 0.239509 0.269417 * CH3CCl3 : 24.924610 25.049180 0.124570 0.499787 * CH3CHOO : 0.000014 0.000013 -1.03558124e-07 -0.764249 * CH3Cl : 3702.231697 3708.465317 6.233620 0.168375 * CH3I : 5.608831 5.628635 0.019804 0.353089 * CH4 : 4284490.833245 4306653.953206 22163.119961 0.517287 * CHBr3 : 21.258389 20.271253 -0.987136 -4.643512 * CHCl3 : 153.231631 152.529235 -0.702396 -0.458388 * CLOCK : 1.49792717e+18 1.68455456e+18 1.86627393e+17 12.459043 * CO : 351726.674534 344179.637335 -7547.037199 -2.145711 * CO2 : 133.947403 1.75487672e+09 1.75487659e+09 1.31012364e+09 * CSL : 0.339559 0.297707 -0.041852 -12.325448 * Cl : 0.000137 0.000208 0.000071 51.611456 * Cl2 : 0.717475 1.169177 0.451702 62.957199 * Cl2O2 : 0.000835 0.000432 -0.000403 -48.254562 * ClNO2 : 2.183921 2.825395 0.641474 29.372569 * ClNO3 : 2.506611 3.838261 1.331649 53.125492 * ClO : 0.422015 0.364425 -0.057590 -13.646539 * ClOO : 0.000015 0.000022 0.000007 48.567401 * DMS : 85.396645 73.282892 -12.113752 -14.185279 * DST1 : 1340.620655 1350.729612 10.108956 0.754050 * DST2 : 1039.186106 1044.748172 5.562066 0.535233 * DST3 : 1437.479008 1444.633724 7.154716 0.497727 * DST4 : 810.208429 813.439293 3.230864 0.398770 * EOH : 141.463823 134.165569 -7.298254 -5.159095 * ETHLN : 0.988800 1.086403 0.097603 9.870887 * ETHN : 3.335186 3.154822 -0.180365 -5.407939 * ETHP : 42.801641 38.073494 -4.728147 -11.046650 * ETNO3 : 24.564952 24.233808 -0.331144 -1.348034 * ETO : 1.74618225e-08 7.04068271e-09 -1.04211398e-08 -59.679565 * ETO2 : 0.219630 0.188678 -0.030951 -14.092543 * ETOO : 0.237116 0.221602 -0.015514 -6.542759 * ETP : 74.117277 60.220960 -13.896317 -18.749093 * FURA : nan 9.243978 nan nan GLYC : 192.122806 139.841933 -52.280873 -27.212216 * GLYX : 8.194039 9.990197 1.796158 21.920307 * H : 2.83788277e-10 3.16356489e-10 3.25682122e-11 11.476236 * H1211 : 75.659089 76.095622 0.436534 0.576975 * H1301 : 71.072577 71.475218 0.402640 0.566520 * H2 : 144552.630627 145352.102696 799.472069 0.553066 * H2402 : 14.445001 14.528039 0.083037 0.574852 * H2O : 1.32065991e+10 1.32092479e+10 2648772.581921 0.020056 * H2O2 : 3164.024603 3220.253524 56.228921 1.777133 * HAC : 168.495648 160.513370 -7.982278 -4.737379 * HBr : 4.487512 8.191243 3.703731 82.534168 * HC5A : 4.225132 4.015354 -0.209778 -4.965005 * HCFC123 : 2.43769902e-23 4.71578202e-23 2.27808300e-23 nan * HCFC141b : 432.249131 434.450160 2.201028 0.509204 * HCFC142b : 325.938718 327.662741 1.724023 0.528941 * HCFC22 : 3077.466416 3093.109163 15.642748 0.508300 * HCOOH : 661.395344 588.893504 -72.501840 -10.961952 * HCl : 230.976121 282.941131 51.965010 22.498001 * HI : 0.420166 0.372374 -0.047792 -11.374571 * HMHP : 47.134560 46.492222 -0.642338 -1.362776 * HMML : 17.536502 17.767225 0.230723 1.315673 * HMS : 88.925333 84.789233 -4.136099 -4.651205 * HNO2 : 3.091652 4.465871 1.374220 44.449364 * HNO3 : 1593.229414 1635.217098 41.987684 2.635382 * HNO4 : 75.916594 97.326496 21.409902 28.201874 * HO2 : 25.180040 25.675753 0.495713 1.968673 * HOBr : 4.217188 8.570095 4.352907 103.218224 * HOCl : 3.349835 5.538048 2.188212 65.322980 * HOI : 10.642579 11.805590 1.163012 10.927911 * HONIT : 4.375281 4.551306 0.176025 4.023160 * HPALD1 : 2.142711 2.027771 -0.114940 -5.364224 * HPALD1OO : 0.004490 0.004372 -0.000119 -2.640193 * HPALD2 : 6.217118 5.941948 -0.275170 -4.426005 * HPALD2OO : 0.013129 0.012797 -0.000332 -2.524992 * HPALD3 : 1.970064 1.828997 -0.141067 -7.160526 * HPALD4 : 4.699946 4.365110 -0.334836 -7.124258 * HPETHNL : 3.853502 3.664035 -0.189467 -4.916755 * I : 1.049523 1.025400 -0.024123 -2.298471 * I2 : 0.033822 0.035902 0.002080 6.149137 * I2O2 : 0.029956 0.025977 -0.003979 -13.283361 * I2O3 : 0.122953 0.072638 -0.050316 -40.922656 * I2O4 : 0.002407 0.002690 0.000283 11.742326 * IBr : 0.158183 0.106245 -0.051938 -32.833952 * ICHE : 15.238998 14.591817 -0.647181 -4.246875 * ICHOO : 0.000567 0.000528 -0.000040 -6.966272 * ICN : 11.231310 11.666529 0.435219 3.875049 * ICNOO : 0.050628 0.054037 0.003408 6.731712 * ICPDH : 4.467590 4.351775 -0.115815 -2.592344 * ICl : 1.165258 0.780144 -0.385114 -33.049666 * IDC : 5.257488 4.918877 -0.338611 -6.440546 * IDCHP : 3.017098 3.021117 0.004020 0.133228 * IDHDP : 10.258504 9.923757 -0.334747 -3.263115 * IDHNBOO : 1.445644 1.306926 -0.138718 -9.595554 * IDHNDOO1 : 0.002602 0.002623 0.000021 0.801241 * IDHNDOO2 : 0.001106 0.001085 -0.000021 -1.884073 * IDHPE : 45.417020 43.642239 -1.774781 -3.907745 * IDN : 2.090976 2.194974 0.103997 4.973631 * IDNOO : 0.001488 0.001558 0.000070 4.723414 * IEPOXA : 101.774393 96.731809 -5.042583 -4.954668 * IEPOXAOO : 0.003729 0.003635 -0.000094 -2.522109 * IEPOXB : 59.904227 56.964917 -2.939310 -4.906682 * IEPOXBOO : 0.001489 0.001451 -0.000038 -2.542024 * IEPOXD : 5.652424 5.409943 -0.242481 -4.289857 * IHN1 : 1.856776 1.840339 -0.016437 -0.885261 * IHN2 : 1.681612 1.601681 -0.079931 -4.753217 * IHN3 : 1.466703 1.410479 -0.056225 -3.833400 * IHN4 : 0.402596 0.395144 -0.007452 -1.850930 * IHOO1 : 0.457733 0.423544 -0.034189 -7.469218 * IHOO4 : 0.089381 0.082951 -0.006430 -7.193424 * IHPNBOO : 0.002165 0.002277 0.000112 5.193539 * IHPNDOO : 0.006754 0.006821 0.000067 0.989337 * IHPOO1 : 0.005208 0.004569 -0.000639 -12.268475 * IHPOO2 : 0.001215 0.001064 -0.000151 -12.415429 * IHPOO3 : 0.008166 0.007163 -0.001004 -12.291346 * INA : 2.26594212e-09 2.36724645e-09 1.01304328e-10 4.470738 * INDIOL : 674.477452 709.850815 35.373363 5.244558 * INO : 0.004282 0.004825 0.000543 12.672732 * INO2B : 1.245470 1.203959 -0.041510 -3.332909 * INO2D : 0.972418 0.945520 -0.026897 -2.766015 * INPB : 3.963598 4.100092 0.136493 3.443676 * INPD : 4.166917 4.379125 0.212207 5.092673 * IO : 2.015346 1.982390 -0.032956 -1.635274 * IONITA : 0.447703 0.477768 0.030065 6.715317 * IONO : 0.277524 0.356238 0.078714 28.363008 * IONO2 : 3.072046 3.819598 0.747552 24.334005 * IPRNO3 : 39.432399 45.716832 6.284434 15.937234 * ISALA : 1.290349 1.144077 -0.146272 -11.335842 * ISALC : 0.579672 0.596038 0.016366 2.823282 * ISOP : 123.875066 111.460299 -12.414767 -10.022007 * ISOPNOO1 : 0.002704 0.002668 -0.000036 -1.343090 * ISOPNOO2 : 0.001975 0.001929 -0.000047 -2.365936 * ITCN : 3.149551 3.320114 0.170563 5.415455 * ITHN : 9.749321 10.220501 0.471180 4.832951 * KO2 : 1.111940 1.035257 -0.076683 -6.896345 * LBRO2H : 0.162235 0.104907 -0.057328 -35.336285 * LBRO2N : 0.163415 0.124651 -0.038764 -23.720984 * LCH4 : 19.704247 22.754670 3.050423 15.481043 * LCO : 81.218354 90.122166 8.903812 10.962808 * LIMO : 1.243402 1.120400 -0.123001 -9.892321 * LIMO2 : 0.026268 