######################################################################################################### ### Global mass (Gg) at end of simulation (Trop + Strat) ### ### ### ### Ref = Fast-JX in 14.3.0 ### ### Dev = Cloud-J in 14.3.0 ### ### ### ### Dev and Ref show 314 differences ### ######################################################################################################### Ref Dev Dev - Ref % diff diffs A3O2 : 0.085747 0.086980 0.001233 1.437626 * ACET : 6089.424242 6128.497254 39.073012 0.641654 * ACTA : 559.698032 561.201985 1.503953 0.268708 * AERI : 5.618574 5.592994 -0.025581 -0.455286 * ALD2 : 291.908602 296.303073 4.394471 1.505427 * ALK4 : 430.944825 440.932348 9.987524 2.317588 * AONITA : 78.104091 78.308222 0.204131 0.261358 * AROMP4 : 0.136538 0.136574 0.000037 0.026750 * AROMP5 : 0.086103 0.085317 -0.000786 -0.913144 * AROMRO2 : 0.088097 0.089290 0.001193 1.354697 * ASOA1 : 7.834639 7.874157 0.039519 0.504409 * ASOA2 : 2.610587 2.620834 0.010246 0.392495 * ASOA3 : 6.650505 6.686532 0.036027 0.541724 * ASOAN : 53.749818 53.926249 0.176431 0.328245 * ASOG1 : 5.703376 5.747236 0.043860 0.769020 * ASOG2 : 6.875443 6.932771 0.057328 0.833806 * ASOG3 : 112.767098 113.585460 0.818363 0.725711 * ATO2 : 0.514756 0.516462 0.001706 0.331415 * ATOOH : 173.327729 174.736436 1.408708 0.812742 * B3O2 : 0.311918 0.316667 0.004749 1.522431 * BALD : 0.881095 0.899146 0.018051 2.048670 * BCPI : 101.190734 101.190734 1.00499165e-10 9.93165681e-11 * BCPO : 20.406666 20.406666 -3.19744231e-14 -1.56686169e-13 * BENZ : 177.712499 180.165784 2.453285 1.380480 * BENZO : 0.009487 0.009592 0.000105 1.107861 * BENZO2 : 0.261874 0.264774 0.002900 1.107503 * BENZP : 79.289451 79.757540 0.468089 0.590355 * BRO2 : 0.068133 0.069053 0.000920 1.349965 * BUTDI : 3526.168951 3525.060731 -1.108220 -0.031428 * BZCO3 : 0.001290 0.001308 0.000019 1.447438 * BZCO3H : 0.485919 0.489994 0.004075 0.838594 * BZPAN : 1.293356 1.318283 0.024927 1.927291 * Br : 1.173899 1.186206 0.012307 1.048408 * Br2 : 11.462984 11.598028 0.135044 1.178090 * BrCl : 11.328740 11.353271 0.024531 0.216538 * BrNO2 : 0.334206 0.339565 0.005359 1.603480 * BrNO3 : 27.294303 27.366694 0.072391 0.265225 * BrO : 13.742787 13.832478 0.089691 0.652641 * BrSALA : 0.372974 0.377462 0.004488 1.203232 * BrSALC : 5.216391 5.192663 -0.023728 -0.454868 * C2H2 : 182.333604 184.327651 1.994047 1.093625 * C2H4 : 163.155390 166.196037 3.040647 1.863651 * C2H6 : 1363.961376 1371.932867 7.971491 0.584437 * C3H8 : 299.837338 304.411163 4.573824 1.525435 * C4HVP1 : 0.000957 0.000978 0.000021 2.229672 * C4HVP2 : 0.002210 0.002252 0.000042 1.886891 * CCl4 : 1956.913232 1956.856819 -0.056413 -0.002883 * CFC11 : 5094.441518 5094.325496 -0.116022 -0.002277 * CFC113 : 2190.091733 2190.064259 -0.027474 -0.001254 * CFC114 : 467.191384 467.188115 -0.003269 -0.000700 * CFC115 : 231.247867 231.247725 -0.000142 -0.000062 * CFC12 : 10274.494233 10274.305278 -0.188955 -0.001839 * CH2Br2 : 18.033131 18.072730 0.039599 0.219590 * CH2Cl2 : 450.791593 450.920130 0.128537 0.028514 * CH2I2 : 0.048476 0.048644 0.000168 0.346363 * CH2IBr : 0.063052 0.063805 0.000752 1.193446 * CH2ICl : 0.297816 0.304103 0.006286 2.110836 * CH2O : 1129.072060 1127.451772 -1.620288 -0.143506 * CH2OO : 0.000002 0.000002 4.43376678e-08 2.245797 * CH3Br : 100.776104 100.781495 0.005391 0.005350 * CH3CCl3 : 30.093962 30.093876 -0.000086 -0.000285 * CH3CHOO : 0.000015 0.000015 2.08702449e-07 1.427758 * CH3Cl : 4386.006878 4386.368607 0.361728 0.008247 * CH3I : 5.607530 5.673634 0.066104 1.178841 * CH4 : 5138679.988034 5138748.288882 68.300848 0.001329 * CHBr3 : 23.089352 23.305065 0.215712 0.934251 * CHCl3 : 166.185929 166.230087 0.044158 0.026572 * CLOCK : 6.21176515e+19 6.21176515e+19 12582912.000000 2.02565804e-11 * CO : 320193.214199 320606.664739 413.450541 0.129125 * CO2 : 2.15301610e+09 2.15301610e+09 -0.698952 -3.24638409e-08 * CSL : 0.530489 0.536948 0.006460 1.217702 * Cl : 0.264275 0.265267 0.000991 0.375168 * Cl2 : 4.286794 4.066088 -0.220706 -5.148500 * Cl2O2 : 42.997559 42.636421 -0.361138 -0.839904 * ClNO2 : 1.954491 1.975479 0.020988 1.073830 * ClNO3 : 673.212502 668.954440 -4.258062 -0.632499 * ClO : 51.784779 52.376567 0.591788 1.142784 * ClOO : 0.000417 0.000425 0.000008 1.822188 * DMS : 188.964263 191.196654 2.232391 1.181383 * DST1 : 2397.325825 2397.325825 4.54747351e-13 1.89689422e-14 * DST2 : 1516.316073 1516.316073 -1.45519152e-11 -9.59688780e-13 * DST3 : 2102.938911 2102.938911 -1.63709046e-11 -7.78477423e-13 * DST4 : 1100.467183 1100.467183 -2.27373675e-13 -2.06615589e-14 * EOH : 138.750715 140.704954 1.954240 1.408454 * ETHLN : 0.992720 1.010250 0.017530 1.765838 * ETHN : 3.434942 3.463332 0.028390 0.826508 * ETHP : 47.079748 47.723547 0.643799 1.367465 * ETNO3 : 24.967779 25.078921 0.111143 0.445144 * ETO : 1.40816423e-08 1.42238330e-08 1.42190723e-10 1.009760 * ETO2 : 0.228756 0.230138 0.001382 0.604267 * ETOO : 0.322213 0.327007 0.004794 1.487822 * ETP : 60.649361 61.208735 0.559374 0.922308 * FURA : 10.765421 10.875474 0.110053 1.022286 * GLYC : 149.502381 151.096376 1.593996 1.066201 * GLYX : 10.196830 10.246181 0.049351 0.483984 * H : 0.000372 0.000375 0.000003 0.823131 * H1211 : 87.047449 87.043632 -0.003818 -0.004386 * H1301 : 83.151309 83.150238 -0.001070 -0.001287 * H2 : 178186.611531 178186.611531 0.000000 0.000000 H2402 : 16.537613 16.536859 -0.000755 -0.004562 * H2O : 1.42865629e+10 1.42865629e+10 66.987791 4.68886685e-07 * H2O2 : 3017.368242 2996.440085 -20.928157 -0.693590 * HAC : 160.600875 161.678360 1.077485 0.670908 * HBr : 9.296646 9.376603 0.079957 0.860062 * HC5A : 3.989841 4.052789 0.062948 1.577705 * HCFC123 : 5.81038309e-20 5.80727824e-20 -3.10484970e-23 nan * HCFC141b : 505.184422 505.185140 0.000718 0.000142 * HCFC142b : 393.607432 393.609348 0.001916 0.000487 * HCFC22 : 3707.510384 3707.549212 0.038827 0.001047 * HCOOH : 499.373873 504.000007 4.626134 0.926387 * HCl : 891.917389 893.819264 1.901875 0.213234 * HI : 0.321128 0.323060 0.001931 0.601424 * HMHP : 48.779054 50.148245 1.369191 2.806925 * HMML : 16.497824 16.759141 0.261317 1.583950 * HMS : 90.669771 90.986919 0.317149 0.349784 * HNO2 : 4.824583 4.850883 0.026300 0.545123 * HNO3 : 5867.316527 5859.763927 -7.552600 -0.128723 * HNO4 : 199.562522 198.177483 -1.385039 -0.694037 * HO2 : 32.931553 32.850554 -0.080999 -0.245961 * HOBr : 12.133924 12.183311 0.049387 0.407016 * HOCl : 40.695071 40.304091 -0.390980 -0.960755 * HOI : 10.741612 10.798234 0.056621 0.527119 * HONIT : 5.849724 5.857086 0.007362 0.125852 * HPALD1 : 1.860263 1.907908 0.047644 2.561169 * HPALD1OO : 0.003841 0.003924 0.000083 2.152952 * HPALD2 : 5.869067 6.007146 0.138080 2.352666 * HPALD2OO : 0.012095 0.012325 0.000230 1.902499 * HPALD3 : 1.691754 1.731150 0.039396 2.328692 * HPALD4 : 4.458956 4.561642 0.102685 2.302903 * HPETHNL : 3.322378 3.379976 0.057598 1.733625 * I : 1.127284 1.137461 0.010177 0.902778 * I2 : 0.037599 0.038104 0.000505 1.342872 * I2O2 : 0.043606 0.044422 0.000816 1.871058 * I2O3 : 0.095514 0.097961 0.002447 2.561524 * I2O4 : 0.008654 0.009064 0.000410 4.739198 * IBr : 0.117318 0.117367 0.000050 0.042531 * ICHE : 13.728610 13.757379 0.028769 0.209555 * ICHOO : 0.000438 0.000437 -0.000001 -0.272439 * ICN : 10.088791 10.346792 0.258001 2.557305 * ICNOO : 0.053471 0.054936 0.001465 2.739190 * ICPDH : 4.141982 4.127320 -0.014662 -0.353995 * ICl : 0.931499 0.936654 0.005155 0.553421 * IDC : 5.059390 5.157344 0.097954 1.936093 * IDCHP : 2.736390 2.704412 -0.031977 -1.168595 * IDHDP : 9.954439 9.903936 -0.050503 -0.507341 * IDHNBOO : 0.859660 0.872026 0.012366 1.438505 * IDHNDOO1 : 0.002224 0.002278 0.000055 2.451757 * IDHNDOO2 : 0.001151 0.001169 0.000018 1.561057 * IDHPE : 40.390230 40.171863 -0.218366 -0.540642 * IDN : 2.571141 2.664381 0.093240 3.626409 * IDNOO : 0.001804 0.001872 0.000068 3.775331 * IEPOXA : 95.323171 95.408649 0.085478 0.089672 * IEPOXAOO : 0.002355 0.002333 -0.000022 -0.923367 * IEPOXB : 55.180509 55.165456 -0.015053 -0.027280 * IEPOXBOO : 0.000933 0.000924 -0.000009 -0.951795 * IEPOXD : 5.096189 5.090172 -0.006017 -0.118064 * IHN1 : 