0.024796 -0.001472 -5.604220 * LISOPNO3 : 1.392049 1.490177 0.098128 7.049163 * LISOPOH : 3.453555 3.312528 -0.141027 -4.083528 * LNRO2H : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan LNRO2N : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan LOx : 162.150317 188.603631 26.453314 16.314069 * LTRO2H : 0.061185 0.052540 -0.008645 -14.128672 * LTRO2N : 0.201314 0.176083 -0.025232 -12.533421 * LVOC : 0.084530 0.078074 -0.006456 -7.637483 * LVOCOA : 17.453014 17.375850 -0.077163 -0.442121 * LXRO2H : 0.038724 0.043886 0.005162 13.331535 * LXRO2N : 0.260697 0.279566 0.018869 7.237929 * MACR : 72.491973 69.359057 -3.132917 -4.321743 * MACR1OO : 0.044487 0.041699 -0.002788 -6.266902 * MACR1OOH : 5.495414 5.217394 -0.278020 -5.059133 * MACRNO2 : 0.000476 0.000483 0.000007 1.436154 * MAP : 490.935110 470.301966 -20.633144 -4.202825 * MCO3 : 1.240568 1.267596 0.027028 2.178667 * MCRDH : 11.349134 10.927228 -0.421906 -3.717513 * MCRENOL : 1.487894 1.418262 -0.069632 -4.679891 * MCRHN : 0.330575 0.326818 -0.003757 -1.136420 * MCRHNB : 1.128215 1.220112 0.091896 8.145284 * MCRHP : 9.344005 9.329281 -0.014724 -0.157581 * MCROHOO : 0.003864 0.003804 -0.000061 -1.570367 * MCT : 1.053734 0.762537 -0.291196 -27.634727 * MEK : 325.708838 317.198327 -8.510512 -2.612920 * MENO3 : 55.311929 61.496462 6.184533 11.181192 * MGLY : 40.549288 44.333929 3.784641 9.333433 * MO2 : 25.627688 23.265366 -2.362322 -9.217849 * MOH : 2419.155144 2187.521280 -231.633864 -9.574990 * MONITA : 0.100356 0.106036 0.005680 5.659899 * MONITS : 3.228685 3.276512 0.047827 1.481326 * MONITU : 0.410012 0.411383 0.001371 0.334498 * MP : 2408.595376 2146.455883 -262.139493 -10.883501 * MPAN : 9.302422 9.662184 0.359762 3.867402 * MPN : 66.310883 79.636393 13.325511 20.095511 * MSA : 32.300856 29.270167 -3.030689 -9.382690 * MTPA : 30.999122 27.999417 -2.999704 -9.676740 * MTPO : 0.920774 0.859272 -0.061502 -6.679382 * MVK : 148.917900 144.875357 -4.042542 -2.714612 * MVKDH : 59.474355 57.005422 -2.468934 -4.151258 * MVKHC : 14.285974 14.689176 0.403202 2.822365 * MVKHCB : 14.555522 14.375041 -0.180481 -1.239949 * MVKHP : 17.828514 17.018587 -0.809928 -4.542878 * MVKN : 1.852941 1.908511 0.055569 2.998988 * MVKOHOO : 0.596356 0.582394 -0.013962 -2.341275 * MVKPC : 5.675752 5.479221 -0.196531 -3.462641 * N : 1.12721512e-11 1.61241976e-11 4.85204640e-12 43.044547 * N2 : 3.13121258e+12 3.14853026e+12 1.73176848e+10 0.553066 * N2O : 2079975.901183 2091687.702033 11711.800850 0.563074 * N2O5 : 39.681065 45.674056 5.992990 15.102897 * NAP : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan NH3 : 285.349795 281.427010 -3.922786 -1.374729 * NH4 : 563.195418 581.983922 18.788503 3.336054 * NIT : 590.029505 578.320703 -11.708802 -1.984444 * NITs : 54.851106 24.631731 -30.219376 -55.093466 * NO : 48.809170 60.454415 11.645245 23.858724 * NO2 : 355.506466 410.824580 55.318115 15.560368 * NO3 : 19.702264 20.361784 0.659520 3.347432 * NPHEN : 1.436944 1.277068 -0.159876 -11.126132 * NPRNO3 : 9.492598 10.854583 1.361985 14.347868 * NRO2 : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan O : 0.000985 0.001082 0.000097 9.865351 * O1D : 2.95850878e-09 3.23494514e-09 2.76436358e-10 9.343773 * O2 : 9.59485973e+11 9.64792568e+11 5.30659469e+09 0.553066 * O3 : 