1.493953 1.527372 0.033420 2.236986 * IHN2 : 1.830430 1.848746 0.018316 1.000660 * IHN3 : 1.948499 1.973017 0.024517 1.258256 * IHN4 : 0.365604 0.372951 0.007347 2.009479 * IHOO1 : 0.522836 0.533570 0.010734 2.052947 * IHOO4 : 0.114743 0.116634 0.001892 1.648550 * IHPNBOO : 0.001585 0.001629 0.000044 2.776268 * IHPNDOO : 0.006816 0.007070 0.000255 3.737802 * IHPOO1 : 0.005207 0.005233 0.000026 0.500192 * IHPOO2 : 0.001208 0.001216 0.000008 0.664802 * IHPOO3 : 0.007871 0.007911 0.000040 0.510787 * INA : 1.85386902e-09 1.91433907e-09 6.04700451e-11 3.261829 * INDIOL : 608.937330 613.996661 5.059331 0.830846 * INO : 0.004510 0.004573 0.000063 1.399929 * INO2B : 0.859943 0.877131 0.017188 1.998771 * INO2D : 0.690869 0.705187 0.014318 2.072413 * INPB : 3.504824 3.613173 0.108349 3.091426 * INPD : 4.212895 4.366630 0.153735 3.649154 * IO : 2.369079 2.372758 0.003678 0.155267 * IONITA : 0.444261 0.449265 0.005004 1.126421 * IONO : 0.436514 0.438337 0.001823 0.417612 * IONO2 : 4.634881 4.642668 0.007787 0.168011 * IPRNO3 : 38.779506 39.267038 0.487532 1.257189 * ISALA : 0.890107 0.883298 -0.006809 -0.764965 * ISALC : 0.497839 0.496206 -0.001633 -0.328057 * ISOP : 133.760187 137.033089 3.272902 2.446843 * ISOPNOO1 : 0.002056 0.002050 -0.000006 -0.295331 * ISOPNOO2 : 0.002034 0.002031 -0.000003 -0.152905 * ITCN : 3.497512 3.518282 0.020770 0.593864 * ITHN : 9.539379 9.701761 0.162382 1.702231 * KO2 : 0.989025 0.997504 0.008479 0.857326 * LBRO2H : 0.185127 0.186522 0.001396 0.753916 * LBRO2N : 0.215779 0.215501 -0.000278 -0.128794 * LCH4 : 25.370958 25.181469 -0.189488 -0.746871 * LCO : 95.197583 94.781451 -0.416133 -0.437125 * LIMO : 1.309105 1.318903 0.009798 0.748444 * LIMO2 : 0.028939 0.029011 0.000072 0.249568 * LISOPNO3 : 1.085887 1.115476 0.029589 2.724881 * LISOPOH : 4.207146 4.193974 -0.013172 -0.313079 * LNRO2H : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan LNRO2N : 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 nan LOx : 3951.850883 3995.376924 43.526041 1.101409 * LTRO2H : 0.126788 0.128090 0.001302 1.026916 * LTRO2N : 0.315204 0.313433 -0.001770 -0.561640 * LVOC : 0.054480 0.054576 0.000096 0.176558 * LVOCOA : 15.919395 15.760082 -0.159313 -1.000750 * LXRO2H : 0.091612 0.090761 -0.000851 -0.929353 * LXRO2N : 0.461476 0.452426 -0.009050 -1.961180 * MACR : 72.892146 74.703539 1.811393 2.485031 * MACR1OO : 0.043472 0.044328 0.000856 1.968698 * MACR1OOH : 5.383528 5.450783 0.067255 1.249268 * MACRNO2 : 0.000405 0.000408 0.000003 0.779800 * MAP : 466.392304 466.790927 0.398622 0.085469 * MCO3 : 1.414256 1.424311 0.010054 0.710938 * MCRDH : 10.516210 10.476178 -0.040032 -0.380667 * MCRENOL : 1.526415 1.561181 0.034767 2.277664 * MCRHN : 0.404143 0.411356 0.007213 1.784880 * MCRHNB : 1.179786 1.211146 0.031361 2.658161 * MCRHP : 8.952136 8.957250 0.005113 0.057118 * MCROHOO : 0.003488 0.003546 0.000058 1.650197 * MCT : 1.396495 1.397879 0.001385 0.099143 * MEK : 344.540326 348.778367 4.238042 1.230057 * MENO3 : 69.927153 70.002871 0.075719 0.108282 * MGLY : 42.243840 42.985710 0.741870 1.756162 * MO2 : 26.633405 26.599976 -0.033429 -0.125515 * MOH : 2322.745461 2329.370332 6.624870 0.285217 * MONITA : 0.122217 0.122263 0.000046 0.037676 * MONITS : 3.679049 3.691630 0.012581 0.341953 * MONITU : 0.477535 0.477573 0.000038 0.007888 * MP : 2253.241879 2247.218982 -6.022897 -0.267299 * MPAN : 9.755258 10.033170 0.277912 2.848841 * MPN : 268.407662 268.031790 -0.375872 -0.140038 * MSA : 42.085704 42.278670 0.192966 0.458507 * MTPA : 32.689249 33.001464 0.312215 0.955098 * MTPO : 0.994264 0.995916 0.001652 0.166142 * MVK : 146.606119 149.379543 2.773425 1.891752 * MVKDH : 53.516422 53.206530 -0.309893 -0.579061 * MVKHC : 14.144332 14.254065 0.109733 0.775812 * MVKHCB : 13.525880 13.478823 -0.047057 -0.347905 * MVKHP : 16.917156 17.114094 0.196938 1.164131 * MVKN : 2.306706 2.330405 0.023700 1.027426 * MVKOHOO : 0.550097 0.558647 0.008551 1.554409 * MVKPC : 5.362119 5.411358 0.049239 0.918279 * N : 0.000113 0.000114 0.000001 0.917833 * N2 : 3.85977185e+12 3.85977185e+12 0.000000 0.000000 N2O : 2479554.619670 2479518.916520 -35.703150 -0.001440 * N2O5 : 504.693593 505.026903 0.333310 0.066042 * NAP : 1.80719463e-20 1.80719463e-20 0.000000 nan NH3 : 208.755738 208.978957 0.223219 0.106928 * NH4 : 409.539800 408.894558 -0.645241 -0.157553 * NIT : 313.092231 311.737004 -1.355227 -0.432852 * NITs : 27.485019 27.569736 0.084717 0.308231 * NO : 555.625343 559.783837 4.158494 0.748435 * NO2 : 1780.889224 1786.625926 5.736702 0.322126 * NO3 : 26.477344 26.600130 0.122787 0.463742 * NPHEN : 1.108864 1.123888 0.015024 1.354909 * NPRNO3 : 9.029947 9.092258 0.062311 0.690047 * NRO2 : 2.24411907e-20 2.24411907e-20 0.000000 nan O : 148.432953 149.718537 1.285584 0.866104 * O1D : 0.000025 0.000026 2.90539801e-07 1.141802 * O2 : 1.18273570e+12 1.18273570e+12 0.000000 0.000000 O3 : 3219957.795268 3223163.704206 3205.908938 0.099564 * OCPI : 697.680729 697.680729 -2.40106601e-10 -3.44149682e-11 * OCPO : 86.614547 86.614547 -3.55271368e-13 -4.10175171e-13 * OCS : 5010.123550 5010.053109 -0.070440 -0.001406 * OClO : 6.461555 6.808494 0.346939 5.369278 * OH : 2.334384 2.353763 0.019379 0.830164 * OIO : 0.451084 0.463354 0.012270 2.720062 * OLND : 0.696818 0.697796 0.000977 0.140225 * OLNN : 0.100131 0.100175 0.000044 0.044035 * OTHRO2 : 0.423056 0.428971 0.005914 1.398007 * PAN : 1895.909130 1915.416748 19.507619 1.028932 * PCO : 57.205164 56.868259 -0.336905 -0.588942 * PH2O2 : 36.473976 36.143736 -0.330240 -0.905413 * PHEN : 3.232731 3.265771 0.033040 1.022043 * PIO2 : 0.262273 0.262600 0.000327 0.124789 * PIP : 133.610031 134.174347 0.564316 0.422361 * PO2 : 0.261403 0.263836 0.002433 0.930877 * POx : 3941.161457 3984.321050 43.159594 1.095098 * PP : 30.410798 30.810948 0.400150 1.315815 * PPN : 368.228000 371.804036 3.576036 0.971147 * PRN1 : 0.653731 0.655818 0.002087 0.319245 * PROPNN : 14.801530 15.155874 0.354344 2.393966 * PRPE : 54.964718 55.770316 0.805598 1.465665 * PRPN : 2.577127 2.608929 0.031802 1.234001 * PSO4 : 3.769308 3.767952 -0.001356 -0.035984 * PYAC : 3.135175 3.219544 0.084370 2.691064 * R4N1 : 0.288355 0.290131 0.001776 0.615782 * R4N2 : 24.591785 24.980979 0.389194 1.582618 * R4O2 : 0.559162 0.570079 0.010918 1.952488 * R4P : 27.085145 27.523568 0.438423 1.618684 * RA3P : 13.326101 13.480926 0.154825 1.161816 * RB3P : 30.141941 30.566865 0.424925 1.409745 * RCHO : 76.806496 77.652837 0.846341 1.101914 * RCO3 : 0.205360 0.207416 0.002055 1.000911 * RCOOH : 1.30711338e-07 1.30711338e-07 0.000000 0.000000 RIPA : 78.736837 79.844190 1.107353 1.406398 * RIPB : 16.027622 16.271382 0.243760 1.520875 * RIPC : 2.358296 2.396340 0.038044 1.613189 * RIPD : 1.005156 1.020202 0.015046 1.496834 * ROH : 4.852933 4.986658 0.133725 2.755548 * RP : 50.221489 50.412129 0.190639 0.379597 * SALA : 308.739114 308.739114 -8.79595063e-10 -2.84899135e-10 * SALAAL : 1.967911 1.968770 0.000859 0.043651 * SALACL : 53.709116 53.753206 0.044090 0.082090 * SALC : 3479.164652 3479.164652 -1.26292434e-08 -3.62996429e-10 * SALCAL : 148.670853 149.641717 0.970865 0.653030 * SALCCL : 1813.936484 1813.990559 0.054075 0.002981 * SO2 : 313.667835 315.519060 1.851225 0.590186 * SO4 : 1584.746535 1582.719881 -2.026655 -0.127885 * SO4s : 0.535477 0.533314 -0.002163 -0.403976 * SOAGX : 61.068957 61.054069 -0.014888 -0.024379 * SOAIE : 196.719371 196.294279 -0.425091 -0.216090 * SOAP : 164.392720 164.392720 1.81330506e-11 1.10303246e-11 * SOAS : 1086.835150 1086.835150 0.000000 0.000000 TOLU : 41.019205 41.871812 0.852608 2.078557 * TRO2 : 0.057530 0.058768 0.001238 2.152336 * TSOA0 : 60.319047 60.439819 0.120772 0.200223 * TSOA1 : 22.169255 22.286396 0.117141 0.528393 * TSOA2 : 88.281458 88.453586 0.172128 0.194977 * TSOA3 : 37.814586 37.937408 0.122823 0.324802 * TSOG0 : 6.466362 6.481270 0.014908 0.230550 * TSOG1 : 11.210700 11.284094 0.073394 0.654677 * TSOG2 : 227.546207 228.029414 0.483207 0.212355 * TSOG3 : 508.536862 509.766315 1.229453 0.241763 * XRO2 : 0.043808 0.044515 0.000707 1.614347 * XYLE : 14.085589 14.357125 0.271536 1.927759 * pFe : 0.968900 0.968900 0.000000 0.000000