319568.757474 344003.867721 24435.110247 7.646276 * OCPI : 552.621868 554.829578 2.207710 0.399497 * OCPO : 63.693722 63.621973 -0.071749 -0.112647 * OCS : 4284.199676 4307.526712 23.327036 0.544490 * OClO : 0.069777 0.059618 -0.010159 -14.559147 * OH : 0.191624 0.222122 0.030498 15.915715 * OIO : 0.145128 0.156937 0.011809 8.136995 * OLND : 0.861200 0.865228 0.004028 0.467738 * OLNN : 0.123136 0.124270 0.001134 0.920876 * OTHRO2 : 0.394577 0.317943 -0.076634 -19.421752 * PAN : 1628.895938 1944.947106 316.051168 19.402784 * PCO : 44.315706 50.047884 5.732178 12.934867 * PH2O2 : 31.290815 33.768648 2.477833 7.918724 * PHEN : 1.346621 1.786888 0.440267 32.694238 * PIO2 : 0.233865 0.221286 -0.012579 -5.378751 * PIP : 126.302494 120.538059 -5.764435 -4.563992 * PO2 : 0.210958 0.208820 -0.002138 -1.013294 * POx : 132.971977 166.023047 33.051069 24.855665 * PP : 28.116613 25.829268 -2.287345 -8.135209 * PPN : 256.655590 320.449401 63.793811 24.855804 * PRN1 : 0.787445 0.628871 -0.158574 -20.137818 * PROPNN : 15.474505 16.987139 1.512633 9.775003 * PRPE : 52.706966 48.299199 -4.407768 -8.362780 * PRPN : 2.242625 2.263188 0.020563 0.916925 * PSO4 : 3.716898 3.705489 -0.011409 -0.306950 * PYAC : 3.390902 3.461196 0.070294 2.073022 * R4N1 : 0.416495 0.407898 -0.008597 -2.064218 * R4N2 : 25.112565 24.912891 -0.199673 -0.795114 * R4O2 : 0.379336 0.339421 -0.039916 -10.522457 * R4P : 30.372576 25.155041 -5.217535 -17.178441 * RA3P : 14.512543 13.187910 -1.324633 -9.127505 * RB3P : 32.650680 29.203956 -3.446724 -10.556363 * RCHO : 59.571655 71.732019 12.160364 20.413004 * RCO3 : 0.165200 0.180932 0.015732 9.522782 * RCOOH : 1.06038654e-07 1.06625118e-07 5.86464174e-10 0.553066 * RIPA : 77.275129 71.484074 -5.791055 -7.494074 * RIPB : 14.753934 13.702256 -1.051679 -7.128123 * RIPC : 2.307544 2.129941 -0.177603 -7.696633 * RIPD : 0.943062 0.878259 -0.064803 -6.871580 * ROH : 3.908517 3.639255 -0.269263 -6.889126 * RP : 50.315241 49.263942 -1.051299 -2.089425 * SALA : 315.728082 312.764383 -2.963699 -0.938687 * SALAAL : 0.913569 0.913161 -0.000408 -0.044655 * SALACL : 71.313068 72.263586 0.950518 1.332881 * SALC : 2987.458220 2987.700943 0.242722 0.008125 * SALCAL : 55.692557 108.168523 52.475966 94.224379 * SALCCL : 1547.862916 1536.976078 -10.886838 -0.703346 * SO2 : 306.782906 311.010414 4.227508 1.378013 * SO4 : 1386.906375 1448.620693 61.714318 4.449783 * SO4s : 0.053145 0.408363 0.355219 668.401186 * SOAGX : 55.788891 70.353938 14.565047 26.107433 * SOAIE : 166.063079 163.841825 -2.221254 -1.337596 * SOAP : 162.775690 167.768517 4.992827 3.067305 * SOAS : 1107.747660 1139.137562 31.389902 2.833669 * TOLU : 50.339735 39.434229 -10.905506 -21.663812 * TRO2 : 0.047536 0.042018 -0.005518 -11.607456 * TSOA0 : 58.804762 57.009858 -1.794904 -3.052310 * TSOA1 : 20.458815 19.556177 -0.902638 -4.411974 * TSOA2 : 109.169738 107.866695 -1.303043 -1.193594 * TSOA3 : 41.741153 41.477526 -0.263627 -0.631576 * TSOG0 : 4.859310 4.758138 -0.101172 -2.082022 * TSOG1 : 9.324859 8.957335 -0.367525 -3.941343 * TSOG2 : 230.691003 228.508231 -2.182772 -0.946189 * TSOG3 : 554.063957 553.089698 -0.974258 -0.175839 * XRO2 : 0.033807 0.035981 0.002174 6.430619 * XYLE : 16.620603 16.529954 -0.090649 -0.545402 * pFe : 1.169646 1.189679 0.020033 1.712765 *